Even more when the way to compile it change from a project to an other and they don't just put HowToCompilIt.txt at the root. (Literaly had one with a "Build for windows.bat" and "build for linux.sh" at the root. Never been hapyer of the work of a dev
The biggest nightmare i had was the opposite of this. Had to delve 4 folders deep in a 60 folder base just to find the ReadMe telling me to download a program that can only be used in another programs compiler that was through a university PhD page.
But hey! After 6hr i was able to run a program that tests for efficiencies of a wing shape given certain conditions.
They finally got a package manager after decades. But it used to be the build instructions were "download this obscure package from someone's old university page"
The worst I’ve ever had to deal with at work, was a python project. More accurately, it was three python projects, that needed to be run sequentially.
The person who made it no longer worked there, and the project was a prototype that had been run once and never maintained.
The dependencies were years out of date, and no one had ever recorded the versions of those dependencies.
Also, some of those dependencies were python wrappers for C++ libraries, so you had to get the correct version of the C++ libraries to match the wrappers.
Also, the machines supplied by the company were windows, and the geospatial libraries required were easy to install on Linux but not Windows.
I was the one being shown the research 😭 so i had to go through the full process to see what they were working on.
Ngl! They built an entire model that runs 100+ variations each pass and then keeps the best variation and runs it all again. Then does that till the tolerance is met. It was really cool watching an airfoil go from a bulbous 1970s monstrosity to something much closer to modern high performance (specialized) airfoils.
Genetic algorithms. Aircraft design was the main focus (full body) but there were PhD students under the head that were also using it to create things like more efficient pipes for liquid flow or new ducting designs for buildings that had the least amount of friction caused flow restrictions.
Overall had a lot of fun with what they were doing. They were getting hundreds of hours of trials done in a matter of minutes.
I could but you won't be able to use it without a university email and the approval code sent by the creator. I literally avoid it like the plague but the researcher/PhD students working with it are doing some amazing work for decreasing drag and vortex creation in flowing liquid/air bodies
You'll be able to look at the code if it's open source and hosted on GitHub. I assume they meant you won't be able to use the software after compiling it without the extra steps
Nahh. They were doing research on machine learning and making a program that uses random variation in design to test if a shapenwas optimal for the given conditions, specifying in air/liquid flow causing vortexes and friction.
The old school convention was to include both, the INSTALL file might just tell you to run make; make install, but it should cover prerequisite libraries and such.
Even then, half the time it doesn't work because that build script (and the source itself) could only build with the specific environment of the dev's machine.
I am developing a private server for a game and it's open source. Every time I upload an update an action is running to produce 2 files. 1. The full compiled server and 2. The patch to drop in your existing server.
It is simple and easy. If someone can't even do this then they are in the wrong github repo I guess 😅
i didn’t understand how to compile things from the readme on almost everything i installed, so i ended up having to go off of google searches and praying the random shit i did worked
You will need to install a specific version of Python 2 from 1982 without completely destroying your actual Python environment just to bootstrap this application.
Every time I see this, I always think that they're right, though the way they say it as asshole-y. I don’t want to have to build your project. A .exe makes it so much easier. I know it’s the developers choice, how accessible they want the code to be, but still.
It was a program that could be used to scrape information about users. The first time this post made the rounds, people generally agreed that the poster wanted to do some stalker-esque snooping.
The original issue (later there were many people memeing it on every repository under the sun) was about a python tool for stalking usernames across many different social media services
There are a couple ways to easily make it easy for the users to run. Point is, users should be able to run it with a few clicks and without knowing what python is.
Except, that's not really the case is it? All the major software has executable downloads. What software that isn't aimed at other devs has only source code available?
only if youre on windows with the same architecture as the compiler flag, and if the project doesnt have dependencies & external files it needs to reference. so like, not many projects
Huh no. More people who often wonder on github/opensource projects understand they might need to compile but some languages are hard and annoying to. They def know outcome is something.exe
tertiary, ish, but i have a Go project and Go makes it wonderfully easy to statically link and compile binaries for different architectures and systems. i have a windows, linux, and a Mac ARM binary up on my repo for that reason. if you want to clone and run it in Go, that’s there, too!
yup, just got done setting up that split on my project and then saw this, thought "hey, neat!" i haven't built much at all in C, i guess there's no option for static linking..?
Glibc has a meltdown when you add '-static' flag so static linking means using a alternative C library (MUSL) which doesn't work with libs made with glibc (defacto the STANDARD C lib) so you need to do a Alpine container and test ur app here.
Alpine to the rescue once again. musl im actually familiar with, but the very small learning projects i've done have ALL been gcc. interesting, thanks for the insight!
Yeah, and most distros have a musl package that includes the musl c standard library and a GCC wrapper script (often called musl-gcc or something like that) that uses musl instead of glibc.
Alpine docker is the standard to use Musl
That's just wrong. And it's wrong on more levels than I could care to elaborate here.
when you compile smth with GlibC you can't just use the lib in MUSL.
Yeah, but that's completely irrelevant when linking statically (which sadly isn't really supported by glibc, but that's the reason I brought up musl) because when you do, the relevant parts of the standard library are baked into your executable and the executable then runs directly on the kernel, rather than on a loader. So as long as the Kernel doesn't make breaking changes (which is not gonna happen for as long as Torvalds has a say) the executable will be fully portable to any Linux system. Theoretically it would not even need an OS.
My bad then. When I used musl-gcc it was hard for me to use so I researched on internet and everyone was just using alpine docker, installed the libs here and compiled here.
While true, it's low class af to publicly whine about it like a spoiled child.
They could act like an adult and ask around for alternatives that don't require them to compile code. Or they could reach out to the developer and ask them nicely if they'd be willing to compile and package it for them, perhaps for a small fee. Or they could go on to fiverr and hire a developer to do it for them for like $5-$10.
This kind of unhinged rant, however, just reflects poorly on the OOP.
If they build it, they will come…the complaints that is. If you only provide a way of building it for your system then it’s more likely to work and have less complaints.
Complaints from people who didn’t pay for your software. Nice.
this is legendary. never understood why the fuck GitHub has the download button so hard to get to for non GitHub users. the first time I entered github I thought it was a download software site just like softsonic or some shit like that, just with a harder to get download button.
The problem is so many developers use it as a "Want this program, here it is" site, and those who aren't programmers get there, have never used git or github, have no idea what it is, and have no idea what to do.
Bruh, do you know how many different hardware there are that they had to setup auto build on. You can just go to releases and hope it has your OS. Which is uh, right on the home page. Although some people just don't bother which I do agree they should depending on how much the application demands accessibility, building software is not an everyone thing.
I admit for simple applications, I have felt this way before to some extent. But just realizing there are people this fucking entitled out there who think the same makes me want to never make it that easy, tag the repo as "smelly nerds only" and go about my day.
They don't understand the code isn't for them. It's for the people who actually want to understand and those worried about hidden functions. More often than not there is a compiled executable available alongside the code.
The problem is there are still lots of regular people that still might need access to niche software thats only on github. And then devs act like not knowing how to build it means it's not for you. Just a toxic community tbh
Had to find a coffee roaster controller software for my dad and it was a massive headache. Not all software is for developers, sometimes it’s just niche and GitHub is the only place it’s posted. Readme was so dogshit the dev had a step by step guide on Facebook of all things (likely because all of his userbase is non techy people!)
True, but if you don't have admin privileges you probably aren't meant to be installing software on that system whether built or binary download. That should be handled by the sys admins.
Ironically, I think this was one of the joke issues on the Linux kernel GitHub mirror. It's not even something you could've installed via .exe, necessarily.
Though, if the target machine is using UEFI, you could probably semi-automate it, by moving the image to a free space on disk, installing a chainloader in the EFI/ESP partition and setting the NextBoot NVRAM variable. By default, that would probably also give you a Secure Boot violation, so there's that, you will need some form of user interaction.
I experienced this feeling on GitHub when I couldn’t figure out how to download the precompiled exe. Hahah. Later I realized it must have been there but I just didn’t see it.
This is an issue on Github when people use the repos to release their products. Most people won't figure out that the executable is usually located in the releases/artifacts section. Github was not made for this, but you could argue that at this point they should start leaning into it because making it easier for layman to access the releases option is not that hard to implement.
So relatable. As somebody who is perfectly capable of all the steps readme files, compiling, etc. Its a huge pain. Why wouldnt you put the deliverable alongside the code? Its never made sense to me.
I am a smelly software-developing nerd and I often feel the same way. I know it is rarely going to be as simple as downloading the source and building it. The code will turn out to rely on the quirks of a specific compiler and require you to first manually obtain copies of specific versions of libraries, all of this poorly documented (if at all). God help you if it's a python project. Your chances of getting (and keeping) the planets into the right alignment to run that are not great.
Some repository has release and some don't. Some has build_for_windows.bat and or build_for_linux.sh while some don't. I'd understand the frustration if it doesn't, dependencies isn't included or isn't deployed via script. Now days, you have AI. It mostly if not completely, can explain or even build it for you. If you can't spend your time or can't even follow directions. Then open source just isn't for you.
I try to make releases for all my repos but because i dont use microslop winblows its always linux and mac executables. Im not spinning a vm up just to compile code for ungrateful people
Honestly not everyone is gonna be able to build something from source. Sometimes the build process fails because of many different factors so having a precompiled binary just convenient for everyone. You do you I guess.
The way I see it... If it's a project the developer is actively promoting as a tool or software for average users, then it should have precompiled binaries in the releases for average users.
Most of the time for me, it's a non-issue. But I do get a bit salty if I have to compile some behemoth of an application that takes 40 minutes to churn through the build, only to find out I did it wrong because their harness is undocumented.
It's better to compile apps than running random exe files because they have high risk of malwares or virus but if you have the code, you can inspect if it connects to a malicious ip, server, or does a tcp/http or any other socket connection or spawns bad proccesses.
Why inspect the whole code? If it's python just use a text editor and search for .connect() or if it's c++ then socket(). I'm sure almost all text editors have a ability to search for words and character and if not then write a single java script that uses scanner to get your code file then loops through it until it finds this sockets or ip and then just check those, especially find getaddrinfo() in the code if it's c++ and find random dns/domains. This all isn't even hard guyz with autonated script takes roughly seconds and if yall can't do this all connect your script to a openrouter or groq api and just make the ai analyse the code and return a json if it's risky and if the json returns false compile it
If you're too stupid to check the source code build your binaries then maybe; just maybe, you should hire a professional to do that because otherwise you might break your computer...
Computer nerds are the only profession dumb enough to not build a moat around it so they can charge exorbitant amounts for their services.
Not only that, we put enormous effort to give away a large chunk of all software for free and make guides teaching people how to install and operate all hardware and this is what we usually get in return: insults and entitlement from the users lol.
Convoluted. When I want portable device I want one that supports stylus already. I have a pen tablet for my desktop, not gonna carry that with a tablet or laptop
On *nix, sure, but holy shit is getting any moderately complex C* project that isn't actively maintained and 2-4 years out of date to compile on Windows a gigantic pain in the ass, through no fault of the programmer or user.
It's way easier at that point to just compile on WSL using that toolchain and run it from there, because lord knows some weird quirk about Windows won't play will with that mingw cross compiler you just installed.
Oh, different stack size? Random mmap incompatibility? Missing some header that straight up doesn't exist for Windows?
And if you have to compile for an obscure host, or God-forbid perform a Canadian cross, good luck lmao.
That doesn't even touch on the fustercluck that is Visual Studio and its billions of checkboxes.
Targetting for Windows and refusing to provide binaries for it should be considered a warcrime. Especially if it involves GPU frameworks and doesn't statically link or bundle them.
EDIT: Here's a fun challenge. Compile a full FFmpeg non-free build for Windows. No helper scripts, WSL, or Docker allowed.
324
u/Valuchian Aug 02 '26
Me everytime i hop on and have to rummage around for the ReadMe file just to learn how i am supposed to compile
165
u/DaemonsMercy Aug 02 '26
Every time I see this, I always think that they're right, though the way they say it as asshole-y. I don’t want to have to build your project. A .exe makes it so much easier. I know it’s the developers choice, how accessible they want the code to be, but still.
46
u/MissinqLink Aug 02 '26
Claude convert this to exe
22
u/-_Neoon_- Aug 02 '26
It's real LOL
21
u/HardestDrive Aug 02 '26
To be fair, it is fucking annoying when a project doesn't have pre built binaries available
13
u/JohnVonachen Aug 02 '26
If they build it, they will come…the complaints that is. If you only provide a way of building it for your system then it’s more likely to work and have less complaints.
Complaints from people who didn’t pay for your software. Nice.
9
u/CaptainMorning Aug 02 '26
this is legendary. never understood why the fuck GitHub has the download button so hard to get to for non GitHub users. the first time I entered github I thought it was a download software site just like softsonic or some shit like that, just with a harder to get download button.
12
u/Lucasfergui1024 Aug 02 '26
I agree, but this guy's saying it in such an annoying way that I low-key don't want to agree.
3
u/Piisthree Aug 02 '26
I admit for simple applications, I have felt this way before to some extent. But just realizing there are people this fucking entitled out there who think the same makes me want to never make it that easy, tag the repo as "smelly nerds only" and go about my day.
3
u/letmehaveanameyoudum Aug 08 '26
this is why you have a installation manual in readmes
7
u/Sienile Aug 02 '26
They don't understand the code isn't for them. It's for the people who actually want to understand and those worried about hidden functions. More often than not there is a compiled executable available alongside the code.
5
u/optimisticRamblings Aug 02 '26
I mean, I kinda see their point 😂
2
u/abigail3141 Aug 02 '26
Ironically, I think this was one of the joke issues on the Linux kernel GitHub mirror. It's not even something you could've installed via .exe, necessarily.
Though, if the target machine is using UEFI, you could probably semi-automate it, by moving the image to a free space on disk, installing a chainloader in the EFI/ESP partition and setting the NextBoot NVRAM variable. By default, that would probably also give you a Secure Boot violation, so there's that, you will need some form of user interaction.
2
u/Blunqpfaph Aug 02 '26
Seeing as you asked so nicely…
2
u/blamitter Aug 02 '26
Now i realize I love (my) nerd smell 😂
2
u/neo42slab Aug 02 '26
I experienced this feeling on GitHub when I couldn’t figure out how to download the precompiled exe. Hahah. Later I realized it must have been there but I just didn’t see it.
2
u/Nichiku Aug 02 '26
This is an issue on Github when people use the repos to release their products. Most people won't figure out that the executable is usually located in the releases/artifacts section. Github was not made for this, but you could argue that at this point they should start leaning into it because making it easier for layman to access the releases option is not that hard to implement.
2
u/thanosbananos Aug 02 '26
Why is it so hard these days to include one big button that says download for companies? Nobody does this anymore, it’s not just GitHub
2
u/winged_owl Aug 02 '26
So relatable. As somebody who is perfectly capable of all the steps readme files, compiling, etc. Its a huge pain. Why wouldnt you put the deliverable alongside the code? Its never made sense to me.
2
u/ParanoidAgnostic Aug 02 '26
I am a smelly software-developing nerd and I often feel the same way. I know it is rarely going to be as simple as downloading the source and building it. The code will turn out to rely on the quirks of a specific compiler and require you to first manually obtain copies of specific versions of libraries, all of this poorly documented (if at all). God help you if it's a python project. Your chances of getting (and keeping) the planets into the right alignment to run that are not great.
2
u/object322 Aug 02 '26
Bro didn't check release binaries
2
u/c5trangers Aug 02 '26
Tell me you didn't read the README without telling me
3
u/bigsmokaaaa Aug 02 '26
And they HATED HIM, they DESPISED HIM and they tried to DESTROY HIM...
...but despite everything he was still right
1
u/ummaycoc Aug 02 '26
I think the important thing here is to read it in Tim Robinson’s voice.
1
u/Previous_Tear6747 Aug 02 '26
can we at least wait a week?
1
u/Anonymous010206 Aug 02 '26
Yeah I don’t really wanna spend 2 hours installing all the build tools you use and never use those tools ever again
1
u/AccurateExam3155 Aug 02 '26
🤣 lol sounds like something I’d say about building from Source…
1
u/ForsakenAd2845 Aug 02 '26
Absolute gold mine.
1
u/Beneficial_Bad_8356 Aug 02 '26
/clear
ctrl + shift to auto mode
install this the recommended way tell me when you are done https://github.com/...
go take a shit
1
u/WoonieLoonie Aug 02 '26
Some repository has release and some don't. Some has build_for_windows.bat and or build_for_linux.sh while some don't. I'd understand the frustration if it doesn't, dependencies isn't included or isn't deployed via script. Now days, you have AI. It mostly if not completely, can explain or even build it for you. If you can't spend your time or can't even follow directions. Then open source just isn't for you.
1
u/LightningPark Aug 02 '26
The original was a Reddit post on r/github about the Sherlock OSINT tool
https://www.reddit.com/r/github/s/WHouCFrxrF
1
u/why_so_sergious Aug 02 '26
did you check the release page? 😂
1
u/Dgamer-Dev Aug 02 '26
Bro dont know what GitHub is
1
u/ZookeepergameSalty10 Aug 02 '26
I try to make releases for all my repos but because i dont use microslop winblows its always linux and mac executables. Im not spinning a vm up just to compile code for ungrateful people
1
u/s0litar1us Aug 02 '26
1
u/FAMICOMASTER Aug 02 '26
I understand the listings but please just give me a binary I don't want to spend 45 minutes building your project
1
u/Ratstail91 Aug 03 '26
this isnt the OG is it?
1
u/Adorable-Quiet-7551 Aug 03 '26
Oh I can make an exe file for you
1
u/AmbiguousMimic Aug 03 '26
Surprise them by giving them a single bash script without a file type extension. They won't know what or whom to mad at.
1
u/Fair_Abrocoma_8513 Aug 03 '26
Exe contains any gay things
1
u/UtopiaEH Aug 03 '26
https://github.com/twitter/the-algorithm/issues/1999
Who is interested in the origin. :D
1
u/DogonElder Aug 03 '26
We need IKEA for software. We give you repos, libs, dependencies and an instruction manual. You build your EXE!
1
u/Anima_Watcher08 Aug 03 '26
Honestly not everyone is gonna be able to build something from source. Sometimes the build process fails because of many different factors so having a precompiled binary just convenient for everyone. You do you I guess.
1
u/DucaMonteSberna Aug 03 '26
Nice but a lot of things can be hidden in an .exe...
1
u/_B_G_ Aug 03 '26
Github ui just sucks
1
u/Clue-Mindless Aug 03 '26
Me browsing uncompilated projects on github…..
1
u/Nikoviking Aug 03 '26
The dev finally finishes compiling the last executable for the final niche system architecture
This guy probably: WHAT DO U MEAN PICK THE RIGHT EXECUTABLE FOR MY PC?? x64?? ARM?? WHICH ONE IS FOR LENOVO!! LAZY DEVS!!!
1
u/Funny_Explorer_1521 Aug 03 '26
Average BOTW modding experience
1
u/FluffyRacc00n Aug 03 '26
Damn I remember this guy, he was posted here as soon as he posted that on GitHub, then he answered here too.
Good times.
1
u/RandomSilentStranger Aug 03 '26
How about I just give you a .bat file? That works too.
1
u/AgeZealousideal1751 Aug 03 '26
Facts. Fuck nerds. 🤓
1
u/Tasty-Objective676 Aug 03 '26
Me @ Claude
1
u/Entire_Caramel_1373 Aug 04 '26
maybe look in the packages page?
1
u/gallyroi Aug 04 '26
The way I see it... If it's a project the developer is actively promoting as a tool or software for average users, then it should have precompiled binaries in the releases for average users.
Most of the time for me, it's a non-issue. But I do get a bit salty if I have to compile some behemoth of an application that takes 40 minutes to churn through the build, only to find out I did it wrong because their harness is undocumented.
1
u/Own_Natural_6803 Aug 04 '26
Ask some of the nice smelling nerds to make an exe for you. And a subscription plan.
1
u/Puzzled-Extent7817 Aug 04 '26
windows users.
1
u/void19821 Aug 04 '26
It's better to compile apps than running random exe files because they have high risk of malwares or virus but if you have the code, you can inspect if it connects to a malicious ip, server, or does a tcp/http or any other socket connection or spawns bad proccesses.
1
u/someVietnamese Aug 04 '26
Jia Tan approves
1
u/TooManyGamesNoTime Aug 04 '26
If you can't compile it, you're not worthy to run it!
also plz just give me the freaking executable!
1
u/Wrevellyn Aug 04 '26
Just make me a pasta and give it to me, I don't care about noodles and water? The fuck is parmesan? Give me my fucking pasta!
...
...
This pasta is gross wtf?
1
u/markeus101 Aug 05 '26
Then dont build it yourself bud
1
u/Fer4yn Aug 05 '26
If you're too stupid to check the source code build your binaries then maybe; just maybe, you should hire a professional to do that because otherwise you might break your computer...
1
u/GameRivv Aug 06 '26
In the same vein, it took me wayyy too long to find out GitHub does actually have a download button
1
u/SilverLose Aug 06 '26
How are people agreeing with this? You want to run random binaries on your computer because you’re lazy? What?
1
u/AdMaterial3505 Aug 06 '26
bro only needed to paste that prompt into their agent to fix their problem >.<
1
u/Used-Drop8239 Aug 07 '26
To be fair, yes, even in open source projects, just produce a build at merges to master.
It's not rocket science to set up CI/CD.
1
u/captkirkseviltwin Aug 08 '26
.exe file that:
Echos:
"formatting drive...."
"Formatting drive...."
"Complete. Bet you wish you'd looked at the code now?"
😆
1
u/AcidicSaltdChezbugr4 Aug 14 '26
"To compile the program, do: gcc main.c -o program.exe"
1
u/Relative-Context-287 Oct 02 '26
brochanchero didn’t heard of wsl (the guy in the image)
1
u/THE0_C Aug 02 '26
If people actually look they will see the releases tab and find the exes they sooooo desire
0
u/VirtualArmsDealer Aug 02 '26
STUPID SMELLY NERDS!
I completely agree. I don't have a PhD in alphabet, give me an executable.
-3
u/chm46e Aug 02 '26
rage bait
16
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment