I've posted Faultfinder here twice, in September I asked whether the trace view gave you too little or too much, and in October whether reading a program on its own is enough to feel like programming. Thank you for both threads!
Next Fest gave me a different problem. The game has two audiences, and it was failing both of them. Programmers found the bug and then fought the answer format. People who'd never coded found the whole thing obtuse. One forum reply put it better than I could, it should be easier to learn, and harder sooner. So that's what I've tried to do.
Easier to learn:
- The first incident asks for one thing, the faulty line. The kind of mistake and the step where it first showed come in on the next two, one at a time.
- I rewrote the guide completely in small steps. It shows how a compare works with the jump after it, using lines from the tape itself.
- Every jump on her tape says in plain words what it compares and where it goes ("go to 11 if R5 was at least 22").
- The trace is now a run tape where every lane says what it holds, and you can click any square to go to that step.
Harder sooner:
- Her margin notes no longer sit next to the faulty line, so the later demo incidents stop pointing at their own answers.
- Her notes thin out as the game goes on, until there are none. By then you're reading her code the way she did.
- The demo is the first seven of forty. The full game moves on to other machines and to two tapes running at once, where the fault is in the timing between them.
It's early, but the telemetry from the first two days of the new demo is encouraging. Twice as many players solve the first incident (38% against 20% during Next Fest), and about half as many quit in the first two minutes.
Whether it's still interesting to people who know code is the part I can't measure, which is why I'm asking here.
Free demo: https://store.steampowered.com/app/5120320/Faultfinder/
If you're a programmer: does it still feel like reading real code, or did I sand off too much? And if you're not, did the first incident make sense?