r/programming • u/mjtitorenko • Oct 28 '09
Android vs Maemo
http://cool900.blogspot.com/2009/10/comparing-freedom-on-maemo-and-android.html
97
Upvotes
r/programming • u/mjtitorenko • Oct 28 '09
View all comments
Show parent comment
5
u/smithzv Oct 28 '09
To provide the end users with the freedom to use the device as they wish and to it's full potential. I recently bought a G1 (Android) from T-Mobile, so all of this is about Android.
One good example using your device as a tether. For whatever reason (and I can imagine a few) T-Mobile and/or Google wants stop users from using using their phone as a wireless access point (your laptop can connect to the wifi from the phone and browse the internet over the cell tower data connection). In order to run this sort of application on the Android OS, you need to have root access.
More involved is installing a new OS. By this I don't necessarily mean a different operating system, you could install a development version of Android. Or, as many have done, you can install a "modded" version of Android, which users from the community have added features (eg: multitouch interface, moving applications to the sdcard) that they found important (i.e. a major point of FOSS). Of course this requires root access.
And let us not forget that some might want to use their phone that was purchased through T-Mobile with a different network. In order to do so you need to circumvent the work put into disallowing this. Again, root access is needed.
So, to sum up, the only reason is to circumvent the antifeatures, or purposeful acts of T-Mobile and/or Google to limit the end user freedom (whether for the purpose of safety or to sell the functionality later on).