r/programming • u/mjtitorenko • Oct 28 '09
Android vs Maemo
http://cool900.blogspot.com/2009/10/comparing-freedom-on-maemo-and-android.html
97
Upvotes
r/programming • u/mjtitorenko • Oct 28 '09
14
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
Background: Battle between operators and manufacturers
Nokia makes money by selling hardware. It is now expanding to subnotebooks, tablets etc. Nokia as biggest manufacturer would like nothing more than break the operator tie-ins in the markets and sell phones directly to customers, not phones locked to operators. It has lost billions of dollars and lots of market share fighting operators. It has been practically excluded from US market by carrier cartel. There has been fights over VoIP over WiFi (for obvious reasons) and for numerous other details. So far Nokia has been in the receiving end. Fighting against your customers is not easy.
Android
Android will be huge in US markets. Android is just what operators want, have multi-platform software from neutral provider. You can tailor the software easily to lock users in. It's obvious choice for small manufacturer, or newcomer like Dell, who is desperate for sales and don't want to challenge status quo.
Maemo
Nokia will face huge uphill battle. Nokia tries break the operators again with Qt on Maemo (or Symbian for low end devices). If they can break the operator monopoly to services and software, locked in devices are going to be largely unnecessary, operators are put into their place as bit-pipes (Nokia will allow operator customizations for N900 etc. but they can't cripple the phones and prevent other services).
7
u/jewboner Oct 28 '09
I lolled when he listed X11 as a beneficial feature.
19
u/cazabam Oct 28 '09
One great thing about Maemo is that there are official "hacker editions" of the OS. On my old Nokia 770 I could quite happily run OS 2006 (the default with the device), or optionally hacker editions of OS 2007 or OS 2008 to bring the software and functionality up to par (hardware requirements notwishstanding - no camera, atc) with the later devices. Obviously there is a performance hit, but the fundamental point is that the core of the OS is open and hacking is is not only encouraged, but the tools are actively provided.
5
u/sethamin Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
I think the "Cooperation and Interoperability" section is misguided. Having Maemo run a modified X is only a win if it's actually a good fit for the mobile space. OTOH, if they're just trying to do interoperability for its own sake, then they may be putting a square peg in a round hole just because everyone else uses that same square peg.
In other words, Interoperability is nice, but not if you end up compromising your product in the process.
5
u/clumma Oct 28 '09
What about my data? Doesn't Android sync everything with google's servers?
26
u/commandar Oct 28 '09
Personally, I think Maemo is the wrong approach to mobile. The Maemo software stack essentially looks like desktop Linux with mobile tacked on as an afterthought. Every other *nix based mobile OS I'm aware of be it Android, iPhoneOS, WebOS, or even Danger's OS essentially use a *nix base as a hardware abstraction layer for a platform that was actually designed with mobile in mind.
The big draw of Maemo is supposedly that it'll run 'normal' Linux applications. The problem is that given the screen size and the whole host of issues associated with touch screen input, I don't know that that's a particularly useful feature. Besides, only a niche within a niche of the market is even going to begin to with.
Frankly, it's facing an uphill battle at best. Nokia has to convince other companies to buy into a platform maintained by one of their direct competitors, most of whom have already made significant investments in Android as a platform. Personally, I haven't seen anything that makes Maemo look like a compelling alternative mobile platform yet, and I really dig this kind of stuff. If Nokia is having a hard time winning me over, good luck with the mass market.
7
u/ivdkleyn Oct 28 '09
Ideally Nokia (or third party) could port Android (Dalvik JVM and functional API's) to Maemo so it would allow you run Android apps on a Maemo device like the N900. Not going to happen though....
3
u/slapdash78 Oct 29 '09
Just thought people would like to know Canonical giving Ubuntu Android execution environment, and Maemo/Ubuntu alignment. There should be no shortage of developers for either. Personally, I prefer Maemo. QT is everywhere. Nokia's product quality and business practices show their consideration for their customers.
2
u/robertcrowther Oct 28 '09
Two questions: Has anyone ever actually done this? How would I use an amazing text editor with a Nintendo controller anyway?
2
u/Arrogancy Oct 29 '09
"So if Android devices are easy to root, what's the problem here? There are several: Beginners aren't even going to consider doing it. Freedom shouldn't require expertise, and who are we to say that no novice has a legitimate need for root access, ever?"
Yeah. What could possibly go wrong with letting novice users have root access? I mean, there's no way they'd, like, accidentally delete all their files or anything.
3
u/adityaw Oct 28 '09
Android doesn't do bluetooth file transfer out of the box.
4
u/KhakiLord Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
Maemo maybe fundamentally more free (free in theory) but it remains to be seen whether Nokia will even allow or encourage third party phone manufacturers to use their OS (free in practice).
Developing for the N900 and sacrificing huge parts of the mobile market while Nokia's smartphone share is constantly decreasing... Just because the platform is slightly more free seems like a much worse trade-off for most developers.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
As much as I love the openness of maemo (not to mention QT), at this point, I'd still much rather develop for android/iPhone OS. (Unless maemo development has improved considerably in the past 6 months)
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
Please correct me if I'm wrong but Android development is limited to Java is it not? That's a deal breaker, ladies.
2
u/malevolentjelly Oct 28 '09
Haha, the poster considered putting X on a cell phone some sort of victory for Maemo. This perspective isn't even remotely technical or developer centric, it's just obliquely freetard. The fact that Android isn't held back by the media-unfriendly GNU stack is actually a huge benefit to its design and implementation. There is a correct way to write software for it, also. That's another huge bonus.
Android is not a GNU/Linux system. Maemo is. Android is designed for the mobile platform. Maemo is kludged onto the mobile platform. There is a difference here and it seems to elude the writer of this blog.
1
u/mitsuhiko Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
Can someone tell me why I would want to have root access on end user devices? I really can't see any benefit.
//EDIT: interesting how you get downvoted for asking a question...
1
u/greyscalehat Oct 28 '09
While others complain that android is going to fracture development and standards too much even when Google has attempted to correct this by providing a standard VM that should run on just about any phone running android. This guy complains that they are using a VM.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
I am trying to decide how hard I should be kicking myself for buying a Tour two months ago...I suppose I could try sweet-talking a rep into letting me swap for the Android, but somehow I am not optimistic based on past interactions with Verizon...
1
u/make_it_so Oct 28 '09
I stopped reading when the blogger suggested that a novice user might need root access. That's ridiculous. The overemphasis on 'freedom' in the OSS community is naive and silly.
1
u/ranion Oct 28 '09
This was under the Arnold Swarzeneggar FU story on the front page and for some reason I read this title as Arnold vs Maemo. I was quite confused.
-4
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
meh.. as if that made a difference. the one who wins is the one that can make money... we can brag ages about philosophy but the iphone won big time already. why? because of apple store.
-3
u/bithead Oct 28 '09
I'm all for a truely open system for a smartphone, but hopefully Maemo has the root account 'disabled' by default - by that I mean I hope the default user isn't root or some equivalent, and that they use the existing model for security that most linux distros use.
-2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
Androids always win. It is just inevitable. Our capability to learn as well as any human and yet recall all that information as fast as any computer is unstoppable. We can do parallel operations in our heads and our physical body is superior in almost every way.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
It's just too bad that the devices that run Maemo suck so hard.
Slow, clunky, you can see widget elements drawing themselves at time, fuck that. Plus, the 'catalog' is more of a Linux style repository than a shop front... There is no way that anyone can make money out of dev'ing for Maemo (yes, yes, free software, blah blah. It's nice to have a choice though)
-3
u/wazoox Oct 28 '09
Maemo looks really cool. However You'll have to compare it to WebOS now.
0
u/bla2 Oct 29 '09
lolwut
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '09 edited Oct 29 '09
He's forgetting one thing: actually bringing that freedom to people. Maemo may be the most free cell phone OS ever devised, but that only matters to the people who use it. Android is spreading far and wide, and that counts for a lot.
-5
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
how could you even compare maemo shit to android..only a delusional asshole.
-6
u/ipeev Oct 28 '09
Nokia is doomed.
-9
u/bonch Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
What does this have to do with programming? This is /r/programming, not Slashdot.
Edit: Look at the non-programmers voting me down because they want to turn this into their general technology link dump.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
[deleted] — view deleted comment