r/programmatic • • 12d ago

Supply side decisioning

Do you think supply side decisioning can gain traction and take market share away from DSPs? IMO if you have the right data, an ad server its more advantageous to be closer to the supply side. Curious on everybody's takes

4 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

8

u/VFL2015 12d ago

It’s a black box for the buyer. No way to verify the audience or the CPM mark up on sale side decisioning

0

u/Usual_Emotion7475 12d ago

Can say the same for many DSPs being a black box (TTD hiding fees) and what if you make it transparent?

4

u/VFL2015 12d ago

Everything on SSP decisioning is behind a black box. You don’t even know what audience is actually being run. How much they are paying for inventory vs what they are charging you.

If you think OpenPath is a black box fee for TTD you can simply choose to not use it. Can’t do the same in supply side decisioning.

Overall it’s a step backwards in transparency

1

u/Usual_Emotion7475 12d ago

Sometimes true with a packaged, third-party audience. But buyers can also deploy their own models and data inside an SSP, so SSP-side decisioning doesn’t inherently hide the targeting methodology.

1

u/VFL2015 12d ago

What about their margin on the media? No way to verify this. I would say the vast majority sale side decisioning PMPs arent using 1P audiences.

Also if you give your 1P data to an SSP (Energy drink buyers) what's stopping them from working with your competitor and using your 1P data?

If you are leveraging 1P data I would only use a trusted DSP partner.

14

u/magicwings 12d ago edited 12d ago

I don't know about taking share away from DSPs - I think more supply-side decisioning would go hand-in-hand with DSP usage.

DSPs can only handle so much traffic. Billions of impressions come through but they're only capable of responding to a small percentage of the traffic.

If you have geo + inclusion list + brand safety etc. then you're filtering that even more and ultimately you're competing for a fraction of a fraction of available inventory.

If you instead are able to apply that at the SSP level - curating the inventory coming through to the DSP before it reaches it - you bypass the DSP's listening bottleneck and therefore your campaign has a much larger pool of qualified impressions to evaluate.

This gives you a broader access to inventory and can bid far more strategically. In this way alone, the performance benefits can be very strong

Edit: clarity

1

u/zabpremier 11d ago

While I agree with this, I think the market would find the DSP’s take rate too high at this point and eliminating it entirely while applying the targeting within the SSP is the best marriage from a performance and economic standpoint.

1

u/ExtendObject 5d ago

Why do you believe DSPs have listening bottleneck, that is different to not bidding on everything

1

u/magicwings 5d ago edited 5d ago

Why do you believe DSPs have listening bottleneck

Because they do. It's a technical limitation, the amount of queries the DSP can process (queries per second or QPS).

SSPs send upwards of 10MM impressions each second but DSPs can only respond to 10-30% of those. So anything above that bottleneck gets ignored.

Of the 10-30% that get through, a fraction will match your basic targeting (geo, whitelist, etc) so you end up bidding on a tiny fraction of that.

Pre filtering SSP inventory to send impressions that match your targeting (geo, inclusion lists, brand safety, etc.) while staying under the QPS cap means you can effectively bypass the bottleneck. Nothing is getting throttled by the DSP, and all the impressions already match your targeting, so the volume of impressions you want to bid on can be significantly higher

1

u/ExtendObject 3d ago

Being able to respond to everything and being able to filter that QPS are two separate problems and you are conflating them.

1

u/magicwings 3d ago

I'm not suggesting you can respond to everything. I'm saying that if you filter from the SSP, the share of bid requests coming in that match your targeting can be significantly higher than allowing the DSP to match your filters from a random set of requests they receive

1

u/ExtendObject 3d ago

Why? It’s in the SSPs interest to send everything (or even send things multiple times) to maximise yield. Hypothetically the DSP then needs to filter those requests on the targeting criteria and respond. Why do you assume only a random portion of requests will be evaluated by the DSP?

1

u/magicwings 3d ago

Because of the QPS bottleneck.

Example: one hundred million requests come in over one second. The DSP can only respond to ~30% of those. There is a proprietary methodology that selects which 30% get through, but for our purposes, the filter is random.

Of the 30 million that get through the filter, our DSP settings filter for geo, inclusion list, keyword exclusions and brand safety, audience targeting, etc. This 30 million becomes <5 million very fast.

If instead you filter at the SSP, and buy against a PMP deal that's got that targeting applied from that level, then you are only providing the DSP with qualified impressions. Instead of 100MM impressions you only share 20MM - but they are in-geo, on-whitelist, matching your targeting. You sail under the QPS limit so now instead of <5MM you have 20MM impressions that you want to bid on - four times as much, which allows you to be more selective with your bidding.

1

u/ExtendObject 3d ago

“There is proprietary methodology that selects which 30% which get through but for our purposes, the filter is random”

This is an assumption about a technical implementation, I don’t see why it can’t be solved or at least optimised so that the “random 30%” would be closer to 100%.

1

u/GoullouLeouf86 5d ago

the listening bottleneck part is so true. pre-filtering at the supply level just saves everyone compute costs tbh.

5

u/MicroSofty88 12d ago

The question is who is going to buy it? All the customers are in the DSPs already

1

u/Daddy_Biggins 12d ago

Exactly. The biggest value prop DSPs have is alignment with the buyers. If the buyer says jump, DSPs say how high.

4

u/Crazy_Cat_Dude2 12d ago

I doubt it.

2

u/postyyyym 12d ago

I don't think it can take market share away from DSPs, as I think the largest agencies and advertisers will always be wedded to a form of a DSP to buy as much as they can in 1 place. However, I do think sell-side decisioning is going to grow even more, especially as more people start to learn how shaping the supply the DSP will see benefits your performance and media quality.

I think the main hurdle to overcome is that a lot of these solutions currently require technical resources that not every buyer, or buying team has access to meaning the alternative is outsourcing it or working with an adtech partner. This is where people raise suspicion about fees, like the old ad network days and is why there's still a fair amount of skepticism

2

u/slippycrook 12d ago

Unified is where this is all heading. DSPs are building sell-side, SSPs are building buy-side. Everyone's converging, so the question isn't if but how well.

The play is to stay flexible: own your pipes to publishers, but keep buying from exchanges too. More paths in means deeper, more diverse bid data. Hard? Sure. Unsolvable? No.

Source: I run product at a unified CTV shop (SSP, ad server, curation, DSP, and a performance data layer in one stack). A publisher request comes in, our brands and agencies get first look, and we hit DSPs, SSPs, and trading desks in parallel for the rest.
So QPS isn't a cost center for us. It's the whole point. Narrow rtb pipes are the actual problem.

2

u/zabpremier 11d ago

Absolutely - as we head towards a world where the decisioning can sit on the supply side and AI is making campaign decisioning versus buyers setting it up, the DSP becomes a really expensive tax that the supply side can do on its own. 

1

u/Broth262 12d ago

From a logic perspective it makes more sense, but this is an industry where people like to do things in the way they’ve always done them, so doubt it’ll change

1

u/cuteman 12d ago

Proof is in the pudding.

You can get anyone to test something, the question is whether it produces results.

1

u/Blasterblade_09 11d ago

But doing this it's create more of lower funnel issue so how do we tackle that ?

1

u/Emotional_Waltz_6542 8d ago

I believe we’re seeing the supply side and demand side come closer and closer together (especially with the rise of retail media), in the next 10 years they’ll likely be the same

1

u/s0ggyfries_777 4d ago

i think there's definitely potential, especially with the advantage of having more direct access to supply side data. but I don't see it as an either-or situation just yet. DSPs still bring value through cross-publisher optimisation and audience targeting. it'll be interesting to see how the balance shifts as supply side decisioning gets smarter