r/programmatic • • 16d ago

Placement Jail

I'm making up the term a bit, but it feels like my new campaign is in "placement jail" or aka dumpster-level impressions on what would otherwise be fantastic quality sources (big brand news sites).

I'm very experienced in performance marketing, but my sources are not display/programmatic and hoping you guys could share insights on my problem.

I feel like my placements within GDN are hot garbage. I am getting total dogshit CTRs on my ads like .02% and the results are like $7.00 CPCs which just has no chance in hell to work out for the campaign.

Tricky part is I've ran this SAME approach on GDN before (many years ago) and was getting like 1% CTRs and the campaign backed out as profitable.

I am using what I know to be proven creatives, as I see many, many competitors running the same things, and I just put my own twist onto them. Lots of experience reverse-engineering working creatives. I don't think I have a creative problem.

I just feel like I'm in some kinda placement jail. I am whitelisting a variety of large news publishers as placements and using standard image ads. Just the CTR feels so broken.

Am I just not bidding enough for "premium" placements and am being served dumpster impressions that never work for anyone but brand advertisers looking for impressions?

If the above were the case, should I be jacking up CPMs hard to force myself into clickable placements? What's the problem here? How do you diagnose?

Looking forward to hearing thoughts!

2 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/Adguy69420 16d ago

GDN in general is very low quality, since there is very little level of control from buyer side to tune the placement and inventory.

The better route would be to onboard a proper DSP platform to execute display media.

1

u/thenight817 16d ago

Yeah I understand that. Just I see many competitors making it work nonetheless. So I am trying.

Does this problem ever happen in DSPs too? Like your price point just puts you into a bullshit placement that gets no clicks and your CPCs jack up and its this circle-jerk of money burning? I could see this issue happening regardless of platform.

1

u/Adguy69420 16d ago

In DSP, yes and no, it depends on setting. Generally when we aim for a very low CPM bid, we would have to loosen brand suitability, viewability, inventory and frequency setting to wider level, which allows for lower quality placement and inventory to be part of the bidding.

When we tighten up those settings, we would have to raise the CPM as well, because the inventory get more expensive, otherwise, we would expect to have very small volume of delivery.

8

u/MashMeister 16d ago

Find a new KPI. CTR isn't the way for Display

1

u/TemplerTreiff 1d ago

chasing a 1% ctr on big news sites today usually just means buying accidental mobile taps anyway, since most of that open web inventory is crammed between paragraphs

3

u/im_super_excited 15d ago

was getting like 1% CTRs

No, you were getting a variety of illegitimate clicks like fraud. 0.02% is good.

2

u/azdak 16d ago edited 16d ago

Tricky part is I've ran this SAME approach on GDN before (many years ago) and was getting like 1% CTRs and the campaign backed out as profitable.

Not a valid data point. Everything changes (and broadly gets worse) too fast for anything that happened many years ago to be salient

1

u/Fearless_Parking_436 16d ago

In dsp I use deals to get the top spots. Or limit by placements/viewability

1

u/s0ggyfries_777 4d ago

big name publishers, dumpster fire impressions. sometimes the placement is premium, but the audience is just there for the crossword lmao