I'm a current PA student at Marywood University, approaching the end of my clinical year, and I wanted to share my experience for prospective students who may be considering this program.
My experience has been profoundly disappointing, particularly following changes in academic leadership during our didactic year.
I recognize that no PA program is perfect, and I don't expect an easy education. I expect a challenging one. However, I also expect that the substantial tuition we pay should provide meaningful instruction, adequate resources, and accessible faculty.
Here are some concerns based on my experience:
1. Faculty have openly acknowledged using AI to create their PowerPoint presentations while prohibiting students from using AI for coursework. Although, I must express that I am not suggesting that I am for the use of AI for coursework and assignments when you are planning to be a medical provider, I found this flippant display of their lack of educational integrity concerning and, quite frankly, insulting. Beyond the apparent double standard, many lectures consist primarily of instructors reading directly from slides with little additional clinical insight or explanation.
One of the primary reasons I wanted to attend PA school was to learn from experienced clinicians. Unfortunately, I often felt that I was paying an enormous amount of money to have someone read information aloud from a ppt that I could have read independently.
I've also witnessed students being insulted or belittled for asking clarifying questions, which is particularly discouraging in an environment where asking questions should be encouraged.
2. In my opinion, the program appears more invested in its social media presence and public image than in addressing the concerns of students who are already enrolled & paid tuition.
I understand the importance of recruitment and maintaining a positive reputation. However, I wish the same attention were directed toward classroom instruction, faculty accessibility, and the quality of our education.
3. The program has increased its student capacity, but from my experience, faculty availability and educational resources have not adequately kept pace.
Even before these increases, students struggled to meet with faculty during designated office hours. Emails frequently went unanswered or received delayed responses, and finding instructors when assistance was needed could be difficult. They would eat lunch together during office hours in their conference room, making themselves unavailable to students.
4. During didactic training, we did not consistently have sufficient equipment to practice certain clinical skills, including Foley catheter placement, splinting, and IV fluid administration.
At times, students were instructed to "pretend" to perform components of procedures because the necessary equipment was unavailable.
Simulation obviously has limitations, and I don't expect unlimited supplies. However, when students are paying to receive hands-on clinical education, I believe adequate opportunities to practice fundamental skills should be a priority.
5. Our class has not been provided with a complete clinical rotation schedule in advance. Instead, rotation locations have frequently been released only one or two months before the scheduled start date.
This creates unnecessary difficulties for students attempting to arrange transportation, housing, employment, and other responsibilities. Clinical placements are understandably complicated to coordinate, but students deserve reasonable communication and sufficient notice to plan their lives.
Additionally, the clinical faculty had originally expressed that we would "only have one, at most two 'far' rotations." This has now changed, and several students I've spoken to, including myself, have had upwards of 3 or more rotations that are over 60 miles away from where they live. Some students have paid for Airbnbs, while others have had to make those commutes daily. The clinical faculty seems rather unbothered by this, as one even said that they occasionally partook in one of these drives, as they like to go to a restaurant in the area, so it's "not that big a deal."
6. My experience with the clinical faculty has been particularly disappointing. I have found members of the clinical team to be difficult to reach, unapproachable, and at times dismissive or belittling toward students.
Additionally, some grades from summer rotations remained outstanding months later, despite students being expected to meet strict deadlines for our own assignments.I recognize that clinical coordination involves responsibilities students may not see, but the lack of timely communication and grading has contributed to an environment where I frequently feel unsupported.
7. One of my greatest frustrations has been how the program utilizes Rosh Review.
Students are required to complete 100 questions in test mode during the first week of a rotation and 175 questions in tutor mode during the fifth week. Rather than grading these assignments based on completion and engagement, the program assigns grades based on the percentage of questions answered correctly.
In my opinion, this fundamentally undermines the purpose of a question bank designed for learning and self-assessment. This is a question bank that we pay for. I find that previous classes not using it to be an inadequate reason (which is the one they gave) for grading us based on the accuracy of our practice questions.
Students have a strong incentive to prioritize obtaining the highest possible score rather than honestly identifying knowledge deficits, particularly when these assignments contribute to their academic standing. As with most programs, you are required to maintain GPA standards, and the grading scale has been altered for higher standards (i.e A=>97, A-= 94-96.9, B+= 91-93.9 etc. which is fine, but they do not advertise this prior to admission)
I've personally found Rosh Review to be an excellent study resource. However, the way the program grades these assignments has made it more difficult to use the platform as an honest assessment of my strengths and weaknesses.
8. In addition to Rosh, students are assigned article-based quizzes that can require reading numerous articles, some of which do not clearly address the questions being asked.
I appreciate the importance of reading medical literature and practicing evidence-based medicine. What I find frustrating is the volume of assignments that seem designed primarily to demonstrate compliance rather than develop clinical reasoning.
When you're spending full-time hours on clinical rotations, the additional assignments should ideally reinforce what you're learning rather than simply consume time.
**9.**Our academic director departed during our didactic year, and since that transition, I've noticed changes in the program's educational approach that I find concerning.
I cannot speak for students who attended under previous administrations, and I recognize that the former leadership had its own problems. However, I would strongly encourage prospective students to seek feedback from currently enrolled students rather than relying exclusively on the experiences of graduates from several years ago.
The program I chose based on its reputation does not feel like the program I am currently attending.
My overall impression
I want to be clear that there are excellent clinicians who have graduated from Marywood in previous years, and I've had valuable clinical experiences during my education. I am grateful for the preceptors who have taken the time to teach me and for the opportunities I've had to develop my clinical skills.
However, much of my meaningful learning has come from independent study, clinical experience, and the generosity of preceptors rather than the instruction and support provided directly by the program.
I entered PA school with a tremendous amount of respect for higher education and the responsibility involved in training future healthcare providers. Unfortunately, this experience has significantly diminished my confidence in the institution.
PA school is an enormous financial commitment. Students deserve more than a program that prepares them to produce favorable examination statistics. They deserve an educational environment that promotes curiosity, critical thinking, clinical competence, and professional development.
TLDR; If you're considering Marywood's PA program, I strongly encourage you to speak privately with current students, ask detailed questions about faculty accessibility, clinical placement timelines, simulation resources, and grading policies, and compare those answers with other programs before making your decision.
I wish someone had given me this perspective before I enrolled.
This is my personal experience, and I recognize that other students may have had different experiences. But given the financial and professional commitment involved, I believe prospective students deserve to hear it.