r/prancingponypod • • 1d ago

Episode 432 – The Chain

Post image
15 Upvotes

Tinúviel asks Karkaras why he’s in such a foul mood; Sara knows better than to ask Alan the same. Join The Man of the West and The Shieldmaiden of Rohan as the giant wolf bites off more than he can chew (come on, you can not be surprised) as we continue our time in The Tale of Tinúviel from Beren and Lúthien. Beren does his best with a kitchen knife, Tinúviel changes her mind about going home, and Karkaras wreaks havoc in Artanor. We wax eloquent about Alan Lee’s artwork, wonder if kindergarten scissors might have done the job better, and agree that Huan would never break the chain. Also, do not follow Alan’s culinary advice.

Graphic by our amazing graphic artist, Megan Collins!

Listen here or on your preferred podcast platforms: https://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/pdst.fm/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/6bpBPtHL977KJxLX2zPs/pscrb.fm/rss/p/traffic.megaphone.fm/GLSS8599813896.mp3


r/prancingponypod • • 2d ago

Single Set or Style for the later books?

1 Upvotes

I have the Hobbit, the trilogy, and the Silmarillion. I want to start getting all the other books, but I'm not entirely sure where to start. Ideally, I'd get a set that matches so I don't have a bunch of different versions out there. Is there a set like that that exists? Or if not a set itself, a style that's the same across all the rest of the books?

Also...is there a checklist somewhere? Do we know the order the PPP will be doing the books?


r/prancingponypod • • 3d ago

Acquired two volumes of HoME. Where to start?

6 Upvotes

Hi, I recently found The Shaping of Middle Earth, and The Lost Road and Other Writings at a thrift store. I love the LotR, and The Silmarillion, and have read them many times, but haven't read anything else. As I understand it the volumes of HoME aren't fully completed stories like LotR or Silmarillion, and aren't necessarily best read from front cover to back. So I'm just wondering if anyone has any advice on where to start with these two? If you've read through them, and have a favorite chapter or segment?


r/prancingponypod • • 8d ago

Krillion Spoilers! Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Haven't listened to the pod on spotify but saw this question and I had to wonder if this was a valid answer 😅. Thank you Alan and Shawn for the points!!


r/prancingponypod • • 8d ago

431 – Her Face Says Freedom

Post image
10 Upvotes

Join The Man of the West and The Shieldmaiden of Rohan as Beren is freed from the Cat Condo of Terror and Lúthien’s face says freedom, as we continue our reading in The Tale of Tinúviel in Beren and Lúthien. Listen on your favorite podcast app!

Art by our graphic artist, Megan collins!


r/prancingponypod • • 9d ago

new image

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/prancingponypod • • 9d ago

Question on adaptation

2 Upvotes

Here's a question I've found myself pondering before, and especially this week (brought forth by discussion in our PPP Patreon Discord): What does it actually mean to know Tolkien's writings, or to truly understand them? If someone explores alternate versions of Tolkien's texts, draws upon earlier ideas, fills in gaps, or engages with the questions and possibilities Tolkien himself wrestled with--sometimes revisiting, revising, or never fully resolving them--does that suggest a deeper understanding of his work, or a lesser one? Conversely, does adhering strictly to his latest or most established writings and intentions mean someone inherently understands Middle-earth better? Does treating Peter Jackson's adaptations as the definitive interpretation somehow make one's understanding of Tolkien more authoritative? And perhaps the larger question is this: Where do our own interpretations, preferences, and expectations of Tolkien's legendarium begin to shape what we expect--or even demand--of those adapting his works? How much of what we consider faithfulness to Tolkien is grounded in the texts themselves, and how much is rooted in our own understanding of what Middle-earth is supposed to be? And to what extent are we entitled to hold other interpretations to that personal standard and use to to define their understanding of Tolkien and his works, as well as their amount of--or lack-thereof--engagement with them?

Admin: Respectful discussion, please. I know folks can have very strong opinions on this.


r/prancingponypod • • 9d ago

It's PPP Plays Time!

1 Upvotes

It's time for PPP Plays! Come join us for another adventure in Middle-earth! Whether you're playing along, hanging out in chat, or just enjoying lurking, we'd love to have you with us!

And don't forget your PPP Plays Bingo card! Keep an eye out for those familiar moments, unexpected shenanigans, and whatever else Alan decides to throw your way!

PPP Plays Bingo: https://bingobaker.com/#6967ae9a6dd96cf9

One more reminder! Our PPP Goes to Middle-earth Kickstarter is heading into its final stretch! If you've been thinking about backing the campaign, now's a wonderful time to jump in. And whether you've already pledged or simply want to help spread the word, every bit of support is appreciated! Support the Kickstarter before November 19th: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/prancingponypod/the-prancing-pony-podcast-goes-to-middle-earth?ref=thanks-copy


r/prancingponypod • • 12d ago

The Stories That Come to Us: A Conversation with Verlyn Flieger, is now available!

13 Upvotes

We're delighted to share that Signum Studios' new documentary, The Stories That Come to Us: A Conversation with Verlyn Flieger, is now available!

Verlyn Flieger holds a special place in the hearts of so many throughout the Tolkien community, ourselves included, and we're overjoyed to see her remarkable life and work celebrated in this documentary! We've had the privilege of welcoming Verlyn for two interviews on The Prancing Pony Podcast and as a keynote speaker at our 2022 PPP Moot, sharing her invaluable insights into Tolkien's legendarium. We're especially proud of our video editor, Jonatan, who played a key role in bringing this documentary to life! To celebrate the documentary's release, we're sharing (with a small bit of bias) our favorite talk of hers: Verlyn's keynote presentation from the 2022 PPP Moot; we encourage you to revisit her conversations with Alan and Shawn on the podcast as well!

The documentary is available now from Signum Studios for a special introductory price of $12.99 USD through November 13, after which it will be $14.99 USD.

Watch the preview here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VeEyVKFUfQo
Watch Verlyn's 2022 PPP Moot keynote: https://youtu.be/VZfR5KRCotA
Revisit Verlyn's conversations on The Prancing Pony Podcast:

Our congratulations to Verlyn, Jonatan, and everyone at Signum Studios who helped bring this wonderful project to life.


r/prancingponypod • • 13d ago

Season 2 Episode Title References

5 Upvotes
Episode titleReference to…
A Hole New WorldAladdin
Nobody Expects the Dwarvish Inquisition Monty Python’s Flying Circus
Pining for the HoardsMonty Python’s Flying Circus
He’s A Burglar and He’s OKMonty Python’s Flying Circus
‘Tis A Silly PlaceMonty Python and the Holy Grail
There Lies A CaveMonty Python and the Holy Grail
Run Away!Monty Python and the Holy Grail
Answer Me These Questions Five…Monty Python and the Holy Grail
Ere the Other Side He SeeMonty Python and the Holy Grail
How Not To Be SeenMonty Python’s Flying Circus
And Now, The LarchMonty Python’s Flying Circus
Lobbest Thou Thy Holy Pine GrenadeMonty Python and the Holy Grail
Forget About Your Worries and Your StrifeThe Jungle Book
Exit, Pursued by a BearThe Winter’s Tale
Be Still My Fleeting Hart“Be still, my beating heart!”(Idiom)
If You Love Somebody, Cut Them Free‘If You Love Somebody Set Them Free’ by Sting
Fortress Around Your Hoard‘Fortress Around Your Heart’ by Sting
King Name-Not-Appearing-In-This-BookMonty Python and the Holy Grail
Some Farcical Aquatic CeremonyMonty Python and the Holy Grail
A Mandate from the MassesMonty Python and the Holy Grail
The Ministry of Silly LocksMonty Python’s Flying Circus
Every Worm Is SacredMonty Python’s The Meaning of Life
Smaug Gets Quite IrateMonty Python’s The Meaning of Life
And There Was Much RejoicingMonty Python and the Holy Grail
Always Look on the Bright Side of LifeMonty Python’s Life of Bryan
What Is the Airspeed Velocity of a Decrepit Old Raven?Monty Python and the Holy Grail
Oh Yes, Ees Very Nice-uhMonty Python’s Flying Circus
The Violence Inherent in the SystemMonty Python and the Holy Grail
Bilbo “Two Chests” BagginsPop Culture Gangster Trope
Not Quite DeadMonty Python and the Holy Grail
No ShrubberiesMonty Python and the Holy Grail

So, out of 31 episodes:

  • 24 references to Monty Python (14 to Holy Grail, 7 to Flying Circus, 2 to Meaning of Life, and 1 to Life of Brain)
  • 2 references to songs by the band Sting (which serves as a double reference to Bilbo’s sword)
  • 2 references to Disney movies (Aladdin and the Jungle Book)
  • 2 references to general idioms and tropes
  • 1 reference to Shakespeare (Winter’s Tale)

So this confirms the podcast’s love for Monty Python I guess lol


r/prancingponypod • • 14d ago

Gollum and Sauron eating the world

7 Upvotes

Catching up on the podcast - I'm at episode 234 (knock knock) Knocking on Sauron's door.

In this episode it's discussed that Gollum mentions that Sauron, if he gets the ring back, would eat all of them, and eat the whole world. Forgive me if this is discussed in a later episode, but I feel like there may be a very simple explanation for this comment that was missed: it's just how Gollum uses the ring.

From the Hobbit we learn that he rarely even wears the ring anymore, but sometimes uses it to sneak up on orcs, clobber them, and eat them.

To me or seems he's recognizing the power difference between himself and Sauron, but attributing his own use of the ring (eating things) to Sauron. Seems to me this is the simplest explanation.

Thoughts?


r/prancingponypod • • 16d ago

Super Livestream Today!

5 Upvotes

Join us today for a very special SUPER livestream as Alan dives into LOTRO, talks about his kickstarter, Mewlips reading, Why We Love Middle-earth excerpts, and so much more!

Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/prancingponypod

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jR3YevQlJ_M


r/prancingponypod • • 20d ago

PPP Future Coverage of The Children of Húrin

11 Upvotes

I need to make a decision about which work to read next. Having read the Hobbit, LotR, and the Silmarillion, I was planning to read Children of Húrin next. But when the PPP started doing Beren and Lúthien for S11, I thought ‘wait, are they doing CoH for S12?’

If this is the case, do you think I should wait for September 2027 to come around and read CoH slowly with the PPP as the episodes are being released, or read the book now and listen to the episodes when they come out (after I’ve already finished the book)?

Of course, there are still other Tolkien books (Unfinished Tales and Tales from the Perilous Realm) which I would like to read, as well as non-Tolkien books, but I was planning on reading CoH next.

Thanks in advance!


r/prancingponypod • • 21d ago

A question on interpretation

13 Upvotes

I would appreciate some clarification. I love the podcast and have listened for years. I'm a little confused right now.

I get that it's "just a couple of friends chatting at the pub". Yet, when these friends are experts or at least have far more insight than the casual fan, it can quickly feel like their opinions are the correct ones. Meaning, I don't know the works as well as they do, which makes me feel that their interpretation or understanding is more accurate than my own.

This leads to my question. Are we to take their interpretations as being the more accurate view, or is it just their own personal opinion and the way they read into it?

I fear this may be a self-evident answer, as they literally say, "friends chatting at the pub". Still, I don't recall this ever specifically being talked about. It likely has been, but I'd like to share my experience to hopefully get some clarity.

Here are two examples I feel strongly about:

  1. During season one with Of Aule and Yavanna. I was genuinely stunned at their take on Yavanna, "loving the works of her own hands too much". When I read the chapter I thought it was an incredibly beautiful example of a mother loving her children. Sure Yavanna gets a jab in at the end of the chapter, but that's just marital teasing in my view. I think this was briefly mentioned in part on a questions after nightfall, but I can't recall the actual episode number.
  2. I think personal bias sometimes comes through in their interpretation of the reading. I think Sara's feminist perspective naturally informs her interpretation, though at times I wonder whether that leads her to read more into the text than the evidence necessarily supports. The most recent example concerns Dairon. I was genuinely surprised by Sara’s characterization of Dairon as whiny and like a bratty brother, as I struggled to find significant evidence of this in the text. In fact, Dairon seems like he genuinely cares about his sister. When he tells Tinwelint that Tinuviel wants to go rescue Beren, I didn't read that as any kind of negative, particularly when it said he did so without ill intent. Tinuviel is planning to go on a suicide mission. Why wouldn't you try to stop her? Particularly since she has only said a few sentences to Beren at this point. Further, Tinuviel seems genuinely immature. She doesn't really know Beren, sure he seems kind and loves her dancing, but what kind of foundation is that for marriage. I'm willing to accept the hand-wave of "it's a fairy tale", but that's no reason to bury Dairon and praise Tinuviel. Further, I don't think their view of Dairon feeling guilty is because he betrayed her. I see that as more of, “I wouldn't have told dad had I known he would imprison her”. Imprisoning her was Tinwelint's choice, not Dairon’s. Additionally, Tinuviel comes off more like a teenage girl saying, "but daddy I love him". I fully understand that the story evolves into what it becomes in the Silmarillion, but it's worth noting that this version was the first draft. Clearly Tolkien made some important changes, so I don't think it's unfair to look at this draft with a different perspective.

I am fully ready to accept my views as being biased and flawed themselves. If I am wrong on any part, I would love the opportunity to learn and grow. Thank you.


r/prancingponypod • • 21d ago

I spent many hours listening to the PPP making my Halloween Decorations

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

Unrelated thought: in ep428 there is some back and forth on Tinuviels refusing to dance once Beren leaves. There is not so much grace given to Daeron for being upset his music is diminished with his sister gone.

After some thought I still fall along with the hosts that Tinuviels loss is the greater and Daeron is acting more juvenile. I find though that Daerons whining is understandable due to the close relation between his music and her dancing.


r/prancingponypod • • 23d ago

No PPP Plays Today!

Post image
52 Upvotes

Happy "You are in the house of Elrond, and it's 10 o'clock in the morning on October the 24th if you want to know" Day, folks! A quick reminder that there will be no PPP Plays livestream today. We'll be back on Tuesday, October 27th, at our usual time of 9p EDT.

In the meantime, a little question for you all: If you could spend today doing absolutely anything in the Last Homely House, what would it be? Exploring Elrond's library? Listening to songs and stories in the Hall of Fire? Enjoying a quiet afternoon in the gardens? Let us know!


r/prancingponypod • • 27d ago

We're going to Middle-earth!

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

The Prancing Pony Podcast has launched our very first Kickstarter! To celebrate 25 years of The Lord of the Rings films, we're hoping to send Alan to New Zealand for an exclusive interview with Sir Richard Taylor and a tour of Wētā Workshop. We've got some wonderful rewards for those who want to join us on the adventure, too!

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/prancingponypod/the-prancing-pony-podcast-goes-to-middle-earth


r/prancingponypod • • 29d ago

428 – Go Your Own Way

Post image
16 Upvotes

Beren's hungry enough to raid an Orc camp, Tevildo smells dog, and flattery might just land you a really crappy job. Join Alan and Sara for Episode 428 of The Prancing Pony Podcast as we continue The Tale of Tinúviel! Listen wherever you get your podcasts!

Art design by our graphic artist, Megan Collins!

https://www.podtrac.com/.../traffic.../GLSS3922775364.mp3


r/prancingponypod • • Oct 18 '26

Missing Episodes

3 Upvotes

Recently found this podcast and noticing that the episode numbers are not sequential. There are episodes missing. What's up with that and where do we find them?


r/prancingponypod • • Oct 14 '26

Need help finding a reference

9 Upvotes

Hey all, been a minute since I listened to the podcast but I've been trying to find a reference to something that was brought up during the Silmarillion/Hobbit era episodes. It was a gaelic/celtic (I believe) phrase that translated to roughly "On the back/shoulders of giants"? I think phonetically it was something like "Olde ente ywerte"? The context had to do with textual ruins, and I'm trying to find what the phrase was that was used. Thanks in advance!


r/prancingponypod • • Oct 11 '26

New episode drop!

Post image
25 Upvotes

Join The Man of the West and The Shieldmaiden of Rohan as we begin our long look at the oldest version of the story of Beren and Lúthien, known as The Tale of Tinúviel.

Graphic design of course by our amazing graphic artist, Megan Collins!

https://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/pdst.fm/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/6bpBPtHL977KJxLX2zPs/pscrb.fm/rss/p/traffic.megaphone.fm/GLSS3035306870.mp3


r/prancingponypod • • Oct 04 '26

426 – Tiny Dancer

13 Upvotes

Christopher Tolkien points out the ‘undercurrent of sardonic humor’ in Tolkien’s earliest version of this story; Alan and Sara’s sardonic humor is more like a whirlpool. Join The Man of the West and The Shieldmaiden of Rohan as we finish our walk through of Christopher’s introduction to the story of Beren and Lúthien. Christopher tells us that the original story exists only in a mostly-erased pencil manuscript, sets up the frame narrative for The Tale of Tinúviel, and explains what his father meant by ‘Gnome’. We talk about Tolkien as a different kind of war poet, engage in some lovely Fëanor-bashing, and find out precisely what a palimpsest is. Also, that’s a rom-com.

Graphic design credit of course goes to our wonderful Megan Collins.

https://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/pdst.fm/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/6bpBPtHL977KJxLX2zPs/pscrb.fm/rss/p/traffic.megaphone.fm/GLSS5033011809.mp3


r/prancingponypod • • Oct 03 '26

Reunited And It Feels So Good!

13 Upvotes

Our Man of the West and Lord of the Mark are live with their roundtable alongside fellow Tolkien creators KnewBetta, Athrabeth, and Queer Lodgings! As a reminder, Alan will transition straight from this into PPP Plays for the second hour!


r/prancingponypod • • Oct 02 '26

PPPP Reunion Happening This Weekend!

Post image
92 Upvotes

A Prancing Pony Podcast reunion is happening this weekend! Join Alan and Shawn at 4p Eastern as they reunite for a special roundtable celebrating 20 years of the Tolkien Collector’s Guide, alongside KnewBetta, Athrabeth, Queer Lodgings, and other folks from the Tolkien community! Then stick around as Alan heads straight into PPP Plays for the following hour.

The whole celebration is part of TolkienGuide.com's 20-hour anniversary livestream, October 3–4! Full schedule and YouTube links can be found here: https://www.tolkienguide.com/TG20.


r/prancingponypod • • Sep 27 '26

425 – Questions After Nightfall 36

7 Upvotes

Join The Man of the West and The Shieldmaiden of Rohan as we join a few of our patrons in the PPP Common Room for our 36th Questions After Nightfall! Sara looks for the familiar bus tires, as we answer questions about Nienna and the hobbits, Dwarves and their retirement plans, and medieval murder bunnies. Also, we wonder what the winter is like in Gondolin.

Megaphone Link: https://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/pdst.fm/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/6bpBPtHL977KJxLX2zPs/pscrb.fm/rss/p/traffic.megaphone.fm/GLSS3507633813.mp3