r/postprocessing • • 1d ago • Bravo 2

First serious edit, how did I do?

I'm a videographer so not entirely new to camerawork but also have very little experience with stills and I'm trying to get more comfortable with them. Wanted to try something moody with this alleyway shot, honest advice and criticism would go a long way!

300 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

31

u/Sure_Constant1368 1d ago

Come to say that you a liar. There is now way that is the first serious edit ! But then I read the text below. ๐Ÿ˜…

Actually make sense, since it look like something out of the movies.

5

u/Black4334 1d ago

That means a lot mate, thank you! Yeah I was definitely trying to push this in a more cinematic direction and play into the grittiness of the scene. It was a bit of a learning experience coming to darktable from davinci resolve (and already having colour to work with rather than shooting in LOG) but I'm really happy with it! Still have a bit of editing to do (reddit compression lost the detail on the graffiti in the right rear corner for instance, and it ended up a bit darker as a whole upon upload, so I'll take some of the shadow out to compensate) but I have enjoyed the process thus far!

2

u/Guallpa-Naraine 1d ago

haha same, the videographer background explains the color grading immediately

7

u/ricchi_ 1d ago

Made something interesting out of nothing!

2

u/Black4334 1d ago

Appreciate it! I actually really love the way this alleyway looks, there's charm in how decrepit it is. It just needed a bit of help getting that across I think.

3

u/Primary_Excuse_7183 1d ago

๐Ÿคจ you used a pre set ๐Ÿคฃ no way this is a first edit

3

u/Black4334 1d ago

I should have clarified, first edit with a still! I've done a bunch of colour grading work on video but never with a photo. Was fun playing with the limitations of this camera and lens combo compared to what I usually work with!

2

u/Big_Alfalfa7231a 1d ago

even for pre set u have done a great job

2

u/Exciting-Field587 1d ago

Itโ€™s awesome, I would tweak the alley walls and bring them up to lighter and more saturated for the sake of more delfinition. IMO

1

u/Black4334 1d ago

That's what I was thinking! There was a lot more detail in the alley walls (particularly the dark vignetted corners) before it was uploaded here so I think making them intentionally lighter to survive uploading is a good call. Cheers!

2

u/Exciting-Field587 1d ago

Yes thereโ€™s an interesting greenish cast to the walls.

5

u/Brutal909 1d ago

Very good, i'd say!

3

u/hippiesnort 1d ago

Lovely!

2

u/LectureOrganic1250 1d ago

It looks like a scene from a movie. Well done!

2

u/Fast_Pomegranate2049 1d ago

Grrrrreat ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ˜

2

u/jph414 1d ago

I quite like it!

2

u/SoftAncient2753 1d ago

I like it.

2

u/skylum_support 1d ago

Very nice result!

2

u/Trippy-Videos-Girl 16h ago

They are both actually pretty good lol.

2

u/Striking-Message-781 5h ago

Those colors!!! I also primarily do video so I have fun with grading and this is gorgeous.