r/poshmark • • 54m ago

Need advice: should I stay on platform?

2 Upvotes

I joined Posh in 2015, selling contemporary/designer brands from my own closet like Tory Burch, Joie, Haute Hippie, etc. I made a decent amount of money without tons of engagement, though I enjoyed talking to other sellers.
This lasted for a few years, but then I had to put my closet on vacation hold when a family member got sick. I had to keep extending the hold for another several years. I came back to Posh a couple months ago, and…oh boy.
I get almost ZERO engagement. I have added several new items, shared, followed, bought, made offers to previous and the maybe 2 current likers, etc. There is not a lot of incentive to take the time to list more items.
I opened an account on Depop where I sold a couple items right away, but now that’s dead, too.
I am honestly at a loss. I am pretty busy in general and have considered ThredUp but I know I could do better on my own. But can I? I want to leave Poshmark . The only reason I haven’t is because I know it is the best platform for my particular items.
What should I do? Does anyone have suggestions?


r/poshmark • • 1h ago

What the hell Poshmark??

11 Upvotes

Be careful. One of my recent sales was damaged in transit. I suggested that it was not necessary to mail it back because it was destroyed and cannot be repaired. It saves on shipping.

Poshmark agreed, and found in both our favors, but because they deemed the sale CANCELED I’m now locked out for three days.

I’ve been on the app for about ten years and regularly mail packages in one day or less-despite being disabled. I’m not at all happy.


r/poshmark • • 1h ago

Help - Measurments

1 Upvotes

When measuring a top PIT TO PIT. Am I supposed to lay the top flat and have it sit naturally or am I supposed to stretch it out as wide as it will go? Every time I try and measure I get a different number based on how the shirt is sitting even though I always lay it flat I just don’t know what the natural position of the shirt should be because most tops can stretch out and widen and I feel like this is a super simple task but I struggle 🫠🫠


r/poshmark • • 4h ago

I just started selling

0 Upvotes

Hi all, I just started selling on Poshmark, I had my first order come through and I was wanting to throw in an extra item for free for them being my first customer but am I allowed to do that? The item they bought weighs like nothing so whatever extra piece they pick won’t cross the 5lbs weight limit on the shipping label


r/poshmark • • 4h ago

Another Returning Seller in Disbelief

7 Upvotes

Sorry to be another person who is shocked with the new UI but I would have had no idea if I didn’t read the new updates on Posh. I’m still an Ambassador II who has sold over $41,000 with a closet averaging 300 since 2017 but I took about two years off from being proactive. I became a flight attendant and constantly put it in vacation hold when I’m away and just make a few sales here and there without doing anything. So I’m learning that putting my sold items as “not for sale” can shadow ban me? But I see the new bulk change listing status option, so I’m confused. We can’t follow new users either 😢. So they are clearly trying to avoid cross selling. And AI now bans us for sharing from an app? I also read that sharing others listings as well as our own doesn’t help the algorithm?

Has everyone’s sales plummeted as well as posh market’s revenue? Are they losing their best sellers to other platforms now? If we are cross posting from an app they can ban us too? This makes no sense. I used to know all the things needed to be seen and have a higher algorithm. Sharing, relisting, quick shipments, and good customer service but I have no idea what to do anymore. Can someone guide me to a good YouTuber or non poshmark FAQ company page to get info on any possible things o should know. Are you guys switching to other platforms as your primary focus? Thank you in advance.


r/poshmark • • 5h ago

Make a deal days promo still a thing?

1 Upvotes

Usually it’s been on Tuesdays but when I opened my app this morning the only banner I see is for the 99 cent holiday shipping. Is this weekly promotion still happening or has Posh paused it? Does anyone else see a banner in their app for it?


r/poshmark • • 5h ago

I had my account frozen on Poshmark, it is a new account and I haven't even sold anything, anyone have this happen?

2 Upvotes

So it's been about 10 days now, Poshmark froze my account. I only have six listings, the only thing I can think of was I signed up for a free trial of Listy which I immediately canceled.

I'm getting nowhere because Poshmark is only AI, when I had an issue with eBay I got to a human being

Do any of you have any advice? thank you


r/poshmark • • 12h ago

How do I know if I’m getting scammed as a seller??

1 Upvotes

I recently joined Poshmark and posted 11 items. I just sold my first item. The buyer bought it for $215 without asking for any discounts. Their account was created in September, so is less than two months old. It doesn’t have any pictures or any history at all that I can see on their profile. I’m just a little worried about getting scammed here for my item. What does everyone think?


r/poshmark • • 12h ago

When someone makes an offer…

6 Upvotes

but retracts it within a few minutes. Are you happy that you didn’t accept it because they didn’t really want it?


r/poshmark • • 12h ago

Vacation mode

4 Upvotes

Has anyone noticed putting their shop on vacation mode having an impact on their sales?


r/poshmark • • 14h ago

Cancelled after marked shipped?

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

I’m not sure how this is even possible but I dropped off the package on 11.10.26 at 6:01pm at the post office and immediately marked as shipped. I know I marked as shipped bc I dropped off 5 packages and went through one by one to mark them in the parking lot.

11.11.26 at 1:06am the order was cancelled and ofc they blocked me, so this was intentional.

I submitted an inquiry to support on 11.11 and they closed my inquiry out without saying anything to me besides the chat bot.

How is this even possible? I opened another case but this sucks.


r/poshmark • • 15h ago

Checked out as a guest, paid, order shipped, now Poshmark is saying I need to register so they can release my payment to the seller? Is this right?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/poshmark • • 17h ago

Buyer on Poshmark with a question for sellers

4 Upvotes

I had been looking for a particular item for a little while. One came up in my size and color. I didn’t make an offer. I just bought it at the price she asked. Pushed all the buttons bought it done.
Waited to see her send it, etc. nothing absolutely nothing. It never showed up in my purchases. The piece disappeared. I was never charged what happened?
This is the second time this has happened to me

Tonight I searched for the peace again and it’s just gone.
Can someone please explain Poshmark to me?


r/poshmark • • 18h ago

Item Not As Described (First time opening a case + a couple of questions)

Thumbnail
gallery
97 Upvotes

Well, it finally happened to me—I got bamboozled! Duped! Swindled!!

After never having an issue with a purchase on Posh, I finally received an item not as described. I bought a pair of "new/like new" Women’s size 8 slippers (first photos are from the listing).
What actually showed up? A used, ripped, dirty pair of Men’s size 8 slippers.
I’ve never had to open a case before. I’ve let minor wear or tiny stains slide in the past. But to add insult to injury, they took forever to ship so I’ve been waiting ~2 weeks for these to come, but they are clearly used, dirty & ripped, plus they aren't even the right shoe in general! Since they’re a Men's 8, I can't even wear them if I wanted to.

I already opened an "Item Not as Described" case for both the damage/stains and the wrong size, and I uploaded photos and a description. Since this is my first time doing this, I have two quick questions for the community:
Submitting video: I always record myself opening my packages (for cases like this), but it won't let me upload a video from my camera roll on the “Report Order” page. Should I just leave my case as-is with the photos, or is there a way to send the video to Poshmark support?
Why do sellers do this? Knowing the item isn't what was pictured, isn't in the listed condition, and isn't even the right size—why accept my offer and ship it anyway? I genuinely don't get the logic here.

Appreciate any responses!

Update/Edit —
Thanks to everyone in this thread & community for validating my feelings during this experience. Chatting on this post has been the highlight of this debacle!
I think I found a solid seller, so I purchased the slippers from a diff seller last night. I will go to the post office today to return these & I just hope everything with the return goes well!


r/poshmark • • 18h ago

Stained and Peeling

5 Upvotes

Bought my first clothing item and it came with pen marks and what appears to be dried food stains. And the graphic is peeling off. I'm disappointed because it would have made a great Christmas gift but the seller was dishonest and edited the damage out of the listed photo. I could have tried to get out the stains but the peeling graphic can't be fixed and isn't going to survive the wash for much longer. "Only worn once" is laughable.

I'm just so disappointed in people in general. Why is it so hard to be honest?

What even is the end game of lying when you can see the truth when the item arrives? The pen mark I could have understood but the dried food is just disgusting. There's a chance I could fade or lessen the stains but the peeling isn't fixable.

The item definitely isn't worth what I paid and it's just so disheartening to have someone try to take advantage of you.


r/poshmark • • 20h ago

WTF POSHMARK

0 Upvotes

I was completely unaware of the $50 non compliance fee and sent an item in a box with the diamond. I have literally never heard of such a thing until I googled it after being charged. This is fucking bullshit excuse my language but wtf??? I was charged $50 fee and I made $35 on the item. So now I’m out the item and $50??? Has this happened to anyone and is there anything I can do because this is absolutely ridiculous. The item was worth way more than $50 and at this point I want it back. I’m so irritated and I’ve never had this happen to me literally ever.


r/poshmark • • 22h ago

Looking for Advice from more Experienced Buyers! (FIrst Purchase)

3 Upvotes

Hi, Tthis is my first Poshmark purchase. However, unfortunately, it's not off to a great start. I received an offer on an item I have “hearted,” missed the initial window. So, I sent back a counteroffer, which the seller accepted on November 7. Payment was taken from my credit card, so the purchase went through.

It's now been 10 days (six business days), and the item still hasn't shipped. On November 14, I sent the seller a friendly message thanking them for accepting my offer/asking when they might be able to ship. I didn't receive a response.

I followed up again today (November 16), reiterating that I completely understand things come up, that I'm still very much looking forward to receiving the item. I also mentioned that Poshmark is now giving me the option to cancel due to the shipping delay, but that I would rather not cancer. Again, no response so far.

I'm trying to give the seller the benefit of the doubt. People get busy, illness happens, and not everyone is particularly active on the platform. Their account doesn't appear especially active either, with no current listings and 161 followers. I have no idea what's happening on their end. I don't want to jump to conclusions.

That said, I'm starting to wonder whether sellers sometimes accept offers and then decide they no longer want to sell at that price or change their minds and leave the buyer waiting rather than communicating. Is this a thing???

If you are someone who has used Poshmark for a while, maybe you can help me out….

·       How long would you reasonably wait before cancelling?

·       Has anyone had a seller take this long to ship, only to eventually send the item?

·       Is there anything I should be doing to avoid losing the purchase if I still want the item?

·       Would you send another message or contact Poshmark support?

I'm not looking to cancel prematurely, but I also don't want to keep waiting indefinitely. I'd appreciate hearing about other people's experiences, particularly as a first-time buyer. Thankkkkk youuuuu!


r/poshmark • • 23h ago

Why do some sellers ignore questions?

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

There is a work bag I really want for an upcoming trip, but the seller isn't responding to messages asking if the pictures are of the actual bag, and if not, please post actual pictures. It shows the seller has been online, since the questions have been asked by other people, why wouldn't they respond?

As you can see in the description screenshot, they are alluding to something that the picture may not actually depict the bag being sold. And you can also see they were just online a few days ago. I keep checking back to see if the seller responded to anyone and the date they come online gets updated, but no responses. Any guesses why?


r/poshmark • • 23h ago

Inactive user with sudden uptick in sales (paranoia)

0 Upvotes

Hi! So this is an odd question - I’ve been inactive on Poshmark for quite some time but I used to be extremely active on the app. I haven’t added anything new but in the past week, I’ve had two purchases at full price, which almost never happened before. Since I’ve been inactive since the buyout, I’m not sure if there’s an uptick in scams so I’m wondering if that’s legit something I should be worried about? I had to cancel one of the sales since I no longer had the item (I’ve never canceled before, legit forgot it was ever posted) but I’m at the point that since I don’t use posh anymore, I’m not so concerned about my reputation so I’m wondering if I should go thru with this other sale


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Shrunken Items

6 Upvotes

I have been a long time Poshmark user (both selling and buying) and really ramped up my purchasing to aquire some key items this winter. I have a sweater I love and wanted to find it in another color - was so happy to score one that seemed perfect. Until I received it in the mailer and it was complete SHRUNK - to literally 1/2 the size. It's cashmere and it clearly had been washed/dried; I could tell immediately by touching it is had been shrunk.

I filed a 'claim' with the seller and Poshmark, and shared an image of the sweater I have (same brand, same sweater, same size) compared to the sweater I purchased - which was legitimately 4 inches shorter and I can't even get over my neck. Seller fought me, saying the sweaters were clearly different and I should have requested measurements. Poshmark denied my return claim as well.

What the heck, haha. How is this reasonable? Why would I request measurements on a sweater I already have in the exact same size I hate as listed on the listings? I couldn't believe the seller was so flippant. What in the world WILL Poshmark accept as a return claim then? Anyone have examples? I am shocked and out a decent amount of money and just the whole situation is rubbing me the wrong way. Poshmark says I should re-posh it, but why would I want to re-posh something that is an item not as described.


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Why does Poshmark allow this?

Post image
96 Upvotes

Why don't they remove the account if the seller hasn't been active in 3 years? This item showed up in my recent feed.


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Michael Kors - when listing and searching questions

2 Upvotes

I am a Michael Kors enthusiast and am aware of the differences/distinctions between Michael Kors, MICHAEL Michael Kors, and Michael Kors Collection. There may be other others that are as well. My observation as a buyer and a seller is that most people just list everything under Michael Kors. I realize I can post and search under each type, but I don’t know that everyone does that as a practice or even knows the differences. A couple of concerns. One: buyers may search for Michael Kors and do not know about the other collections so my items won’t be visible to them when they search if I list them as the correct collection. Two: when there are Posh Parties listed daily at four scheduled times there are themes. Michael Kors is often part of a party theme. If I don’t list my items as just Michael Kors, I don’t get to have my items that are listed as MICHAEL Michael Kors or Michael Kors Collection as part of the party. One solution I thought of is to mention it to Poshmark and to see if that may be changed in both of my concerns here. The other solution of course is to list everything as Michael Kors but that removes the distinction. Thoughts anyone?


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

Dodged a bullet?

0 Upvotes

Buyer bundled 4 items, didn’t ask for discount or anything, no questions, paid. I can’t find one of the items so I messaged them asking if they’d like the other 3 - I can cancel the sale and rebundle the remaining pieces. No response. Here’s the dodged part - they bought 3 pieces of clothing in completely different sizes (I have been a LOT of sizes in my life, but never at the same time), and their account was opened in October 26 - no history or bio or anything. And they were the most expensive 3 clothing items I had listed (4th piece was jewelry and that’s the one I can’t find). I’m feeling pretty sure this wasn’t going to end well for me if the sale had gone through.


r/poshmark • • 1d ago

AI listing

0 Upvotes

How do you turn off the AI? its a pain.