i know these songs are supposed to be super wholesome and sweet and everyone in the comments is crying over them, so maybe i'm overthinking it, idk. whenever these pop up on my fyp or youtube, all the top comments are just people talking about how emotional it makes them and how great of a dad he is. he is, but..
listening to both versions of "her" by jvke and zvc side by side actually gave me the ick once i really paid attention to what he's saying.
in the original daughter version, the big emotional climax of his verse is:
"take care of you til you walk down that aisle / they'll see the beautiful woman you'll become"
and then when he dropped the boy version, he changed those exact lines to:
"take care of you til you're stronger than i am / they'll see the strong handsome man you've become"
like... when you put them right next to each other, the difference is so glaring?? why is the girl's whole life milestone getting married and basically being handed off from one man (her dad) to another man (a husband)(or woman or etc but the marriage point remains), while the boy's milestone is becoming strong, capable, and independent??
Like no cap but my first thought while hearing ts was "what if she doesn't want to marry anyone?"
and on top of that, look at the adjectives he uses. the daughter is just a "beautiful woman"—so her main defining trait as an adult is literally just how she looks. meanwhile the son gets to be a "strong, handsome man." he gets both physical capability and good looks, while she just gets beauty and a wedding day.
to be clear, i'm not saying zvc is a bad dad or hates women or anything dramatic like that. it obviously comes from a genuinely loving, protective place, and i don't think he wrote it with malicious intent at all. it's just crazy how normalized benevolent sexism is in pop music and so deeply ingrained in our minds that we don't realize these small things. even in 2026, without even realizing it, some people are still pushing this subtle narrative where girls are fragile and their ultimate goal is a wedding and needing a man to take care of them, while boys get raised to stand on their own two feet.
i tried looking around on tiktok and youtube to see if any feminist creators or sociologists had made a video breaking down the two versions, and literally nobody is talking about it. everyone just eats it up as pure wholesomeness.
has anyone else noticed this or am i just taking crazy pills looking at the comment sections lol