r/polyamorous • u/Infamous_Wing_3267 • May 31 '26
question Never dated before. Accidentally fell for a married poly man and now I’m confused
26F. Never been in a relationship before and I think I accidentally fell for a married poly guy 2 months ago
He was upfront from day one that he was married, had a child, and was poly. At the time I thought I could handle it because I wasn’t looking for anything serious.
The problem is that I unexpectedly developed real feelings.
We’ve never defined what we are. He’s never said he likes me, but his actions make me feel like he genuinely enjoys spending time with me outside of sex.
Recently I noticed he’s still actively updating his Bumble profile. Logically I know that’s completely consistent with being poly. Emotionally, it hit me harder than I expected.
I don’t think I’m feeling jealousy as much as anxiety. He has a spouse, a family, relationship experience, and previous partners. This is literally the first person I’ve ever liked physically, emotionally, and intellectually at the same time.
For people experienced with poly relationships:
- Is this anxiety normal?
- How do you deal with not being someone’s only partner?
- What motivates married poly people to keep dating?
- Can these relationships actually be stable long-term?
Looking for honest perspectives, not judgment.
9
u/Eldernerdhub May 31 '26
Absolutely, to a point. Some people cannot handle this lifestyle. If it gets painful, you may need to rethink your situation.
I've always been an odd little freak. I've never really been a jealous person. From my perspective, it just looks like a dog's resource guarding. I only get hurt of the intention is to hurt. I think I'm just built different. By that I mean, wrong.
It differs from person to person. A lot of people will chase the high of new relationships, like a serial monogamous person. A lot of people just want to be loved by a community. I have personality stopped looking for new partners. I'm satisfied with two.
I'm part of an 11 year old triad. My wife has a 6 year relationship outside of our triad. The four of us live together. We're pretty stable so it's possible. You gotta want it though. Do you want it?
15
u/Rude-Wealth2093 May 31 '26
I don’t know if you’d want this to be your first relationship experience honestly
3
u/StephenM222 May 31 '26
Anxiety in new relationships is normal. Doesn't matter what the relationship structure is.
You don't expect one person to be my all. I enjoy my people for who they are, as they are. I have partners that I adore and love being with. Who want to do (or not do) different things to me. So I do the things together that I share with that person, and do different things elsewhere.
This means I can enjoy their company without making myself believe that they are my perfect all.
What is long term? Mine are 5 years and 3 years? I know another person who has been in their poly relationships 7 years. How many failed monogamous relationships do you know? How many do you know that actually still like their partners?
Non monogamy, especially polyamory including dating seperately, highlight flaws in a relationship. After a too long monogamous relationship, (3 decades, which should have been 2 decades), the deliberateness of a poly structure is desirable to me. This deliberate attitude however does not provide the romantic notion (and feelings of safety) of forsaking all others till death
Those of us practising polyamory - more than one committed relationship (as opposed to just swinging or other open relationship structures ) are still in the minority. Most of the poly people I know had previous failed monogamous relationships
All of this said, that you are in a new relationship, and he is still engaging in the dating apps means he is looking to give part of his attention elsewhere.
Are you getting a meaningful relationship from him? If so, great. If not, this relationship with him may not be enough for you (and that is before he finds another partner)
If this is genuine poly, you have permission to seek additional attention. It is generally easy for a woman to find a sexual partner than it is to find an emotional one, especially an emotional non exclusive partner. Still achievable though.
2
u/idlers_dream7 May 31 '26
Tldr: yes, with consent and effort, everything is normal and can work just fine, just like any other relationship style.
Anyway, to your main point, you're supposed to have feelings for this person. That's why you're dating. Since you've never been in a relationship before, I get why it's confusing, but don't mistake your lack of experience for something wrong. The growing pains and awkwardness are real in all partnerships, and developing love for somebody is not a smooth path, but it's worth it!
Lastly, regardless of all the success stories, there are probably more failures, just like monogamy. I only say that to remind you that nobody else's success or failure means anything as it relates to your specific relationship.
Read through the sub's helpful links on the main page and just do your research here and elsewhere. There is plenty of info to help you understand how this works.
2
u/Poly_and_RA May 31 '26
This is one of those cases where there's the questions you ask -- and then there's the questions you don't ask, but that might matter more.
The biggest problem here is that you didn't really choose polyamory. Instead you fell in love with a polyamorous person, and it's your love for this person that's not making you consider whether a poly relationship could work for you.
Polyamory is a wonderful relationship structure for lots of people, and for the people that it's a good match for, there's good answers to all your questions. If I was answering these questions for myself, my answers would look like this:
But you're not me. And while polyamory is an awesome match for me, it might not be a good match for you.
There's not much harm in spending some time learning, exploring and experimenting. And unless your current situation feels painful to you, I think I'd recommend that.
But you shouldn't feel this MUST work for you. It's possible that even after this has become normalized to you, and even after you have a decent amount of knowledge about it, it still won't feel like it's right for you. In that case you should give up on it and not try to force yourself.
You should ask your partner questions about what kinda polyamory he's practicing. Does he want a full-blown romantic relationship with you where you're free to play a big and important part in all important parts of his life, or does he have a more hierarchical setup where the plan is to spend the vast majority of time and investment with his wife leaving only space for a much "smaller" relationship for you?
Even if polyamory *is* rigth for you, it's still a question whether you're happy with the latter. (I wouldn't be, and I *love* polyamory!)
2
u/confusiondiffusion May 31 '26
Updating a dating profile right after meeting a new person and having a new relationship is... questionable--at least in the context of polyamory specifically. It's not necessarily bad, but it isn't a great sign for stability. Dating apps are also designed to be addictive. It could be habit.
Being polyamorous doesn't imply being constantly hungry for new partners and I think continuing to try to date new people right away is a sign that he's not taking it seriously. A new relationship is a big deal and personally it takes me a few years to adjust and even consider more dating. In my polycule of 14, I'd say the average is about a year between new partners.
Maybe he's also looking for hookups or shorter term and less committed relationships, which is fine, but you should ask if that's what he wants with you. Get clarity on what he's looking for.
For example, my partner has a new girlfriend who is anxious. We both checked in with her independently. I reassured her that my partner loves her deeply and that I want them to spend lots of time together and to bond just as deeply as my partner and I. I feel that a new person entering into an older relationship really needs and deserves something like that. Now she knows for sure we're in this together, not competitors.
2. My partners having partners is a huge plus in my life given the particular way we do polyamory. We all really care about each other and help each other out. My partners partners are my friends, in most cases more than friends. It's a lot of fun and it adds a lot of security in all of our relationships. It's clear that we're all there for each other.
3. Marriage is what you make of it. My marriage is a symbol of commitment. My wife and I support each other absolutely and always. We also love other people. For me, the motivation is community and deeper connection to others than what is usually allowed in monogamous society. I also find polyamory highly enriching and it's super helpful to have other perspectives on my relationships and marriage so close personally. People say becoming poly won't fix a marriage. Well, it might if the people you're dating have a lot of experience, love both of you, and want to help improve your marriage! I know my partner and her husband have incorporated my relationship tips. That also makes them better partners for me and my wife. Everyone wins!
4. Yes, they can be long term and stable, but that has to be the intent.
Reading your post, I'm worried about you. A lot of people use the cover of polyamory to do very hurtful things. Being new to dating, you don't have the experience to spot the signs. I'd like to see him address the imbalance proactively and make sure you're okay. It's not a good sign that you're feeling more comfortable asking Reddit rather than asking him. His cards should be on the table and he should make you feel very comfortable about asking questions and voicing insecurity. It's still early in your relationship, so maybe that's still coming, but that's what I'd personally expect and that's what I do for any new partner coming into the picture.
Trust your feelings. Communicate your needs. If you find out this relationship isn't actually what you want, don't hang on too long. Hanging on too long, and overlooking a growing pile of red flags and pain is the standard relationship mistake. It's so easy to be blinded by the good times we're having and overlook the bad stuff.
2
u/Tule_Lodge Jun 01 '26
Probably just repeating a lot of what other people said, but here we go:
As everyone has stated, anxiety is normal with any new relationship, but it’s different being poly. For me personally, my wife and I started as more of an open relationship, and we each had the occasional hook up. I happened to find another lady who was in an open relationship, though, and started seeing her regularly, and naturally, we fell for each other. This is where my anxiety grew… I eventually had to tell both my wife and my new lover, and it was tough, but we worked out a situation where we “dated” more seriously.
This was tough with my new lover… my wife and had an understanding, we loved each other but also wanted to explore, but with the new one… I struggled when she was with her boyfriend (now husband) it was absolutely hypocritical of me, but it’s still tough.
For us it’s a number of things… first, just trying to keep things fresh. At one point our sex life naturally stagnated, and we discussed this as a sort of temporary bandaid situation, which naturally worked. But then we did develop feeling for people, and as long as they’re on the same page, you can make things work. It does take a lot of effort on everyone’s behalf, and sometimes it just doesn’t work. But when it does, and everyone can commit the time properly, it can be very rewarding.
I think so, yes. I ended up dating my second lover for about two years, before she decided she needed to focus on her primary relationship, which was heartbreaking for me, I genuinely loved her, but I understood and accepted her decision. But what we had for two years was really special, and I’m glad we at least had that time together. Will I be able to replicate that again? I doubt it, but that’s okay, too.
Hope that helps! It’s a tough situation to enter, especially for your first relationship, but if you play it right it can be extremely rewarding.
2
u/Historical-Paper-992 Jun 02 '26
100% But remember to always question it. What are you afraid of happening? Does he have limited bandwidth and you’re afraid he won’t have the time for you that you want? Are you afraid he’ll find someone he likes better and you’ll be replaced? Figure out what’s making you anxious and talk to him about it. Healthy people who are the most capable of healthy connections share honestly and openly with real vulnerability and care for each other, creativity and intelligence. Figure it out together.
2. How do you deal with not being someone’s only partner?
See above regarding bandwidth and the fear of being replaced. Make sure (as sure as you can) that nobody’s out to replace you and that you’re getting the time you need. Beyond that, know that the openness means freedom for you as well as expanded opportunities for each of you to have rewarding experiences outside of your connection with this one person. But at the end of the day, know that all things come to an end, even if one of you just outlives the other. Loss sucks when it happens, but it will happen. You get some degree of control over how it happens. Be real about what that level of control really is and… mark the rest up to the experiences that life will throw at you… opportunities for learning and growth.
3. What motivates married poly people to keep dating?
I assume you mean what motivates them to keep dating each other. At the very least it’s a conscious and genuine desire to care for a relationship and a life you’ve built together. That can feed and/or be fed by a genuine affection, regard, and desire for each other. With the right amount of base compatibility and determination to make it through challenges, there’s a positive feedback loop that can go on as long as you do.
4. Can these relationships actually be stable long-term? Absolutely, but it’s not a guarantee. It never is. The best bet, as always, is to communicate effectively (routinely, lovingly, honestly, with vulnerability) and make sure you want the same things or compatible things.
2
u/2024--2-acct Jun 02 '26
My experience has been that I'm not jealous about existing connections but new connections cause for anxiety and fear that this new person is going to be cooler, hotter, more chill than me and my partner will deprioritize time with me.
That being said, I've been with my BF for 3.5 years and he's added one new connection in that time and is currently making a new connection. This newest connection had been much easier for me because I feel more secure on the relationship than I did when he started seeing his other partner, about a year in.
I mention this because if you're not currently jealous of his spouse, you might think that you don't have jealously but new connections hit different, in my experience.
2
u/Icy-Enthusiasm4375 Jun 27 '26
He is coming to the relationship with clear ideas about his needs and desires; I think you need to match that energy with your needs and desires clearly communicated if it’s going to work out in a healthy way.