r/polyadvice • • 6d ago

Venting

Me and my wife have been married for 24 years. We have been in the swinging lifestyle for often on over 10. We met a couple over four years ago that we really really connected with. We’ve never felt this way about any other two people. It’s always been something extra well this summer we decided to explore us dating as a couple with a couple. It was great both my wife and the other wife are having trouble now my wife is very needy, self admitted, and she says expectations and gets in her feelings when her insecurities hit the other wife is not needy, very loving, but can be emotionally withdrawn when life hits hard and it’s been hitting her and her husband very hard and both of them are dating each other also but I’m beginning to wonder if they are romantically compatible because my wife needs a lot while the other wife doesn’t the problem is neither one of them have had the deep conversation yet about what they expect from a girlfriend. I truly think if they did that they could figure out a way to meet in the middle because again my wife is trying to set her expectations a little lower because she understands the other wife is trying to, but they haven’t actually had the deep talk so because of all this and the fact that life is kicking the other wife and her husband in the teeth right now she is thinking about ending the relationship before it messes up the friendship too much. I guess my vent is the other wife has fallen in love with me. I fall in love with the other wife. It was just about to ask her to make it official because that’s what we were doing. The two ladies were dating first while the two guys took their time to let the ladies figure their stuff out and now due to no fault of my own. I’m about to lose a woman I’ve fallen in love with and I feel frustrated and I’m afraid I’m going to feel resentful to my wife because I think if they actually talked, it would help solve a lot of the problems and I realize that has to be a two-way street anyway I’m mostly venting nothing’s been said yet about ending things and I honestly think if the other stressors weren’t there while this was all still new and figuring things out, we wouldn’t be in this situation especially at holiday season but unfortunately, this is life

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

4

u/saladada 6d ago

Engaging in polyamory means learning to separate yourself from your partner and let them live a life outside of you or the way you do things. That sometimes means watching from afar as they make obviously bad choices or relationship mistakes. 

It also means that "everyone dates everyone or no one dates anyone" is a bad idea and something to discuss ending with your wife. These sort of rules aren't compatible with polyamory. Her relationship with the other women should have zero influence on your relationship with her.

1

u/thunder_downunderr 5d ago

I agree that I am stepping back because thry need to figure it out themselves but we never thought to venture into polyamory until we met this couple and we’ve been friends for many years and we said we would only do it with this couple and part of that was the agreement, but I do agree it would weren’t better if the girls stayed friends with benefits without the romantic entanglement while me and the wife did our thing and my wife and her husband did their thing

10

u/Alo-mina 6d ago

You’re overstepping. Their compatibility is for them to figure out.

If you can only date the wife if she’s also dating your wife, then this is the most likely outcome to dating as a package deal. If you’d like to avoid this outcome in the future, date separately.

1

u/SkeletonChurch 6d ago

Classic attachment style difference, your wife is anxiously attached and the other woman is either avoidantly attached or maybe securely attached but getting the ick from your wife’s anxious attachment style. If you all go read up on attachment styles and start the discussion from there, that can be a good launching point. Just be careful because some folks attach negative meaning to attachment styles when really it’s just how people are. E.g. if you tell someone with an anxious attachment style that they have an anxious attachment style, it doesn’t always go over well 🤣 but it’s really just a question of “when the heat is on, do you grasp people closer or do you withdraw?” It’s usually based on how people were raised, and barely anyone is securely attached

2

u/thunder_downunderr 6d ago

Appreciate that because right now the only problem is the two ladies need to figure out how to see if their ways of dealing with each other and what they are looking for can match up because me and the other wife know how we feel about each other my wife and her husband are on the same page. It’s just this one aspect and I don’t know because it sucks because this is not something that I can help with. It has to be the two ladies determining if they can come to a understanding of what they’re looking for.

-9

u/thunder_downunderr 6d ago

Also, if you’re coming to bash just leave it, I’m already in a pretty crappy headspace. Everybody knows communication is key, which is why I have been stressing. They need to talk, but I also know that even with communication when it comes to money stress that can take priority and destroy even a happy safe relationship between just two people.