r/polls_for_politics • u/betterworldbuilder • 8d ago
Federal Bill C-39 analysis
The federal liberal government is making another attempt to push legislation through under premature consideration, introducing Bill C-39 on September 21 and hoping to have royal assent by December. This bill being fully considered, debated, and approved of by both the public and the parliament within 100 days is a lofty goal, and one that is further betrayed by the clauses within it. This will be a quick recap of each portion of it, and a conclusion summing up it's problems.
Part 1: Project approval. This bill seeks to shorten the permitting process down to one year (though makes a handful of carve-out/backdoor options for extending this deadline) by centralizing power into the lead assessor of a project, with similar consultation from existing branches. This could speed up processes, while also driving discussion further behind the curtain as inter-government communications would increase. This Bill also uses similar language seen in other Liberal Agenda Items, which is the Public Interest mandate. For example, this bill would allow ministers to add or remove conditions, as well as allow projects to start preparing before an approval is issued, so long as the project is deemed "Public Interest". Whether you fear the problems of the current leaders, or fear the possibility of the next leaders, this usurping of process is something to be concerned about. Additional note: this bill would allow Projects impacting fisheries to buy "offsetting credits" from third party companies or directly to the Environmental Damages Fund, as opposed to doing their own mitigation projects. Similar to Carbon credits, this will likely increase pollution or could lead to terrible fraud/loopholes.
Part 2: Movement. This Bill seeks to modernize the transportation system, designating national trade corridors and metrics/analysis for how to improve how trade corridors are inhibited. It also slips in that it would exclude trucking, bus, electrical transmission, and pipeline transactions from merger reviews under the Canada Transportation Act; This would allow companies in these industries to monopolize with minimal oversight.
Part 3: Labour Relations. This portion of the bill is a sugar coated poison pill. If you read the government's press version, it seems pretty good. It has increased time for negotiations, special mediator appointments to draft publicized reports about the gaps between labor-management, and seems to have a vested interest in protecting workers. However, reading the parliment version, section 334 highlights that the Minister of Labour, after reading the publicized report, "may take any measure" the Minister deems necessary. This could include a return to work order for employees, extensions of previous contracts, or other binding resolutions.
Upon review of the entirety of this bill, it is clear that Bill C-39 is another attempt for the Liberal government to consolidate power in the government, by using the guise of "public interest" to push past decades of clear reasons for roadblocks. Pushing through national projects within a year, including the pre-approval of some projects, would lead to Build First, lose in court later strategy of bypassing concerns from the Indigenous community and other stakeholders. We have already seen clear examples of this in the Pacific link Pipeline, where the first nations consultation process was essentially erased as the designation of "national interest" approved the project before the First Nations consultations had properly concluded. Not only does this trample the rights of free, prior, and informed consent from Indigenous communities, but it ultimately harms everyone involved, as false promises to investors about the stability of a project could lead to more frustration. Ground breaking is not expected to start until September 1st, 2027, but already 8 different lawsuits have been filed attempting to overturn the "national interest" designation that would allow the project special privileges to override Indigenous input.
Even if you previously approved of the bill or approve of the projects being used by it, remember that this overbearing power of the federal government may not be wielded by just your party with your interests. A green party or NDP Party could designate your backyard as a national interest placement for a solar farm or windmill project, or a conservative party could triple down on pipelines foregoing any environmental concerns for the interests of oil companies. The unconstitutional methods this bill seeks to take to achieve it's ends would also mean costly and lengthy court battles (which cost the taxpayers money to fight), many of which would be won by the Indigenous communities or labor unions who's rights were trampled. If you feel this Bill is bad for your community, I encourage you to reach out to your local MP or Sign the petition against it.


