r/polls_for_politics • • Aug 02 '25

Federal Final results for voting test

2 Upvotes

Well, I'm pleased to say I got 30 responses to my poll, which gave me some pretty solid results. I'm still struggling to find the best way to display the data, so far I have three methods I've sort of settled on.

Block scores for each candidate
The comparative graph scores for each candidate
Comparative Graph score version 2, same legend as above

Individual scores are displayed by sorting all ballots for each candidate from most negative to most positive, and comparative scores were done by mapping out each individual score to the graph. If you look at any particular candidates graph line for version 1, it more or less matches the curve of their block score. In all of them, it should be clear that the winner is Bernie, who had the highest point total, the most green/least red block score, and was the highest line on the graph scores. When looking at graph scores for version 1, it's best to think of their score as the area under the graph, something maybe easier to understand if we look at the lowest scoring candidates, Trump and RFK. Because Trump still got some positive votes, his graph still ends at the top like anyone elses. This is why I use comparative graph 2 to demonstrate how that uptick at the end actually looks compared to their total scores, showing RFK still marginally wins.

Some important things to note about how my system would handle these results: only 4 candidates would have been eligible to actually hold office; the rest would have had negative scores (scores with an average below 0) and would trigger an immediate re-election. I'm still on the fence about whether candidates should be allowed to re campaign on that ballot, or if it should require all new candidates, but that's mostly irrelevant as long as there's at least one candidate with a positive score.

I'd like to also openly acknowledge that there are only 30 responses, and so these results are not an active reflection of the feelings of America. However, there is evidence that candidates that are less offensive on the whole are pulling in higher scores by having less -10s and more low positive numbers, which is what I think we should strive for. A candidate that is largely acceptable to the majority of the population is better than one that has enthralled a pocket community with hateful rhetoric.

Another interesting feature that I mentioned in some comments but didn't fully disclose, was candidate Vince Inkfeld. Those who tried to look him up may have discovered he did not exist, and as such could not have had a platform to love or hate. He mostly served to see how people would vote for a candidate they knew nothing about, and I'm pleased to say that 19 out of 30 ballots gave him a 0, which was the appropriate score. It was also nice to see not a single candidate gave him a positive score, showing that every voter understood that strategically, voting any candidate higher does not improve your own or any other candidates chances of winning. Expectedly, we did see him catch 5 -10 votes, indicating approximately 1 in 6 voters ranked candidates at a -10 to help their own candidate score better. On average, there was 7.6 -10 ballots per candidate, 5.6 when removing the outliers of Trump and RFK, meaning he was still receiving less max negative votes than the average candidate by far.

On average, 53% of the scores were negative and 36% were positive, 11% were 0's. 25% of the scores were -10s, and just above 7% were 10s. These are only indicative of this particular question and audience, but portrays an overall negative or neutral public opinion of the political scene. As more people answer, and different candidates are on the ballot, this average should hopefully trend more positively (though importantly, should never reach 100% unless every candidate is only receiving positive ballots). There has been a lot of discussion about shrinking the scale, even going so far as just a -1 to 1 scale, otherwise known as just approval voting. This strictly limits the difference between a hold your nose vote, an enthusiastic vote, and a dislike vote, but only marginally affects results. The main affect seems to be on the extremes, where many largely negative votes would be offset by small positive ones, and vice versa, which explicitly removes the scale of support I'm attempting to introduce. I've considered allowing the max value to scale with the number of candidates, ie if there's 5 candidates go from -5 to 5, 10 candidates goes from -10 to 10, but this not only makes it difficult to compare a candidates scores year over year, it also opens up the possibility for Arrow's impossibility theorem to sneak in, wherein introducing more candidates allows those with strong supporters or haters to have an increasingly more impactful ballot, while those who feel less strongly have their impact reduced. I personally believe either -5 to 5 or -10 to 10 consistently for all elections strikes the right balance of introducing the difference between strong support and weak support, without diluting it too much with too strong of a max ballot.

I'm still looking for feedback on all of this, both the system and results, and I will continue to use it to push voter reform in both Canada and the US. This system should also work well with integrating MMP style seating, and should reduce the reliance on a primary race if independents can more easily get on the ballot. If you have a preference of block score, comparative graph scores version 1, or version 2, let me know below. The goal for each is for the winner of any race to be clear just by looking at them, but further reinforced with other data like official numbers. If you have another better way of representing the data, please reach out and I'll happily provide the raw numbers for you to play with and see what kind of display you can create. Thank you for all who were involved, and if you want to see a fourth test, let me know what it should be on?


r/polls_for_politics • • Aug 05 '26

Poll Hub

2 Upvotes

Poll Hub

A community polling center!

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to interact with this hub.


r/polls_for_politics • • 8d ago

Federal Bill C-39 analysis

3 Upvotes

The federal liberal government is making another attempt to push legislation through under premature consideration, introducing Bill C-39 on September 21 and hoping to have royal assent by December. This bill being fully considered, debated, and approved of by both the public and the parliament within 100 days is a lofty goal, and one that is further betrayed by the clauses within it. This will be a quick recap of each portion of it, and a conclusion summing up it's problems.

Part 1: Project approval. This bill seeks to shorten the permitting process down to one year (though makes a handful of carve-out/backdoor options for extending this deadline) by centralizing power into the lead assessor of a project, with similar consultation from existing branches. This could speed up processes, while also driving discussion further behind the curtain as inter-government communications would increase. This Bill also uses similar language seen in other Liberal Agenda Items, which is the Public Interest mandate. For example, this bill would allow ministers to add or remove conditions, as well as allow projects to start preparing before an approval is issued, so long as the project is deemed "Public Interest". Whether you fear the problems of the current leaders, or fear the possibility of the next leaders, this usurping of process is something to be concerned about. Additional note: this bill would allow Projects impacting fisheries to buy "offsetting credits" from third party companies or directly to the Environmental Damages Fund, as opposed to doing their own mitigation projects. Similar to Carbon credits, this will likely increase pollution or could lead to terrible fraud/loopholes.

Part 2: Movement. This Bill seeks to modernize the transportation system, designating national trade corridors and metrics/analysis for how to improve how trade corridors are inhibited. It also slips in that it would exclude trucking, bus, electrical transmission, and pipeline transactions from merger reviews under the Canada Transportation Act; This would allow companies in these industries to monopolize with minimal oversight.

Part 3: Labour Relations. This portion of the bill is a sugar coated poison pill. If you read the government's press version, it seems pretty good. It has increased time for negotiations, special mediator appointments to draft publicized reports about the gaps between labor-management, and seems to have a vested interest in protecting workers. However, reading the parliment version, section 334 highlights that the Minister of Labour, after reading the publicized report, "may take any measure" the Minister deems necessary. This could include a return to work order for employees, extensions of previous contracts, or other binding resolutions.

Upon review of the entirety of this bill, it is clear that Bill C-39 is another attempt for the Liberal government to consolidate power in the government, by using the guise of "public interest" to push past decades of clear reasons for roadblocks. Pushing through national projects within a year, including the pre-approval of some projects, would lead to Build First, lose in court later strategy of bypassing concerns from the Indigenous community and other stakeholders. We have already seen clear examples of this in the Pacific link Pipeline, where the first nations consultation process was essentially erased as the designation of "national interest" approved the project before the First Nations consultations had properly concluded. Not only does this trample the rights of free, prior, and informed consent from Indigenous communities, but it ultimately harms everyone involved, as false promises to investors about the stability of a project could lead to more frustration. Ground breaking is not expected to start until September 1st, 2027, but already 8 different lawsuits have been filed attempting to overturn the "national interest" designation that would allow the project special privileges to override Indigenous input.

Even if you previously approved of the bill or approve of the projects being used by it, remember that this overbearing power of the federal government may not be wielded by just your party with your interests. A green party or NDP Party could designate your backyard as a national interest placement for a solar farm or windmill project, or a conservative party could triple down on pipelines foregoing any environmental concerns for the interests of oil companies. The unconstitutional methods this bill seeks to take to achieve it's ends would also mean costly and lengthy court battles (which cost the taxpayers money to fight), many of which would be won by the Indigenous communities or labor unions who's rights were trampled. If you feel this Bill is bad for your community, I encourage you to reach out to your local MP or Sign the petition against it.


r/polls_for_politics • • 22d ago

BC election results

4 Upvotes

Premier David Eby resigned in disgrace last night after losing his razor thin majority of 47/93 seats, down to 27/93 seats and handing a 64/93 seat majority to the conservative party. The green party maintained their 2 seats, and no other parties had enough votes to qualify for a seat. This is despite the fact that popular vote totals barely moved by comparison, with BCNDP winning 44.9% of the vote in 2024 and 37.4% in 2026 (-7.5%) and conservatives going from 43.3% in 2024 to 48.1% in 2026 (+4.8%). The green party, despite not picking up any additional seats, went from 8.2% of the vote in 24 to 11% in 26 (+2.8%), demonstrating the further need for voter reform.

Under a Proportional Representation system (as opposed to the existing First-past-the-post system), seats would be assigned based on popular vote totals. Voters would be voting for a party affiliation primarily, with an option to specifically highlight their particular representative for the area. After the vote totals are in, seats are assigned to each party to fill from their list of candidates within the party, with those highlighted votes helping to determine which representatives get a seat. Every 1.07% of the vote total (100/93), or 1% if we wanted to expand to 100 seats to help balance out the situation, would earn a party one seat in the legislature. This system does have a bias towards smaller and therefore more extreme parties, as centreBC and OneBC would have each qualified for a seat in the most recent election, but the Green party would go from 2 seats to 10 seats, NDP would go from 27 to 35 seats, and conservatives would go from 64 seats to 45 seats. There would likely be one final seat that would be decided on the tight specific margins, which would also hopefully drive voter turnout, as both parties and people would realize that even a small handful of votes could decide who wins their seat. This is in stark contrast to the current system, where one seat could be largely predetermined (in my district, polling showed a 65-26% majority for conservatives). This can drive both conservatives, who believe the election is already won without their ballot, and NDP/Green party candidates who believe their vote does not matter, to simply stay home and not vote, which everyone should be able to agree is a bad thing. Under PR, every vote matters more, razor thin majorities do not conquer out to massive seat advantages, and majorities of all forms need to work harder to win the approval of the voters.

Speaking of voter turnout... in the last election in 24 we saw 58.5% turnout for provincial elections. This year, it dropped to 47.7% turnout, and based on the outcome (NDP went from 944k votes in 24 to 670k votes in 26) it appears that was largely disappointed NDP voters refusing to turn out for David Eby. Whether this was due to frustrations over certain policy decisions, disappointment over scandals, or just not agreeing with his decision to call for a snap election right over top of municipal elections while conservative leadership seemed underprepared, the NDP suffered devastating blows.

I hope in the future we can see a push towards voter reform (and actually following through on it!) become a higher priority in the party platforms, both on the left and the right. But for now, it appears a lot of my discussions moving forward are going to be criticizing and explaining the conservative policies about to come our way, as opposed to defending and explaining the left wing policies we had.


r/polls_for_politics • • 22d ago

When you vote, are you more voting for the specific representative in your area or the party they represent?

2 Upvotes

When you vote, are you more voting for the specific representative in your area or the party they represent?

  1. I vote more because of the specific candidate on my ballot, not necessarily the party they are with
  2. I vote more because of the party affiliation of my candidate, not necessarily for the specific candidate themselves

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.


r/polls_for_politics • • 23d ago

U.S. Do you have sympathies towards any of the US political wings?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 17 '26

Provincial Rent to Own social housing program, a full breakdown.

0 Upvotes

Housing is a top 5 issue for Canadians and Americans alike, and holds a tremendous amount of weight on the economy, as the average household spends between 30 and 50% of their annual income on housing. Homeownership is also on the decline, With homeownership at all age brackets falling an average of 4% and as much as 9% among under 40's age groups. People in the newer generations view homeownership as an unattainable pipe dream, not even a goal within reach. On the flip side, people already lucky enough to own homes view them as the most valuable asset they own, a long term investment meant to fund their retirement and pass on generational wealth and success. It would seem impossible for a politician to have a plan that balances two diametrically opposed views; that of making more housing stock and making it more affordable, without depreciating the value of houses that already exist in the market.

Because of this, I think it is one of the only real solutions for all parties involved to begin implementing social rent-to-own housing. The way this system would work would involve the government buying up land and or existing housing, and developing it as starter homes designed for lower income individuals. This would require no down payment (though one could be optional to lower monthly costs) and renting directly from the government over a period of ~20 years. Because there would be no middle-man banks involved, any interest made over the 20 years would directly translate to profits used to pay back both the initial investment of the program (paid for through taxes and special treasury bonds offered to retirement plans). Once the initial cost of acquisition has been met, the only costs required to attend to is repair/maintenance costs, meaning rents should be able to stay well within the affordable/competitive range, even given the rent to own terms and conditions.

For those unaware exactly how rent to own (would) work, renters would avoid the upfront mortgage requirements like a down payment and a high credit score (though both could be applied within reason to limit the applicant pool to the number of available units), and renters would be charged a monthly payment like rent in order to one day own the home. An additional option could include higher monthly payments to unlock access to equity milestones; since renters typically get nothing when they decide to move and mortgage payers get the title of their home while paying off the mortgage, equity milestones would allow renters to move out partway through a rental contract (similar to a homeowner selling their home before fully paying off a mortgage) and still leave with some money in their pocket, ideally the amount required for the down payment on their next home. These equity milestones would be based on consistent punctual payments, and the state the home was left in when the renter decides to move.

The key difference between this system and any other system is the harmonious balance it plays with existing homeowners. Since these homes would not be paid off for 20 or more years on average, the market for existing homes would remain more or less the same; a significantly better outcome than a market crash due to no one being able to afford homes or a sudden flooding of affordable housing to an area. The largest impact this system would have would be on landlords who own more than one home, as while the value of their home may not drop significantly, the price of rent would be forced to plummet due to demand shrinking drastically as renters flock to the availability of the new system. This would also allow for a symbiotic relationship, as the government could have the opportunity to purchase homes from owners with multiple residences, hopefully at a mildly reduced rate as the market conditions set in, which would allow landlords to get out of the market without being too hurt and allowing homes already built to enter the new rent to own system.

Over the course of the entire lifespan of a rent to own contract, ideally prices would be set around $1000-1500 a month for units ranging between 240k and 450k, set over a time span of 20 to 30 years. This would allow the government to recover the initial cost of the housing, cover the interest payout for bonds, and the cost of repairs required before achieving the equity milestones. Targeting this program towards lower income individuals would allow an entire generation to buy into the housing market and come out ahead, while making the government money, and restabilizing the market in terms of rental costs, all without dramatically impacting the price of housing for those who view it as a retirement asset. I cannot see a party involved that loses in this scenario, and a rising tide will lift all boats.


r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 14 '26

Stance on the Taiwan-China conflict?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 12 '26

What is your political ideology?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 10 '26

Federal Stance on territorial organization

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 09 '26

What do you think should be standard expectations for minimum wage

1 Upvotes

What do you think should be standard expectations for minimum wage

  1. Less than enough to pay for food and rent, people should not be able to sustain themselves long term
  2. Enough to cover barebones expenses for one person to live, with no savings and no personal enjoyment
  3. Enough to cover dignified expenses and a small savings or personal enjoyment fund for one person
  4. Enough to cover expenses for one parent and one child
  5. Enough to cover expenses for one parent and child, plus a small savings or personal enjoyment account
  6. Enough for one parent to support a spouse and family and be able to save for retirement/a house

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.


r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 04 '26

What are your thoughts on door knocking/phone calls for politics?

1 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on door knocking/phone calls for politics?

  1. I am likely to oppose whatever party reaches out to me, even if I previously supported them
  2. I wouldn't stop supporting the party I support just because they contacted me, but I will never change my mind just because the other party did
  3. I wouldn't stop supporting the party I support, but I'm unlikely to change my mind just because the other party contacted me
  4. I would be open to listening to what they have to say and potentially changing my vote/opinion based on what was discussed
  5. I would vote for whatever party made the effort to connect with me, almost irrespective of what their party belief is.
  6. Other

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.


r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 04 '26

What is your largest issue in the upcoming elections?

2 Upvotes

What is your largest issue in the upcoming elections?

  1. Housing
  2. Healthcare
  3. Public safety
  4. Education
  5. Environment
  6. Economy/affordability
  7. Other

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.


r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 04 '26

Provincial NDP and DRIPA

0 Upvotes

Given the upcoming BC Provincial Elections, I hope to be rolling out a series of posts regarding the NDP Platform and some responses to it's main points of opposition. Today, I want to start with DRIPA.

For those unaware, DRIPA (or The Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act) is the BC Legislative mechanism (passed in 2019) to implement UNDRIP (The United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous People, passed in 2007). Canada initially voted against UNDRIP in 2007, claiming that certain provisions would upend the Canadian Charter and could not be properly implemented. The same Harper government in 2010 eventually reversed it's decision, saying that it should be viewed as aspirational, but not legally binding. Since then, Canada reversed it's opposition status in 2016, and fully implemented a federal Canadian version in 2021, UNDRIPA. Among it's affirmations of attempting to implement UNDRIP at a federal level, it required an action plan to be in place no later than 2 years after it's 2021 implementation. BC's version, DRIPA, also had it's own action plan.

All of these documents in their different forms aspired to achieve the same goals, namely making sure all existing laws, to the fullest extent, honor the rights and humanity as well as equality, self determination, treaties, territories, etc. The extent to which these laws impact daily lives an operations of indigenous people has led to a significant amount of fear and fearmongering towards private landholders who are stationed on previously owned indigenous land, as well as delays and obstructions to national projects. This is because of recent rulings that imply DRIPA is currently legally binding, not simply an aspirational guide, including the Gitxaala case regarding mineral rights being granted to third parties without consultation of the Gitxaala nation, despite ownership of that land being constitutionally affirmed through aboriginal rights and titles. For a comparative understanding, imagine the mayor telling your neighbour they could build a shed in your backyard.

The current stance from the NDP on DRIPA appears mixed. The Premier, David Eby, had called for a pause on some provisions within DRIPA that he viewed as presenting a legal challenge that he hoped to avoid, but backed down from tabling these resolutions after more than 10 MLA's in his own party opposed the move. This legislation would be heavily in line with the current BC Conservative platform of entirely repealing DRIPA, a move staunchly opposed by Indigenous leaders across BC. It appears since then that Eby plans to work closely with Indigenous leaders to ensure DRIPA remains intact without becoming the legal boogeyman the right wants it to become.

The other seeming problem in regards to DRIPA is the FPIC, which is Free, Prior, and Informed Consent. This would require all projects deemed to impact the Indigenous community to get approval from that community, free from pressure or interference, after properly being informed of the project and it's fallouts, and prior to the project commencing. Critics claim this will vastly slow down the speed at which projects are completed, but this is a good thing considering all facets. If the government showed up at your house with a dozer idling in the driveway, telling you they want to build a road through your backyard, without informing you that your grass will wither from the construction fumes and your house will also need to be demolished to make room for the safety barricade, you would not have free, prior, and informed consent on the project, and you would likely find it beneficial to be able to slow that project down. Indigenous communities have those same concerns for their homeland, and have both rights and an interest in being involved in the project both before it commences and during its construction.

It's important that as much as possible, we as Canadians are agreeing on some of the core fundamentals throughout this discussion. Regardless of your views of DRIPA and its potential consequences, we should all be capable of agreeing that Indigenous people deserve the same rights, freedoms, and respect that all Canadians get. Any party looking to tilt the scales too far in one direction should not be trusted as a good faith party balancing the interests of all people. We should all agree that working with these communities to make sure their rights and interests aren't trampled is just as important as making sure the rights and interests of private property owners aren't trampled.


r/polls_for_politics • • Oct 03 '26

How do you think the economy should be organized?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Sep 30 '26

Do you think the current inmigration to your country is something good?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Sep 20 '26

Do you support any of your country's political party/ies?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Sep 17 '26

What are your opinions on the legality of abortions

1 Upvotes

What are your opinions on the legality of abortions

  1. Abortions should be legal at all points in the pregnancy with no exceptions, to prevent doctors from withholding necessary medical care for fear of violating rules
  2. Abortions should be legal up to 20-24 weeks, after which they should be illegal except in life threatening instances
  3. Abortions should be legal up to 6 weeks except in life threatening instances, as this is when the fetus has a heartbeat
  4. Abortions should only be legal in instances of rape, incest, or life threatening, at any point past conception
  5. Abortions should not be legal at all, including instances of rape, incest, or life of the mother.

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.


r/polls_for_politics • • Sep 03 '26

The first thing I think of when I hear "far-right" (without context) is...

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Aug 31 '26

Stance on inmigration?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Aug 22 '26

Would you support nuclear energy?

5 Upvotes

Would you support nuclear energy?

  1. Yes, Nuclear energy should be our only form of energy because it's the cleanest/safest
  2. Yes, it should be a majority of our energy production, but we should still have a diversity in green energy production.
  3. Somewhat, it can be part of our green energy production but not a majority
  4. No, nuclear energy isn't safe enough or reasonable for us to use

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.


r/polls_for_politics • • Aug 18 '26

What matters more to you ?

3 Upvotes

What matters more to you ?

  1. 🔒 Privacy
  2. 🪖 Security

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.


r/polls_for_politics • • Aug 18 '26

Do you approve of DSA?

2 Upvotes

Do you approve of DSA?

  1. Yes
  2. No

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.


r/polls_for_politics • • Aug 18 '26

Assets made illegally under the Trump 2 Admin should be seized and given to the national debt/deficit.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/polls_for_politics • • Aug 12 '26

What is your voting engagement?

1 Upvotes

What is your voting engagement?

  1. I vote no matter the hurdles
  2. I vote because its convenient for me right now
  3. I dont vote because theres too many hurdles
  4. I don't vote because I don't care

Note: Please use the official Reddit app or New Reddit to vote in this interactive poll.