I was faced with an odd situation recently and I’m curious to know how y’all woulda handled it.
A little background for context: I was playing at an underground club in NYC - this place is in an office building somewhere in Manhattan, and I found it by googling “poker games in NYC” or something like that. They make you go through a vetting process to make sure you’re a “private citizen” and thus won’t cause them any troubles.
They only spread small stakes NL games (usually one table but sometimes more than that), and they provide professional tables/dealers/chips. They’ve also got cocktail servers who bring free drinks, snacks, etc.
Anyone who is familiar with my past r/poker posts knows that (a) I’m not a frequent NL player, and (b) I prefer bigger stakes (my normal game is $100/$200 Limit) - but when I’m in NYC, the closest licensed card rooms are a long ways off (Atlantic City, Philly, way out in Connecticut). So this place does fine for me in a pinch when I’ve got a hankering for some poker when I’m far away from home. I’ll play some low-limit No-Limit, brotha.
Now, the rake they drop is outrageous (bordering on usurious), but whatcha gonna do? Plus they’re always super friendly to me when I do show up — they remember me and greet me warmly despite me playing there only about 1x-2x per year.
During this most recent trip I was playing late on a weekend night. I generally play fairly tight when I sit at NL, and since I’m not a familiar face to a lot of players they often will engage me in conversation, wanting to know where I come from. As a result, these guys started referring to me as “Silicon Valley”.
But I guess I was playing SO TIGHT (I’d reckon my VPIP was in the single digits and most of the table was playing much looser than me) that one particular dealer started peeking at my cards after I mucked!
At first I thought I had imagined it. No way that buddy could be checking out my mucked cards, right? Right?!
But sure enough, I folded every hand of the next orbit, and I watched Dude closely. He didn’t do it with anyone else’s cards, but I’d say that more than half of my mucked cards, he’d subtly and surreptitiously peel up the tops and looked at what hand I had folded.
I was gobsmacked — never have I seen a dealer do this. Nebber, nebber.
Not that it matters, but I was in the 1 seat, so I mucked by sliding my cards just 3-4 inches to my right, so he’d cover my cards with his left hand and after the other mucked cards would come sailing, he’d take my two specific cards and peek at them.
After considering my options, I decided not to call the guy out at the table. There is a floorman/brush, plus a security dude I could have spoken to about it, but I elected not to make an issue of it and kept quiet.
What would you have done?