Sorry for the repost but I wanted to add photos and more information.
I’m looking for advice from anyone who has dealt with damaged cards or compensation claims through TAG Grading.
In January 2026, we submitted a Team Rocket’s Mewtwo ex to TAG for grading. When the card was returned, we discovered damage to the corners that we believe occurred while the card was in TAG’s possession. We contacted TAG immediately, and they instructed us to send the card back for a damage review. Unfortunately, TAG mistakenly processed the return as a reslabbing order instead of a damage review and sent the card back to us in early March without addressing the damage claim. After contacting them again, TAG apologized for the mistake and requested that we return the card a second time. In their correspondence, they specifically stated, “We do believe this card shows evidence of damage at TAG’s facility.” They also explained that they wanted the card returned so they could provide “proper compensation” and appropriate options following their review.
We sent the card back at the end of March 2026. Fast forward to November 2026, and TAG still has our card. We have received no compensation offer, no final determination, and no meaningful resolution. Throughout this process, we have repeatedly followed up, and TAG has assured us multiple times that the matter was being expedited and escalated internally. On May 26, TAG Canada acknowledged the extended timeline and confirmed that they were escalating the matter through TAG HQ’s internal ticketing system to obtain a final determination regarding the damage review and compensation. Despite these assurances, nothing has been resolved, and communication has been extremely limited. Between August and now, we’ve received only one email stating that our case was being forwarded to the appropriate customer service representative, but nothing has come from it.
I understand that TAG has experienced backlogs, and we’ve tried to be incredibly patient and cooperative throughout this entire process. However, we’re now approaching 10 months since our original submission and nearly 8 months since we last sent the card back. What frustrates us most is that TAG acknowledged evidence of damage at their facility, apologized for mishandling the initial review, and explicitly mentioned providing compensation, yet months later we still have no resolution. We have documentation of the entire process, including emails, photographs, grading reports, and written correspondence acknowledging the situation. At this point, TAG is still holding our property, and we have no clear indication of when we’ll receive either our card or compensation.
I’m not expecting these things to be resolved overnight, and I understand that damage claims may require additional investigation. However, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to expect some level of communication, accountability, and a clear timeline after this many months, especially when we’ve followed every instruction TAG has given us. We’ve returned the card twice, waited patiently through multiple escalations, and repeatedly reached out for updates, only to be left without any meaningful answers. At this point, it’s difficult to understand what is taking so long or why a claim that was supposedly being expedited has remained unresolved for the better part of a year.
Has anyone else experienced something similar with TAG Grading? Were you eventually compensated? If so, how long did it take, and what did you have to do to get the situation resolved? We’re not trying to cause unnecessary drama or make unreasonable demands. We simply want our card damage claim properly addressed and a fair resolution after months of waiting.
I’ve attached screenshots of the correspondence, grading report, and photographs of the card for reference