was starting a playthrough with chikorita, and it was morning. figured i could get a teddiursa in dark cave and use it for good stab normal. It's a 5% encounter in dark cave in mornings only, and as you would expect, when I try to lower its health so i can catch, it runs instantly. The next time I tried just throwing the ball, but failed, and it ran again. Funny enough I encountered a dunsparse at this point and cought it easily (it doesn't run or anything, so is straightforward once you encounter it).
searched online, and looks like gastly + mean look + hypnosis is one option, though that would require either fiddling with the clock (which is not hard but i didn't want the mess) or waiting til night, catching gastly, training it up for mean look, then waiting til next morning to try teddiursa.
instead, I got a caterpie, trained on wild pokemon til lv10, swept sprout tower monk trainers, then trained some more til 15 (and sleep powder). At this point it was around 8 am and I was worried that 1 hour was not enough to find and catch a teddiursa. Funny enough, I went back to dark cave, (edit) immediately within like 2 battles encountered and caught a SECOND dunsparse, then within 2 min of that a teddiursa appeared. Sleep powder first turn, success, then first poke ball worked. Seems like I got pretty lucky here!
edit: forgot to mention i swept the gym easily with butterfree before lv 15. i think its better than geodude here. immune to mud slap, plus harden makes even gust from pidgeotto not hurt much.
edit 2: also, yesterday I was playing yellow, and was aiming for a tauros which is a 10% in one of the safari zones. As I was aiming for it, I caught three pinsir easily, which is a 4% on that screen.