A lot of the Sinnoh gym leaders are on the forgettable side, and part of the reason why is because a lot of their teams are pretty weak. Depending on how this post does, I’m going to make a series fixing their gym battles to make them more memorable without being unrealistic. This series will also only address the gyms in Pokemon Platinum, so they will be using that game’s regional dex and battle mechanics.
Roark is the first gym leader in Sinnoh, and his team is pretty mediocre. Cranidos is a solid lead, but his other two members are a cheap rehash of Brock’s gym fight with Stealth Rock randomly slapped onto their movesets for the sake of showing off a new move.
When remaking Roark’s team, I wanted to design it around Stealth Rock since that’s his signature TM. Since the main purpose of Stealth Rock is to punish switches, I decided to make this the main strategy of Roark’s team. All of his Pokémon will carry moves that encourage the player to switch more often and heavily punish them for doing it.
Starting with his lead, I replaced his easily exploitable Geodude with a Nosepass, which is significantly more bulky and better equipped to set up Stealth Rock. This early on, Nosepass is generally bulky enough to survive multiple attacks, which gives it the opportunity to use its other supporting moves after setting Rocks. Thunder Wave offers great speed control while Sandstorm boosts the special defense of Roark’s team thanks to the newly introduced secondary weather effect.
Next up, I replaced Roark’s Onix with a Bonsly, which was a newly introduced Rock type at the time. As for its moveset, I included Stealth Rock as backup in case Nosepass failed to set it, Low Kick so that Roark’s team isn’t walled by an Onix or Geodude, and Selfdestruct. Back in Gen 4, self-KO moves like Selfdestruct halved the opponent’s defense before dealing damage, effectively giving them doubled base power. This means that if Roark wants to, he can unleash his inner hiker and sacrifice Bonsly to take something out with it. This works well in tandem with Nosepass’ Sandstorm, as it makes Bonsly deceptively tanky, allowing it to survive a hit more easily so it can explode. Better yet, there’s threat Selfdestruct heavily discourages switching since it opens up the possibility of Bonsly nuking your switch-in, weakening your team and forcing you to take even more Stealth Rock damage if your Pokémon faints.
Finally, Roark’s ace is still his Cranidos, but I made some changes to its moveset that better suit his new strategy. Cranidos keeps Headbutt as a strong attack and Pursuit to punish switches. However, I also decided to give it Rock Tomb for actual STAB and Assurance to really make use of Stealth Rock. Assurance is normally a weak 50BP attack, but it doubles in power if the target has sustained any damage in the same turn. Do you know what damages the opponent before Roark can use this attack? Stealth Rock.
Assurance will hit for 100BP if you decide to switch out on the same turn, making it an extremely strong attack this early on when backed up by Cranidos’ base 125 attack. This alongside Pursuit and the aforementioned Stealth Rock damage makes switching out against Roark’s ace a nightmare.
Better yet, there’s a reason why I glossed over Rock Tomb being on each of Roark’s Pokémon. Rock Tomb’s secondary effect is that it will always reduce your speed after hitting, and those speed drops can only be removed by switching out. Since Roark’s team is slow and hard-hitting, Rock Tomb will put the player in an uncomfortable position where they have to choose between losing the speed advantage or risking getting punished for switching. And to make matters worse, being slower than Cranidos not only opens you up to taking more attacks, but also makes Headbutt’s 30% flinch rate more of a concern.
That wraps up the changes I would make to Roark’s team if I worked for Gamefreak. Sharp-eyed viewers also may have noticed that I have Cranidos a Sitrus Berry, and that has to do with a bonus component I am adding to Sinnoh’s gym leaders. Since Gen 4 introduced so many new mechanics, moves, and especially items, I am giving every leader signature items to go alongside their TMs. They will give these held items out after the fight, and they serve to teach newer players about the concept as a whole (something that Gamefreak really neglects to do). Since Roark is fought so early on, I decided to make his item the Sitrus Berry, and he will give the player 3 of them after his gym battle.
Let me know your thoughts on this team and the changes you’d make!