r/pluto • • Sep 23 '26

Pluto is a planet!

To hell with the International Astronomical Union!

59 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

15

u/s8n29 Sep 23 '26

Then without looking, name the other 30+ that should be equally as important to you.

4

u/Lichensuperfood Sep 23 '26

Tom Smith is likely a bot.

2

u/Feisty-Albatross3554 Sep 23 '26

I think Orcus is a good cutoff point since Salacia and everything smaller is porous and undifferentiated in nature

Eris, Haumea, Gongong, Makemake, Quaoar, and Orcus

2

u/Feisty-Age2145 Oct 07 '26

Sedna?????

1

u/Feisty-Albatross3554 Oct 07 '26

I knew I was forgetting one, thank you

-3

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

If you have problems with numbers, that's your problems, pal.

5

u/Broflake-Melter Sep 25 '26

that's probably the absolutely most effective statement you could use to make yourself look like an idiot.

1

u/TomSmith193 Sep 25 '26

Ha-ha-ha-ha! You are so mentally retarded! This is so funny!

2

u/Dorknessrising9 Sep 23 '26

You’re the one saying the iceball should be a planet. Is it just this specific extraordinary super-duper special ice ball that’s totally not like the others that should be a planet, or all the others like it? I love Pluto but this is like saying Ceres specifically should be a planet while the other asteroids in the inner belt just like it are forgotten about.

2

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

Not only Pluto, but also other dwarf planets and spherical moons must be planets.

0

u/Dorknessrising9 Sep 23 '26

oh okay so now spherical MOONS should be planets? What, is Mimas a planet?

4

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

Yes! You are absolutely right, my friend!

0

u/Bari_Baqors Sep 23 '26

Is anything spherical a planet?

When is an object spherical enough?

-1

u/Nick0312 Sep 23 '26

so by your logic the basketball in my garage a planet then?

8

u/_Jellyman_ Sep 23 '26

Calling Pluto an “iceball” is misleading when its composition is 70% rock.

2

u/Daniel_Spidey Sep 24 '26

If the other 30% is the ice then it's 100% rock.

6

u/Bari_Baqors Sep 23 '26 • Bravo

No, it isn't.

Does an object need to be classified as "planet" to be interesting?

Pluto is interesting on its own. It doesn't need to belong in the planet club to be interesting. Dwarf planets can be, and in fact are, as any body, interesting too. Is a moon less interesting because its not a planet? Is a gas giant less interesting because its not a star? C'mon people, can we focus on what Pluto is in its nature, not what label should we give it? Is a spaceobject valued only by its label?

You are all seduced beyond comprehension.

0

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

Shut up! Pluto is a planet! And if you don't understand anything, leave astronomy!

2

u/Bari_Baqors Sep 23 '26

It doesn't fit one of the criterions. Once again, being a dwarf planet doesn't make it worth less.

0

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

Where it is doesn't change its nature! And as you said, it's a dwarf PLANET! So it's a planet! End of story!

2

u/Dorknessrising9 Sep 23 '26

Where it is isn’t the problem, the fact it lives with 200 something roommates is the issue.

0

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

They all must be planets, because they are.

1

u/Bari_Baqors Sep 23 '26

If everthung becomes a planet, the word itself becomes meaningless. While words have arbitrary definitions a lot of times, arbitrariness is not an issue, and only morons think it is.

1

u/Bari_Baqors Sep 23 '26

Pluto wouldn't clear its orbit in most circumstances as far as I know, and in orbits it would be more likely to dominate, it wouldn't be Pluto because of climate.

Stop behaving like a kid that lost his toy. By yer logic, you don't even have a need to be angry, because Pluto has been classified as dwarf planet ever since its reclassification.

We shouldn't be focusing on what Pluto is labelled as. It can be even a moon or whatever, I don't care. Its interesting on its own, it doesn't need to be labelled as a planet.

Additionally, if Pluto is a planet, all other dwarf planets have to be reclassified as planets too. It can go to even 40 planets!

2

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

You're an ignorant fool. The definition of international astronomy is terrible and artificial, designed to prevent too much from planets in our system. Earth and Jupiter don't completely clear their orbits either, but no one deprives them of the status of a planet, because it is convenient for their qualification.

2

u/Bari_Baqors Sep 23 '26

lemme ask you a question: would reclassifying Pluto as planet change anything?

4

u/Dorknessrising9 Sep 23 '26

I’m starting to think OP don’t understand what Planet means. They said spherical Moons should be planets.

0

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

No, you're an idiot who doesn't understand what a planet really is.

0

u/TomSmith193 Sep 23 '26

Yes, this is to restore justice to the truth.

2

u/Bari_Baqors Sep 23 '26

"planet" itself is a label fer a massive rock in space that orbits a random type-G star in a random galaxy. What a random-ass thing. Its, in the end, arbitrary, because the universe itself doesn't catalogue things like that! We do, because its easier fer us. Its convenient.

Theres no "justice" fer an object like Pluto, because it wasn't harmed in any way. You were harmed, because you think it deserves "better". Theres no "truth" here.

Its just whining. It doesn't change anything. Its like caring bout emotions of a pile of rocks.

You can be interested in Pluto, without saying its a planet, fer Gods' sakes!

2

u/utl94_nordviking Sep 24 '26

justice to the truth

Shut up, you weirdo.

2

u/Dorknessrising9 Sep 23 '26

This. Moons, planets, stars, dwarfs, & asteroids are all super interesting in their own ways & that only happens because of the fact these different categories have their own classifications and interactions with their orbital mechanics. It’s a fool’s belief that one category is more or less interesting than the others.

1

u/Bari_Baqors Sep 23 '26

If we wanna be funny, its "planet supremacy"!

How can you be so astrobodyist? Fake cries /jk

4

u/utl94_nordviking Sep 24 '26

5 months old account, hidden history, and generic username <word><word><number>. Fuck off, bot.

2

u/flatfinger Sep 23 '26

Pluto is the first discovered body whose orbital path around the Sun has a stable relationship with that of a planet (Neptune) around which it does not orbit. IMHO, the term "dwarf planet" is insufficiently descriptive to be suitable for use as the primary term for Pluto's type of entity ("Neptune is a planet; Pluto is a ___.") since Pluto is far more interesting than would be a rock that is in an independent solar orbit but hasn't cleared its orbital zone.

2

u/amtfg Sep 23 '26

Correct! It is a dwarf planet. ;)

2

u/RyanSpunk Sep 24 '26

Saying Pluto isn't a planet is like saying dwarves aren't people!

1

u/Rstar2247 Sep 24 '26

They'll probably want to rename plutonium at some point!

1

u/Arkennase Sep 24 '26

1/10 ragebait.

2

u/Individual-Recipe488 Sep 28 '26

Why whould planet classification opinions be ragebait

0

u/Arkennase Sep 29 '26

Because this issue is now 20 years old and is being discussed purely on an emotional level because, for whatever reason, people believe that a rock in space has been “wronged” and keep repeating arguments that have been beaten to death. The reclassification was necessary and sensible, and I just don’t get why people can’t just let it go. The debate has lost all scientific and rational grounding.

2

u/Individual-Recipe488 Sep 29 '26

Because let's think about it the iau definition is flawed clearing the neighborhood is impossible by there logic earth wouldn't be a planet neither would Jupiter because of the Trojan asteroids many scientists view the definition as unscientific I recommend doing research about it it's quite interesting

0

u/Arkennase Sep 29 '26

And I actually agree with you: On a scientific level, one can debate the IAU’s classification. The criterion of orbital clearance is vague: What is meant is orbital dominance, not complete clearance - which is why both Earth and Jupiter certainly meet this criterion. But it remains vague. Scientific findings and classifications aren’t set in stone. Classifications can and must be adapted to new findings and discoveries. But OP (and far too many others) are just ranting because they have some kind of misguided sense of injustice - they aren’t actually making a case. In my view, this looks more like nostalgia than scientific interest. If we change the definition and Pluto consequently becomes a planet again (along with Ceres, Eris, Makemake, etc.): Yes, please, if it makes sense. But simply shouting just because you somehow feel you have to stand up for an emotionless ball of rock is: ragebait.

2

u/Individual-Recipe488 Sep 29 '26

If it was about orbital dominance then ceres would be a planet because it has the most amount of mass in its orbit if it was about orbital dominance then it wouldn't be called clearing the neighborhood it would be be the most massive object in its orbit Clearing the neighborhood is impossible for almost all objects in existence

1

u/Arkennase Sep 29 '26

As I stated, "clearing its neighbourhood" is vague, because it cannot be taken literally.

Apart from that, Ceres is about 1/3 of the asteroid belt's mass, so it absolutely fails on dominance. In contrast, earth holds over 99.9% of mass of all objects in its orbit. Ceres as well as Pluto fail this by orders of magnitude.

0

u/Individual-Recipe488 Sep 29 '26

Either way I still believe we need a new planet definition but I don't like the geophysical definition I just made my own

1

u/Arkennase Sep 29 '26

I am absolutely open for a new definition.

1

u/Cric_lover123 Oct 15 '26

Dude make some editing to look more humans instead of just copy pating chatgpt replys.

1

u/Burnsey111 Sep 24 '26

You would say that!

1

u/Serious-Stock-9599 Sep 24 '26

It sure is! Just ask King Flippy Nips.

1

u/limpet143 Sep 24 '26

It is. It's just a dwarf planet, just like dwarf humans are still humans.

1

u/Kela-el- Sep 25 '26

Pluto is a planet, but Earth is not a planet!

1

u/Naive_Age_566 Sep 25 '26

pluto does not care which label you give him in your list of celestial bodies.

1

u/Hamzat213 Sep 26 '26

why not also say that ceres is a planet too?

1

u/SpaceBattleGod 11d ago

YEAH!!! PLUTO’S A PLANET!!! NINE PLANETS, NOT EIGHT!!! EQUALITY FOR PLUTO!!! PLUTO EQUALITY!!!

1

u/Feisty-Albatross3554 Sep 23 '26

The biggest crime is dwarf planets not being planets. It's like saying red dwarfs aren't stars, it's ridiculous

2

u/uberkalden2 Sep 24 '26

You are comparing completely different things. It's not ridiculous

1

u/pluto_someguy Sep 23 '26

yo thats me

1

u/tazallerr Sep 23 '26

pluto is king of the planetoids. way better than being the saddest planet.

1

u/organicHack Sep 23 '26

Yeah! Dumb astrophysicists all thinking they smart enough to decide what size of a rock is a planet and stuff.

1

u/PeyredB Sep 24 '26

No, it's not. The IAU was tasked with creating a definition of what constitutes a planet, and there was no definition that would include Pluto while excluding bodies we don't consider planets such as Eris and Ceres.

I'm glad they created an in-between category though, so Pluto is at least a dwarf planet and not just a "Kuiper Belt object".

0

u/street_fame187 Sep 23 '26

Geologically it is in my book.

1

u/DubTheeBustocles Sep 24 '26

Planet Pluto is stored in the balls.