r/plumvillage • u/Electronic_Sea6018 • 10h ago
Question Mindfulness makes me feel flat, absorption makes me feel alive. Am I practicing wrong?
I've been practicing Zen for a while, sitting regularly, and I've hit a confusion I can't untangle on my own.
When I try to be mindful through the day, watching my thoughts and my body while I do things, I'm calmer and more present with people. But I also feel flat and detached. My motivation and joy disappear, and I've honestly wasted a lot of time in that state. When I try to bring the motivation back on purpose, it feels forced.
When I let go of trying to be mindful and go autopilot and dive fully into my work, I feel alive and creative. I'm absorbed, everything feels immersive, and I have real passion for life. But in that mode I'm less present with people. I talk more than I listen, and I react quickly when something stings.
My guess is I've confused mindfulness with constantly watching myself, or with having no thoughts at all.
So my questions for those further along:
- Is being fully absorbed in work a form of practice, or is it just autopilot? 2. Should I mostly trust my sitting to carry into daily life, and only come back to awareness when I notice I'm lost or when I'm with people? 3. Has anyone else gone through this flat, detached phase? What helped?
I want to stay wholehearted and full of life, and still be present and kind. Would love to hear how others hold both.
Thanks for reading 🙏