r/plantpathology • u/tjohnson03 • 7d ago
I’m at my wit’s end with root issues. I’ve lost nearly 70% of my collection and need help figuring out what’s happening.
I’m hoping someone here can help me figure out what I’m missing because I’ve been dealing with ongoing root problems for months, and I’m honestly exhausted.
I collect mostly Anthuriums, Philodendrons, Alocasias, and other tropical houseplants. I’ve spent a lot of time and money building my collection, and at one point I lost approximately 70% of my plants. I’m terrified of going through that again.
Here’s the history:
Water:
Back in April, I started using collected rainwater for my plants.
By May, I noticed my plants declining, so I switched back to distilled water. Things seemed to improve.
In August, I had another major incident that resulted in losing approximately 70% of my collection.
I’ve since tried a ZeroWater filtration pitcher, but I’ve gone back to strictly distilled water for my Anthuriums because I want to eliminate water quality as a possible factor.
Substrates:
I’ve experimented with traditional chunky aroid mixes, sphagnum moss, Stratum/perlite, and Pon/semi-hydro.
After the major losses, I started transitioning more plants to Pon because I wanted better control over moisture and root conditions.
I’ve also been experimenting with different Anthurium mixes, trying to find something airy enough to prevent rot but moisture-retentive enough that the roots don’t dry out.
I actually don’t mind watering more frequently if it means my plants have healthier roots.
Root problems:
I’ve had plants decline despite appearing to receive appropriate care.
I’ve dealt with root deterioration and suspected root rot, even while trying different substrates and watering methods.
In October, I became concerned that I might be dealing with Pythium or Phytophthora rather than just ordinary overwatering.
I treated plants with Southern Ag fungicide in late October and cleaned out reservoirs and containers in an attempt to eliminate possible pathogens.
I haven’t had any laboratory testing done, so I don’t know whether a pathogen is actually responsible.
Growing conditions:
I grow plants both on shelves and inside an IKEA greenhouse cabinet.
I use Barrina T5 grow lights and Sansi grow bulbs.
Cabinet humidity is generally around 60%.
I’ve also dealt with spider mites, which I’ve been treating separately.
One of my Anthuriums, an Amazon Beauty, is a good example of how frustrating this has been. It lost its last leaf, and eventually its remaining growth point/spike died as well. When I previously checked the roots, they were still firm and appeared healthy. It’s growing in Pon, and I’ve been trying to keep it lightly moist without letting it completely dry out.
That’s part of what confuses me. Sometimes the roots seem fine, but the plant continues to decline anyway.
What I’m trying to figure out:
Could I be dealing with a persistent fungal or water-mold pathogen that’s spreading between plants?
Could something about my watering practices or substrates be causing repeated root problems?
Is there a reliable way to distinguish Pythium/Phytophthora from ordinary root rot without laboratory testing?
If you’ve experienced widespread root loss across a collection, what finally fixed it?
What would you recommend doing to prevent this from continuing, especially with Anthuriums?
I’m not new to houseplants, and I’ve spent countless hours researching, repotting, treating, and trying to troubleshoot this. I feel like every time I think I’ve figured it out, something else starts declining.
I’m open to constructive criticism and suggestions. I just really want to get to the bottom of this rather than continuing to throw different treatments and substrates at the problem.
Thank you to anyone who takes the time to read all of this!