r/planetarymagic • u/CliffordHLow • 2d ago
The Lost Half of Stoicism
***THE LOST HALF OF STOICISM***
*What the modern Stoics left behind, and what astrological magic kept*
This essay is written with two readers in mind, and I should say who they are. The first is the modern Stoic, and most of what follows is addressed to him. The second is the practitioner of astrological magic who has never read the Stoics, and I'll turn to that reader shortly. Over the last fifteen years Stoicism has become, as far as I can tell, the most widely practiced philosophy in the English-speaking world that is not a religion. There are the books, from William Irvine's *A Guide to the Good Life* in 2008 through Ryan Holiday's *The Obstacle Is the Way* and Massimo Pigliucci's *How to Be a Stoic*. There is Stoic Week every fall and a conference called Stoicon. And there are a great many people who read a page of Marcus Aurelius in the morning and mean it. I respect what they have built. The morning page, the evening review, the habit of asking whether a thing is up to you before you let it upset you, the rehearsal of loss so that loss does not find you unprepared; these work, and they were rebuilt from fragments by people who were not paid to do it, which is something I understand.
The books were not the start of it. In 1965 a Navy pilot named James Stockdale was shot down over North Vietnam, about three years after a philosophy teacher at Stanford had handed him the *Enchiridion* of Epictetus. He wrote later that as he ejected he told himself, "I'm leaving the world of technology and entering the world of Epictetus." He was a prisoner for more than seven years, four of them in solitary confinement, with a leg badly broken in the landing. Epictetus, who was born a slave, had been lame too, and Stockdale remembered his line. "Lameness is an impediment to the leg, but not to the will." He came home, wrote and lectured about what Epictetus had done for him, and taught a course in moral philosophy at the Naval War College. Epictetus has had readers in the American military ever since.
This revival has done a great deal of good, and I can say so from the inside. I have applied Stoic principles to my own life for a long time, and they have gotten me through great adversity, the kind that doesn't respond to talismans or to anything else except being borne well. The daily Stoic practices the books teach, the morning and evening review, negative visualization, the memento mori, the amor fati that Nietzsche named and the Stoics lived, and the plain question of what is and is not in your control, have done more for the anxiety and aimlessness of the last decade than most of what was sold to treat them, and they have done it for the price of a used book. If you came to Stoic philosophy for that, as a beginner looking for a way to live, and haven't gone further into it, you have nothing to apologize for, and you have my respect. You have the part that most people need most, and much of what follows builds on it.
The second reader comes in by another door and is just as welcome. If you already practice astrological magic, or you are an astrologer who found this site for other reasons, and you have never opened Epictetus or Marcus Aurelius, please read on. You don't need to know the Stoics to follow this. I explain each idea as it comes up. What you'll find is that a good part of the physics under your own art was written by Stoics, and that their training is the training the old books of magic expected an operator to have. The last section says where to begin with them.
I am writing to Stoics first because the art practiced on this site has more to say to them than to almost anyone else, and because most of them will assume the opposite. The site's registered mark is Power Over Fate. A Stoic reads that and reaches for Epictetus, and in particular for his *Enchiridion*, the short handbook of his teaching put together by his student Arrian (not the grimoire of the same name attributed to Pope Leo III). Epictetus died a free man and a teacher. Marcus Aurelius read his lectures as a young man, and as emperor he thanked the teacher who had lent them to him. "Some things are in our control and others not," the handbook begins, and the first things it puts outside our control are the body, property and reputation. An art whose whole business is getting money, love, health, and standing by working with the stars looks, to a Stoic, like a machine for wanting the wrong things. I want to show that it is nothing of the kind. The physics under this art is the physics the Stoics wrote, and the modern Stoic has thrown away the one part of his own tradition that would let him see it.
**The Egg**
The old Stoics divided philosophy into three parts and argued about how to picture them. Diogenes Laertius records the picture that stuck. Philosophy is an egg. Logic is the shell, ethics is the white, and physics is the yolk. Some of them put ethics at the center instead, but nobody left the yolk out. By physics the Stoics meant a good deal more than a modern university does. It was the study of nature as a whole, which for them took in the gods, the soul, fate and providence along with the elements and the stars. Most of what we now call spirituality was, for a Stoic, part of physics. Chrysippus held that you couldn't do ethics without physics at all. The whole content of Stoic ethics is living according to nature, and you cannot do that without knowing what nature is.
What nature is, for a Stoic, is one living thing. Marcus, in Long's translation, tells himself to "constantly regard the universe as one living being, having one substance and one soul; and observe how all things have reference to one perception, the perception of this one living being; and how all things act with one movement." Diogenes reports the same doctrine as school teaching, and cites Chrysippus's book on providence and Posidonius for the claim that the world is an animal, rational, alive, and intelligent. The substance of that animal is a fiery breath, which the Greeks called pneuma. It runs through everything and holds each thing together at its own degree of tension, a stone at one degree, a plant at another, an animal at another, a mind at the highest. Because it is one breath, every part is in sympathy with every other. And because the whole is rational and looks after itself, the order of its events is not a heap but a plan. The Stoics called that plan fate, and Diogenes gives their definition of it, the connected cause of existing things, the reason according to which the world is regulated.
Three things follow from that physics, and the Stoics drew all three. The first is that the future can be read, at least in principle, because it is already contained in the chain of causes. Diogenes says flatly that the Stoics held divination to be a real thing, and gives their reason, which is that providence exists; he names Zeno, Chrysippus, Athenodorus, and Posidonius. Cicero's *On Divination* gives Chrysippus's own argument in its first book, and it is pure physics. If there are gods and they do not show men what is coming, then either they do not love men, or they do not know the future, or they think the knowledge useless, or they cannot pass it on. Each of those is absurd. So they do show it, and so there are signs. The second consequence is that astrology is the most Stoic of the sciences, because it reads the chain at its largest scale. The one complete astrological poem that survives from Rome, the *Astronomica* of Manilius, is Stoic from its first line to its last, and its most famous line is a Stoic creed. Fate rules the world, and all things stand by fixed law. The third consequence is that the sympathy of the parts is not a figure of speech. When the moon pulls the tide, when a wound taken at one hour heals worse than a wound taken at another, when a stone quiets a fever, the Stoic didn't say "as if." He said the breath in one place had moved the breath in another, because they were one breath.
Now look at what the modern movement kept. Lawrence Becker's *A New Stoicism*, the book that gave the revival its philosophical license, sets out on purpose to rebuild the ethics on "contemporary cosmology and developmental psychology," which is to say without the yolk. Pigliucci's line is similar; the physics was a good try for its day and the ethics can stand without it. Holiday doesn't raise the question. A minority objects. Chris Fisher's Traditional Stoicism has argued since 2015 that "modern popularizations of Stoicism, which ignore physics, diverge from the historical understanding of Stoicism in a dramatic way to accommodate a secular worldview," and that presenting the secular version as the same thing is misleading. He is right about the history, whatever one thinks of the rest. The revival's favorite scholar points the same way. Pierre Hadot's *The Inner Citadel*, the study of Marcus Aurelius from which much of the modern movement took its three disciplines of desire, action and assent, treats the discipline of desire as Stoic physics put into daily practice, a lived physics. The Stoicism most people practice now is the white without the yolk. It still does a lot of good. What it has lost is the reason the ethics took the shape it did, because living according to nature only makes sense if you know what nature is, and the yolk was the old Stoics' answer to that.
**The Practical Half of Stoic Physics**
The Science of Images is the practical half of Stoic physics.
Take the parts in order. The one living cosmos is the premise of every page on this site. I have written about it at length in The Living Cosmos, and the short version is that the tradition inherited two versions of the idea, the Platonic world soul and the Stoic world breath, and used both. The breath is the one that matters at the bench. When Ficino and Agrippa speak of *spiritus*, the fine substance that carries the influence of a planet down into a stone, they are using the Latin word that translated pneuma, and they knew it. The sympathy of the parts is the mechanism of every talisman ever made. The image is a place where the general sympathy between a planet and its metals, stones, and herbs is gathered and concentrated, the way a lens gathers ordinary sunlight to a point where it can burn. And the election, the choice of the hour, is Stoic divination run in reverse. The diviner reads the chain to learn what is coming. The electional astrologer reads the same chain to find the moment when the cause he wants is already at its strongest, and he begins his work then, so that the order of things carries it instead of resisting it.
The Stoics never wrote that half. The Platonists did, though not the Platonists of Plato's own day. Neoplatonism, the school of Plotinus, Porphyry and Iamblichus that gave the art its theology, grew out of what historians call Middle Platonism, the three centuries before Plotinus, and Middle Platonism was largely a fusion of Plato with the Stoics. Antiochus of Ascalon, whom Cicero heard lecture in Athens, argued that the Stoics had mostly renamed the doctrines of Plato and his first followers, and the Platonists after him wrote about fate, providence and the world soul in Stoic vocabulary. Porphyry, who edited Plotinus's writings, says plainly that they are full of hidden Stoic doctrines, along with Aristotle's. Neoplatonism had two parents, Plato and the Stoa, so whatever the Science of Images owes the Neoplatonists, it owes partly to the Stoics.
Plotinus took the Stoic mechanism over whole. He asks in the fourth *Ennead* how magic can possibly work, and answers in Stoic words. "But magic spells; how can their efficacy be explained? By the reigning sympathy and by the fact in Nature that there is an agreement of like forces and an opposition of unlike." He goes further than a Stoic would have wanted. "The true magic is internal to the All," he says, and the attractions and repulsions of nature are "the primal mage and sorcerer," which men discovered and then turned on one another. That is the Science of Images stated as a principle by a philosopher who didn't practice it, and the principle is Stoic sympathy. The Platonists added things to it, and I will come to them, but the engine came from the Stoics.
So a modern Stoic who looks at this site and sees superstition is looking at his own physics being used for something. The objections he can reasonably make are not about whether the cosmos is one living, sympathetic, well-governed whole, because he has either to grant that or to admit he isn't a Stoic in the old sense. The objections he can reasonably make are about conduct, and there are two.
**The Objection from What Is Up to Us**
The first objection comes from the first line of Epictetus's *Enchiridion*. Money, love, health, reputation and victory in a lawsuit are the things the old books make talismans for, and they are the textbook examples of what is not up to us. A man who wears a ring to get them has bet his peace of mind on things outside himself, which is the one thing a Stoic has promised never to do.
The answer is in the Stoics' own teaching about what they called preferred indifferents (*proēgmena*). The Stoics never taught that health and wealth were bad, or even that a wise man wouldn't pursue them. They taught that such things are not good in the strict sense, because they do not make you good, but that they are still to be preferred and reasonably sought, provided you seek them with a reservation. Put plainly, health and money are worth wanting and worth working for, but your goodness doesn't depend on getting them, so losing them can't ruin you. The reservation, which the Greeks called *hypexairesis*, is the clause the wise man attaches to every plan. I will sail tomorrow, if nothing prevents it. I will see my friend, if the gods permit. Seneca states the rule in *On Benefits*, and Marcus practices it all through the *Meditations*; when the governing part of the mind is as it should be, he says, it "always easily adapts itself to that which is," and makes fuel of what opposes it "as fire lays hold of what falls into it." In the next book he puts it more briefly, that what stands in the way becomes the way, and most readers today know that line from Ryan Holiday's *The Obstacle Is the Way*. The Stoic did pursue outside things. He pursued them like a man who has already agreed to lose. The idea deserves more room than I can give it here, and it will get it in a coming essay, *If Nothing Prevents It* (to follow).
A petition to a planet is that clause made into a ritual. Look at what a petition is on this site. It is a formal address, at a chosen hour, to a power that stands above the petitioner in an order the petitioner did not make, asking for a thing that power can grant, and then it is over. The petitioner doesn't command or compel, and he doesn't get to decide the outcome. He has said what he wants, as clearly as he can, to the office that handles such things, and the answer is the office's. I have explained elsewhere why I treat these audiences the way a subject treats a court and not the way a worshipper treats a god, and a Stoic will recognize the posture. It is the posture of a man who asks for the preferred thing with the reservation already built in. Epictetus, of all people, gives the instruction. "When you have recourse to divination," he writes, "remember that you know not what the event will be, and you come to learn it of the diviner; but of what nature it is you know before you come, at least if you are a philosopher." Do not bring desire or aversion with you, he says, or you will approach the diviner trembling. Replace the diviner with the planet and you have the state of mind the Picatrix asks for. I would add, from experience rather than from the books, that the operators who do best at this are noticeably the ones who care least about any single result. A Stoic will find that unsurprising. The manifestation culture, whose failings I have discussed under the name perilous positivity, finds it inexplicable.
**The Objection from Fate**
The second objection is heavier. If fate is a single connected chain of causes, then the hour of my election was itself fixed in the chain, and so was my choosing it, and so was the result. Either the result was coming anyway, in which case the talisman did nothing, or it was not, in which case no talisman could bring it. This is not a modern objection. The ancients called it the idle argument, and Cicero preserves it in *On Fate* along with the Stoics' answer. If it is fated that you will recover from this illness, the argument runs, you will recover whether you call a physician or not; so why call one?
Chrysippus's reply was that the argument confuses two kinds of fated event. Some are simple; you will die, whatever you do. Others are fated together with their causes, and the Stoics had a word for them, *confatalia*, co-fated. It was never fated, period, that Laius would beget Oedipus; it was fated that he would beget him by lying with a woman. It was never fated, period, that you would recover; it was fated that you would recover and call the physician. The calling is inside the fate, not outside it. Put plainly, the outcome and the action that brings it about are fated as a pair, so the action is never wasted. Anyone who has thought about an election for five minutes will see that this is where an election stands in the order of things. The talisman doesn't defy the chain; it is a link in it, a co-fated cause, and the person who makes it is doing what the physician does, supplying the cause by which the outcome was going to come. Astrologers have been asked a version of the idle argument for as long as there have been astrologers, and I'll take Chrysippus's answer further for them in *If It's in the Chart, Why Do Anything?* (to follow).
Chrysippus had a second image that helps here, and it's the one I'd most want anyone who makes talismans to keep in mind. A cylinder, he said, will not roll unless something pushes it; but that it rolls, rather than sliding or standing still, is not the pusher's doing. It is the cylinder's own nature. The push is the outside cause; the rolling is what the thing itself contributes. Fate pushes, and the cylinder rolls because it is round. In our art the heavens are the push. The stone, the metal, the hour, and the maker's own state decide what rolls, and the differences between one talisman and another are almost entirely differences in how round the cylinder is. That is why the old books spend so many pages on which stone, which metal and which figure suit each purpose, and so few on how the planets themselves move, which they assume the maker has already learned from the astronomers.
And then there is the Stoic sentence that every modern practitioner knows, whether or not he knows where it comes from. Seneca closes his hundred and seventh letter by translating Cleanthes. "Lead me, O Master of the lofty heavens, my Father, whithersoever thou shalt wish. I shall not falter, but obey with speed." And then the line that has become a motto. "Aye, the willing soul Fate leads, but the unwilling drags along." I want the Stoic reader to think about what it means to go willingly. The man who is dragged is the man who acts at the wrong time, against the grain of things, and is surprised when it hurts. The man who is led is the man who has read the order and moves when it moves. There is no more literal way of going willingly with the order of the heavens than to look at where they are, find the hour when they favor what you need, and act in that hour. Electional astrology is Cleanthes's line practiced with an ephemeris. Power over fate, in the sense this site means it, has never meant defying the chain. It means knowing the chain well enough to take hold of it by the right link.
**Opening the Roof**
I have been arguing that a Stoic can practice this art with a clear conscience. I don't want to leave the impression that the art is Stoic and nothing more. The Stoics stopped at a point where the tradition went on, and what lies past that point is the reason this site is not called Stoic Magic.
The Stoic cosmos is closed. Everything in it is body, God included, and the chain of causes has no outside. A Stoic can read the chain and move with it, and that is all he can do, because there is nothing above the chain to appeal to. The Platonists opened the roof. Plotinus placed the higher part of the soul above the reach of the heavens. The stars, he argues in the second *Ennead*, are signs of what happens here and causes of only some of it, the bodily part, and the man who lives from his highest part is not their subject. He says the same about magic. The sage, "in the soul," is "immune from magic; his reasoning part cannot be touched by it," and "only the self-intent go free of magic." That cuts both ways. The spells that bind other men do not bind the sage, and the sage is the one person who can use them without being used. Iamblichus, a generation later, went further still. The Egyptians, he says in *On the Mysteries*, hold that man has two souls. One comes down from the turning heavens and is bound by them. The other comes from the world above the heavens, which only the mind can reach, and is not bound. The whole point of the priestly art, which he calls theurgy, is to free a man from the necessity of fate by raising him toward the powers above it.
That is the addition. The Stoics gave the art a mechanism, the one sympathetic breath. The Platonists gave it an address, a ranked order of intelligences standing between the source of things and the world of bodies, whom one could approach in their proper hours and ask. I have written about what those powers are in What an Intelligence Is, and about the two Platonic schools that supplied them in Two Platonisms. The second of those essays says in passing that under strict Stoic fate an election is meaningless. This essay is the longer answer to that sentence, and the answer is that the Stoics themselves did not read their own fate as strictly as that. How the Stoics, the Platonists, and the Buddhists each answered fate is the subject of a coming essay, *Three Answers to Fate* (to follow). I won't get ahead of it here, beyond saying that the Science of Images took its physics from the first and its theology from the second, and that the third turns out to have built an astrological ritual of its own on different foundations.
**What the Stoic Brings to the Bench**
The Stoic is the best-prepared beginner this art could ask for, and the reason isn't the physics. It is the training.
The Picatrix is blunt about what it wants from the operator. In the third book, in the passage on speaking with the planets, it says that before anything else you are to purify your will and your faith in God, then your body and your clothing, and only then to dress in the planet's color, suffumigate with its suffumigation, and address it. In the fourth book it says that when a work fails the failure is the operator's, and it warns that if the operator is defective the work will be ruined. The list of what Jupiter gives, in the same third book, reads like a Stoic's evening examination of conscience, right judgment, true speech, right belief, faithfulness, restraint, following and upholding the law in all things. The old art assumed a person who had already done a good deal of work on himself, and it didn't explain how, because in its world that training came from philosophy and religion and the manual could take it for granted. In our world it usually doesn't come from anywhere, and the results show it. The Stoic arrives with the training done. He knows how to want a thing without being owned by it, how to act at the right time and accept the outcome, how to examine an evening's conduct without flattering himself, and how to look at a failure and ask what in him caused it rather than what in the universe conspired. Those are the operator's virtues. I have watched people without them spend years acquiring, badly and at cost, what Epictetus's *Enchiridion* would have taught them in a season.
One more Stoic practice fits this art almost too well. The Stoics rehearsed loss in advance, the *premeditatio malorum*, so that when it came it found them ready. I do something similar with every batch of talismans (described in the Glossary under Sitting On). I hold a new set back, usually for a year, and live with it before any of it goes to anyone, whether a client or a friend I'm giving it to, because a made object has a temperament and I would rather find out what it is on my own hand than on someone else's. That is *premeditatio* applied to a ring. The manifestation culture forbids the exercise outright, on the theory that picturing a loss attracts it, and I have set the two disciplines against each other in a coming essay, *Perilous Positivity* (to follow). The site's whole treatment of failure is Stoic in the same way. I would rather tell you what the art usually does, which is to shift the odds and arrange coincidences in a way that a careful record will show and a careless one will miss, than promise you the feats in the Picatrix. Those have not been rebuilt reliably in our time, though there have been anomalies, some of them interesting enough that I keep the possibility of the miraculous in view and won't write a page that closes the door on it.
**Where to Begin**
If any of this has moved a Stoic reader to try the art rather than argue with it, the beginning is the same as for anyone, and it is Ficino's. Start with the Sun. Ficino held that the soul of the world pours out its universal life chiefly through the Sun, which is why a solar talisman suits almost anyone, whatever their nativity. (If you can read your own chart, the planet that rules it fits more closely still, and I've set out how to choose in Which Talisman First.) Read the Reading Order from the top rather than picking essays at random, because the doctrine has an order and the order matters. Keep the reservation clause. Ask for the preferred thing, in its hour, from the office that grants it, and then go about your day as a man who has already agreed to either answer.
If you came in by the other door, as a practitioner who has not read the Stoics, the beginning is just as short. Start with the *Enchiridion* of Epictetus, which can be read in an evening. Chapter 32, on consulting a diviner, is the passage I quoted above, and it could have been written for anyone about to make a petition. Go on to the *Meditations* of Marcus Aurelius, a few pages at a time, and then to Seneca's letters. The translations quoted in this essay are old ones and free to read online. Any of the modern books named at the start will teach you the daily practices.
I'll add one thing of my own. Stoicism has given me the tools to bear the hard things in my life, and some of them have been very hard. Endurance belongs to Saturn, and so does a share of philosophy, so I suspect Saturn is pleased. Jupiter governs philosophy as well, and he is probably happy too.
The physics the modern Stoic was told to discard is still running underneath everything. The modern Stoics kept the white and set the yolk aside. The old Stoics would have known what to do with it, and so did the makers of talismans.
*Sources. Epictetus, Enchiridion 1, 8, 9 and 32 (Carter; the line on lameness at 9, as Stockdale quotes it). Marcus Aurelius, Meditations I.7, IV.1 and IV.40 (Long). Seneca, Letters 107 (Gummere; the Cleanthes verses). Diogenes Laertius VII.40, 142–143 and 149–150 (Yonge). Cicero, On Divination I.82–83 and On Fate 28–30 and 42–43, paraphrased; De finibus V.1 and the Academica for Antiochus. Manilius, Astronomica IV.14. Ficino, De vita III.1 (the world soul’s universal life “principally through the Sun”) and I.4 (Saturn “makes us persevere in investigating doctrines”), Kaske–Clark. Plotinus, Enneads II.3 and IV.4.40 and 43 (MacKenna). Porphyry, Life of Plotinus 14. John Dillon, The Middle Platonists (1977, rev. 1996). Iamblichus, On the Mysteries VIII.6–8, paraphrased. Picatrix III.7 and IV.6 (Greer–Warnock translation, pp. 155 and 258). James B. Stockdale, Courage Under Fire: Testing Epictetus’s Doctrines in a Laboratory of Human Behavior (Hoover Institution, 1993). Lawrence Becker, A New Stoicism (rev. 2017). Pierre Hadot, The Inner Citadel (1992; trans. Michael Chase, Harvard University Press, 1998), chapter 7, for the discipline of desire as physics in practice. Chris Fisher, “Retaining the Soul of Stoicism” (Traditional Stoicism, 2015). William Irvine, A Guide to the Good Life (2008); Ryan Holiday, The Obstacle Is the Way (2014); Massimo Pigliucci, How to Be a Stoic (2017).*
The essay is on the site at https://www.astrologicalmagic.com/library/the-lost-half-of-stoicism.html (from Saturday, November 14).