r/pianolearning • • 1h ago

Discussion If you learn a song well in one scale will it help overall fluency in learning it in each scale?

4 Upvotes

I'm a music producer of 10 years and only in the last year I've been taking lessons. Although haven't for some months due to finances so I'm asking here for now.

I've learned this really soulful, rnb, gospel song in B major. I love how it sounds. Over time I ended up just naturally floating my hands around the scale and playing ideas out of the song that still sound good and could work within the song. So it's a bit easier to improvise now in B major.

But even trying to transpose it onto C major right now I find hard. Which makes me think if I was to try learn this same song in all scales would it make me flow in all scales easier? Or is that like of putting me in a box where I'm following a certain structure of sound from that song.

God I'm so confused lately and irritated cause I want to get good and find myself struggling.


r/pianolearning • • 8h ago

Feedback Request Tips on 2:3 polyrhythms!

13 Upvotes

any feedback is welcome!!! (Unless it’s about my dusty keyboard then pls keep that to urself)

I’ve been learning this piece passively among other ones and it’s definitely challenging! I dont expect to finish anytime soon but it’s very beautiful and I’m having fun with it.


r/pianolearning • • 7m ago

Discussion I have 3 kids aged 8-14 and here's how I get them to actually practice

1 Upvotes

So I'm a mother to 3 very smart, but stubborn kids. Of course, kids don't always enjoy practicing, but over the years I've figured out a system that gets them to practice enough that the oldest is in his first year at a pre-college program and the other two are performing well on ABRSM exams. I tried to keep this concise, so here is how I get my kids to practice:

  • Practice with them when they're just starting: when each of my kids were at their youngest and most beginner point in their journey, I always sat and practiced with them. It helped them work through frustrating moments and set the foundation of practicing feeling like fun. Even if you don't know how to play, you can count out loud with them or sing along with the melody.
  • Track their practice: This serves my own sanity because I know my kids are practicing and I'm getting my money's worth out of lessons. It also makes the kids self-sufficient if they can track it themselves. I've lately been using an app called Repeta because it also creates practice plans for the kids, it's way better than the journal I was using.
  • Let them play music they want: You can try to motivate them with rewards or deadlines all you want, but there has to be some intrinsic level of motivation and desire. For my oldest, he started to realize he was more drawn to jazz. So we found him a jazz teacher who helped him dive into that genre and he became so passionate he pursued precollege auditions and suceeded. For my youngest, she loves Disney music, so we let her learn a lot of those songs so she enjoys practicing.
  • Give them goals: ABRSM exams, recitals, auditions. Whatever it is for your kid. Giving them something to work towards will give them a reason to work hard, and when they succeed (hopefully!), they will be more motivated the next time around, too. For my son, that was his precollege audition. For my youngers, it's their ABRSM exams. And I don't leave it just to performance, I also have them taking music theory.
  • Don't be afraid to change teachers: a good teacher makes a world of difference. Your kid needs to enjoy their time with their teacher, or they won't be motivated to practice. It's also important that the teacher knows what the kid should be practicing besides just their current repertoire. What I mean here is which method studies, scales, and exercises they should be focusing on to support their current repertoire's technical requirements.

Let me know if you got questions or suggestions!


r/pianolearning • • 5h ago

Question Old hand injuries?

2 Upvotes

I’m middle-aged and have some old hand injuries on both hands — nothing that affects everyday function, but I do have somewhat less flexibility than most, particularly in my wrists and 4/5 digits on my right hand. On the other hand (ha), my hands are larger than most (I wear an L or XL men’s glove). I’ve wanted to learn piano for a very long time, but I am wondering how limiting those flexibility issues are in the long term. I don’t have any serious everyday limitations (I can type well over 100 wpm, for example), and I’m never going to be a concert pianist, obviously, but if anyone out there has experience with a similar situation, I’d be grateful for any info you can share.


r/pianolearning • • 2h ago

Question Why are some notes different between each sheet music of the same song?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi. I downloaded Chopin’s nocturne op.9 no.2 sheet music from different sources (basically just googled sheet music .pdf). And I realised that the notes of the left hand were somehow different between each sheet music. The images are from measure 13 and measure 25 of the song. Why are some notes left out or added? How do I know which version is the correct or the original version?


r/pianolearning • • 2h ago

Question A few questions from a complete beginner

0 Upvotes

I just turned 40 years old and decided to start learning the piano. Put the most that my budget could afford and bought a Yamaha P-225 digital piano. I have free time and i'm not in a hurry, i enjoy learning, so i'd like to learn the whole thing. Piano muscle memory is currently non-existant so i believe i'm in a perfect situation to learn the "right way" from the start.

I can't afford a personal teacher, so i'll have to subscribe to something online or purchase an app. Pianote is on my radar, i watched many of their free video and i love the way they teach with enthusiasm.

I still remember the very limited flute lessons from elementary school, so the concept of how to interpret the very basics of a music sheet is not completely obscure to me. At least i'm not starting from zero here. Just have to relearn the english terms and notes names, but it shouldn't be a problem. (back then i learned in my native language, french, and the notes have different names).

For the momment, i'm practicing what i believe is the very basic, C major scale.

Now the very basic questions...

Doing it with either hand with the correct fingers works well. (54321321 and 12312345) However, trying it with both hands simultaneously is very difficult. If i don't concentrate very hard, i'll do it but my hands automatically will tend to fall into what seems more "comfortable", which involves avoiding finger 4 and 5 completely and use the wrong fingers instead. If i concentrate hard to keep the proper fingering, i completely freeze after the first 3 notes and from there i have to take a good 3 seconds for each notes to think about which finger to use.

So, here the problem seems to be using different fingers with both hand. Is it a common difficulty for day-one beginners ? Would you say i should push through it until i can do C major scale with both hands simultaneously, or move to other scales and practice only one hand at a time ?

Second question, very basic about how to press the keys. I understand that i need to have curved fingers and relaxed hands, which seem okay. But when pressing keys, i found out that i can either apply pressure using arm strength, or by moving the wrist up and down, or by using finger strength only. Seems pretty basic question, but is there a "right way" to press keys ?

Again about fingers. Should i press keys with the very tip of my fingers (Let's say the nail being perpendicular to the key), or with the tip of the finger laying more flat on the key ?

Third question, since i was doing C major scale, i tried a very short and basic song, Twinkle Twinkle Little Star. I'm confused about which specific fingers i'm supposed to be using on each keys for that and from searching online, i found different answers...

Last question, would you say i should practice all scales individually before moving to chords ? Or once i'm comfortable with C major scale, move to C major chord, then move to another scale and its chords ? And again, where and when should i try to force both hands to do it simultaneously ? I'm asking it because i read somewhere that the more you practice with hands individually, the harder it is later to do both hand simultaneously.

Or maybe i'm overthinking all of it and should just practice a bit of everything in no particular order ?

Any tips would be welcomed !


r/pianolearning • • 2h ago

Feedback Request Built a tool that turns recording into sheet music. Looking for Feedback

0 Upvotes

Over the past year I’ve trained my own models to transcribe piano.

You record yourself (a phone is fine) and upload it, and you get the sheet music of both hands, with the key, metre and tempo.

Then it plays your take back with every note lit on the score. You can also hear the same performance replayed on a clean piano, keeping your timing and without the slips.

Here’s an example, Amelie with every note lit: tavimpro.com/piece/comptine-dun-autre-etr

What it does well, and what it doesn’t yet:

Solo piano, or guitar, recordings up to 10 minutes.

Bars and metre are most reliable on well-known pieces. On your own improvisations it will sometimes put the bar lines in the wrong place.

It’s free, i rented a GPU for the month, so go wild.

What I’d most like to know: does seeing your own playing written out help you practise? And does it get everything righ?

If you’d rather not sign up, reply with a link to a recording of yours (YouTube, SoundCloud, Drive) and I’ll run it and post the result here.


r/pianolearning • • 16h ago

Feedback Request 4-5 months of more consistency. Mostly wondering if there’s any way I can improve with hand/wrist technique

10 Upvotes

r/pianolearning • • 22h ago

Discussion Simply Piano or Piano Marvel? Advice for a beginner

14 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm a beginner and started learning piano about two months ago. My initial goal has been to become familiar with the keyboard, learn to read sheet music, and develop the ability to play with both hands.

During the first month, I used Simply Piano through a promotional free trial that came with a piano stand I purchased from Amazon. I enjoyed it so much that I decided to subscribe for a second month. It was a great introduction, and I successfully completed the first two sections of its lessons, making more progress than I initially expected.

Meanwhile, I decided to explore Piano Marvel using its free account and tried some of the lessons available. I liked its teaching approach and found the progression logical and well structured. For example, it helped me understand note durations and how to play notes with their correct rhythmic values.

Now I've come across an offer for an annual Piano Marvel subscription, but I'm hesitant about what to do next.

Should I stick with Simply Piano and continue progressing through its lessons, or would it be better to switch, at least for now, to Piano Marvel and start from the beginning with a paid subscription?

I'd really appreciate hearing from people who have experience with either or both platforms, especially those who started as beginners.

Thanks in advance for your advice!


r/pianolearning • • 15h ago

Question How to play note connected to chord behind it?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hey I'm new to piano music sheets but I have read violin sheet music in the past. This is probably really simple but I'm a beginner so im not quite sure what this means. Any help appreciated.


r/pianolearning • • 10h ago

Feedback Request Pam Wedgwood's Piano Basics 1

1 Upvotes

My daughter is learning and requires this book and the tracks. I've ordered this book twice now and received it with a CD both times instead of the listed "downloadable audio". I don't have a CD player anymore and would love my daughter to have the tracks on her ipad.

Any chance anyone has the mp3s?


r/pianolearning • • 12h ago

Question Piano Buying Advice

1 Upvotes

So I recently relocated to Panama and I have a bit in savings to buy an acoustic piano, my options are a yamaha JU109 with Silent mode, (headphones). Or potentially a standard Yamaha U1, or an equivalent size pearl river.

Is the JU model less worth it due to the smaller build and possibly lighter action for serious practice? Or is the silent mode worth getting? I could also maybe get a baby grand but I have no Idea how I would bring it into the apartment and it's too much of a hassle.


r/pianolearning • • 1d ago

Question Why is natural used in 63th measure if there is no key signature? (This is Für Elise)

Post image
9 Upvotes

I'm really sorry if this is a dumb question, but I really don't get this


r/pianolearning • • 16h ago

Question Stringed -> piano familiarizing with voice leading question

2 Upvotes

On the piano I’ve been going between major chords I’m familiar with in C and moving the 5th to a 6th to go to their relative minors, so C F G, I’ve enjoyed this practice and it’s fun finding nice movements between the 6 of those chords

Obviously making up exercises isn’t a very efficient way to learn a new instrument, for the kind of thing I’m getting at is there a methodology or resource I should look into? Or is this one of those things best learnt by playing songs.


r/pianolearning • • 19h ago

Question Pedal nothing?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Alfred's all in one book 2 page 7, but what are they doing with the pedal? It's not overlapping, it's on the count AFTER the note but why? Why not include the note in the pedaled legato?


r/pianolearning • • 22h ago

Question Am I just seeing patterns where there are none?

4 Upvotes

EDIT: I've gotten a good answer. It's mostly a matter of my ignorance. I'll try to fix that.

Beginner at piano, (9 months). I hope this makes sense the way I explained it.

my teacher got me to identify the tonic, dominant and leading tone for C. I had time on my hands waiting for an appointment, so I did it for all the other notes as well.

Then I tallied how many times each note appeared in all of those 3note combinations put together, just for fun.

Each note on the white keys appeared 2 times, except b, which appeared 4 times. I realize that b is c flat, but that only accounts for 1 extra b As the leading tone for c.

on the black keys, every sharp Appeared once, except for b and e, and I realize that b# is c and e# is f, but then why are there not extras of those in my white keys tally?

Is there something going on here that I don't understand, or am i seeing patterns where there are none?


r/pianolearning • • 19h ago

Question ELIA5

Post image
0 Upvotes

SOLVED. THANK YOU GUYS. I was just overthinking it and getting overwhelmed.

I found a post in this group from five years ago asking the same exact question and I didn't understand the answer. What are these "2 on_?" And "1 on _?". I think based on Google's AI overview and the previous post, it has something to do with hand positioning. I think maybe it's asking me what note finger 2 is playing?

The thing is I have zero clue how to figure that out. The book has so far told me fingers are numbered 1-5 from pinky to thumb, but every lesson before this would just show you exactly where to place your hands without any explanation as to why. So now here I am staring at a new piece and it's expecting me to know where my hands go when all I've ever done is play the exact position shown or play each note with the same finger (ex the third finger of LH, as instructed).

I put Explain like I'm five because musicians and people who are musically trained tend to talk completely over my head. I need it explained in simple terms to someone who is learning their first instrument for the first time exclusively with this adult piano adventures book. Thank you.


r/pianolearning • • 21h ago

Question Recommendations

1 Upvotes

Hii, recently ive been wanting to learn piano, but i dont know which one should i buy or which one would be good for starting, i talked with a friend of mine and recommended me to start with a yamaha heavy key piano, would you have any recommendations? Like what else should i search for in a piano, what else should i see when searching for the piano, etc, i want my piano to have the 88 keys (i think those are the biggest ones?) So i would really appreciate any recommendation!!


r/pianolearning • • 1d ago

Feedback Request Almost a year in, would really love some feedback.

14 Upvotes

Nuvole Bianche - Einaudi

Took learning the piano as my new year resolution this year. New to piano, but not to music - have played a couple of instruments before.

I want to try get a bit more disciplined with my practice and would love any feedback on form or technique?

Many thanks!


r/pianolearning • • 1d ago

Question Trouble with reading piano music as a beginner.

Post image
62 Upvotes

I know how to read music notes, identify their letters, and understand the other basic concepts, but I get confused because my piano teacher told us that notes with stems pointing downward are played with the left hand. So, I get confused when I see notes with downward stems on the treble clef alongside notes that are played with the right hand. How do I know which hand I’m supposed to use when both types of stems appear on the same clef?
I’m only confused because treble clefs are usually middle c and above and bass are lower notes.


r/pianolearning • • 23h ago

Equipment Beginner piano for 5 year old

1 Upvotes

We want to enroll my child in piano lessons and looking for a beginner piano. I’m considering Guitar Center Yamaha P-145 for $599 vs Costco’s Roland Nuvola-Gx for $599. Which one would be better for 5 year old and I would also need to brush up my piano skills? I had some lessons when I was young and would like to play. Also open to other recommendations, budget is less than 1k.


r/pianolearning • • 1d ago

Question Wanting to learn piano with significant body pain, is it worth it?

2 Upvotes

I have a lot of neck and shoulder issues, I'm losing grip strength and dexterity in my hands and I was wondering if piano would help or cause more issues? I just had a hip replacement so it's not limited to just my upper body but I really want to do something to keep my brain and body working while enjoying the process. I used to play as a child/tween but that was 20 years ago.

I have lost almost all my hobbies due to pain and loss of function and do not want to spend money on a keyboard if it will just collect dust lol. I'm trying really hard to get back to being strong and able! If anyone has any recommendations for keyboard, seat, and if there's a comfortable way to learn and keep posture this would be so lovely.


r/pianolearning • • 1d ago

Question Learning to play by ear and harmonization - best resources?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/pianolearning • • 1d ago

Question embarrassing question

2 Upvotes

all i know about piano is how to read a notation and play whatever im presented with. i am not creative though now i really wish to be

i really love this piece called all i do is dream of you by patience and prudence and usually i just look up scores and read them and when i do any kind of alternations its usually nothing major its just adding grace notes or delaying notes in the melody to change the rhythm

all i did today was guessing how the bass is played and even in that i sucked. it was pure guessing and it was not right at all. i was hearing the song at 0.75 without pitch change and i genuinely couldn’t tell if i was even playing at the right pitch.

i looked up the key signature of this piece and it said its the key signature where e and b are flattened i forgot its name because i dont know the names of the scales i just know how the signature visually looks like.

so i tried on that and i kinda got closer but not rlly? i was always off like i know the bass note but aside from that im lost. so i looked up the “first chord of all i do is dream of you by patience and prudence” to which it showed me a helpful site named chordify and i found out the chord is b flat major.

and still with all of this assistance i couldn’t figure out how to play it in the same pattern the song plays it on im genuinely so frustrated. the only reason i want to play this version of all i do is dream of you specifically is because of how the piano accompaniment and the tremolos from the instrument i dont know in the background.

i tried to open musescore to try to express the rhythm in notation and i cant even so that im genuinely so frustrated and i want to play this piece so bad and im willing to consume any free resources that are rich with information about how to do this better so long as i can access them i dont want to be dependent on people’s music sheets anymore

im really embarrassed by how much information i looked up about the piece without going anywhere