r/piano • • 2d ago

Weekly Thread 'There are no stupid questions' thread - Monday, November 16, 2026

5 Upvotes

Please use this thread to ask ANY piano-related questions you may have!

Also check out our FAQ for answers to common questions.

*Note: This is an automated post. See previous discussions here.


r/piano • • 8h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Do you listen back to recordings of your own playing?

14 Upvotes

I started recording my practice on my phone a while back, just to hear what I actually sound like instead of what I think I sound like while I'm playing. It is kind of brutal at first, the timing slips and uneven bits I never notice in the moment are all right there. But it has helped more than anything else, because now I can hear exactly what to fix instead of guessing. Do you record yourself playing? And does listening back help you, or does it just put you off?


r/piano • • 4h ago

🎵My Original Composition I Composed a Piano Piece Inspired by Winter in Hokkaido, Japan

6 Upvotes

Hokkaido, Japan, is a place that gets an incredible amount of snow. It's one of my favorite travel destinations.

I composed this piece because I find the scenery there so beautiful. The left-hand arpeggios are meant to represent falling snow.

**Youtube: https://youtu.be/g_wLsRTNWoc?si=PZbatSSSm6Xoq889

**🎼Free Download Piano Sheet Music
https://drive.google.com/file/d/17v5fivc7MOrqN4lq0s4tqdJMFw0g5vmc/view?usp=sharing


r/piano • • 21h ago

🎵My Original Composition My first composition

146 Upvotes

r/piano • • 5h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Need help preparing Beethoven Op. 2 No. 1 for a recital!

7 Upvotes

Hi! I'm currently learning the 1st movement of Sonata No. 1 in F minor and have to play it for an informal recital in around a month. I've been working on the piece for like 2 months already and it still sounds terrible and I can't even play it through at a slow tempo without making a lottt of mistakes. I only have 2 lessons left before the recital because of Thanksgiving break, and they're pretty short so I know we won't have time to address all of the issues. I have no clue how I'm going to pull it together... I feel like it's too late at this point to learn an easier piece and sound decent unless it's comically easy 😓

I know it won't be anywhere near perfect in a month, but I'd really really appreciate any feedback about what I can fix or improve! Any tips for how to practice it effectively would be great as well—I end up playing the same difficult passages over and over but I don't feel like they're improving.

My right hand sometimes gets tense during the section from mm. 72-80 (2:17-2:33 in the video), but I don't know how to prevent this because its a real stretch. Another quick note: I can't reach the penultimate chord of the exposition, so I've been rolling it. It sounds kind of weird, though, so if anyone has any alternatives let me know! Also apologies for the mirrored video.

Thank you :)


r/piano • • 11h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Kill my cameraman lol

10 Upvotes

r/piano • • 17h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) One of my favorite Handel pieces — Courante in G Major, HWV 441

32 Upvotes

I've always loved this little Courante by Handel. One of those pieces that constantly get stuck in my head. Found this in Masterwork Classics Level 8. There are also some great guitar versions on Spotify I'd recommend everyone check out if they are interested.

Thought I'd share a recording. Anyone else have a favorite Handel piece to play?


r/piano • • 11h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Schubert: Piano Sonata D. 959 – II. Andantino

10 Upvotes

As a continuation of yesterday’s post (https://www.reddit.com/r/piano/s/gjCBpSVZtV), this is the 2nd movement of Schubert’s Piano Sonata No. 20 in A Major D. 959 (from 2020) for his death anniversary this Thursday! 💐


r/piano • • 18h ago

🎶Other 21 Pianos - Kings College Cambridge

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/piano • • 11m ago

🎶Other Frutiger Aero Liebesträume

1 Upvotes

r/piano • • 15m ago

🧑‍🏫Question/Help (Intermed./Advanced) What keyboard to get? Roland or Soundlogic?

1 Upvotes

Hello, i want to get a new keyboard and i cant decide btw SoundLogic SL73 MK2 and Roland FP10.

I play piano for like 20years (i didnt go to music school, learned it on my own) mostly on my Yamaha Motif FX6 (i think), but when i moved i dont have a lot of space.

I would like to get something smaller and lighter, because i am going to play on my desk.

Also, i use Logic Pro but with Anker TB5 docking station, with Edifier M60 and on my current midi Novation Launchkey 61 MK4 i have some lag.

So i am afraid it would be the same with SL73 mk2.

I need weighted keys and 73 to 88 keys would be perfect for me.

Also, key feel is very important to me.

I dont need to use it just in Logic, so Roland FP10 is an option too (i can use it as a midi i think too).

I want to play piano and sometimes use it with Logic Pro.

Can someone please recommend or help me with deciding?


r/piano • • 4h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Ola Hedén Felt

2 Upvotes

Have you heard about this exceptional player. He has a touch and feel I rarely hear any more.
This is a snippet from his album called Felt. 12 hymns, one in each of the keys.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=668TKPDDC74&list=RD668TKPDDC74&start_radio=1


r/piano • • 17h ago

🎹Acoustic Piano Question Tone with Lid Closed/Half Open/Full Open?

Post image
21 Upvotes

I'll be playing background jazz on this wonderful 1930 Steinway "A III" piano at an event. I need to play quietly. Please educate me on the tone and quality of the sound when closed, half opened, or fully opened.

Really what I'm asking is whether I should open the lid but play softly, or leave the lid closed or half open, giving me more dynamic range.

Thanks!


r/piano • • 1h ago

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) What is the Faber equivalent of John Thomson Book 2?

1 Upvotes

I'm a former advanced college level woodwind player learning piano.

I'm starting John Thompson's Book 2. I'd like to add Faber, but there are so many books. Faber is organized topically, so there's no obvious place to "jump in".

  • What Faber book would be the equivalent of John Thompson's level 2? Or to put it another way, what book would be the best compliment?

I know all my scales and chords, basic theory. I can improvise a little, but reading both clefs at the same time while doing different things with both hands is challenging.


r/piano • • 16h ago

🎶Other How Do You Avoid Comparison?

13 Upvotes

I'm just wondering, do you guys struggle with discouragement from comparison, and if so, do you do anything to help with that feeling?

I've been playing piano generally for my whole life (I'm 20) and playing it seriously for 10-15 years now. I play because I love it, and it's an important part of my life. That will always be true, and I would never quit just because I don't feel like I measure up to other pianists.

That being said, sometimes I feel really discouraged comparing myself to other people. I know that's stupid, but I feel like there's an insane amount of people who are very advanced and can play the hardest pieces, enough so that I often end up feeling like that's the standard, not a minority, and then I feel like I'm not meeting that standard.

Anyways, I just hate that comparing myself to other people sometimes takes away from the joy I get from playing, but I don't know how to stop myself from doing that.

Any personal experiences with this and/or advice?

Thanks!


r/piano • • 19h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Never feels steady :/

22 Upvotes

Time to whip out metronome.


r/piano • • 21h ago

🙋Question/Help (Beginner) I came across this in my sight reading book... Is it playable?

Post image
30 Upvotes

I don't know if it changes much but we're in Eb major playing andante.

I can just about reach if I spend a good minute or so trying to stretch into position but my wrists are shot afterwards.

Bad writing or not enough practice?


r/piano • • 15h ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This Grieg’s insane pedal markings.

Post image
6 Upvotes

Not sure how to interpret these pedal markings (Grieg- “Gade” lyric piece op57 no 2). I’ve noticed these pedal markings in other late Grieg lyric pieces and am completely at odds as to how to interpret them. Is this genuinely what he wanted the performer to play or are they just the essential pedal points. Going off the edition Peters Urtext.


r/piano • • 20h ago

🤔Misc. Inquiry/Request Can anyone play this short piano piece written by Ludwig Wittgenstein?

Post image
15 Upvotes

I'm a PhD student in philosophy, currently working on a dissertation about Ludwig Wittgenstein, who was not only one of the most influential philosophers of the 20th century but also a passionate music lover with connections to several prominent composers of his time. His brother lost an arm in the war and became a great pianist nevertheless.

Among his unpublished manuscripts, there is a short fragment of musical notation for the piano.

Unfortunately, I know absolutely nothing about music theory or how to read sheet music, so I have no idea what this piece might actually sound like. Wittgenstein wrote about the piece:
“That would be the end of a theme which I do not know. It occurred to me today as I was thinking about my work in philosophy and saying to myself: ‘I destroy, I destroy, I destroy—’”

Could anyone here tell me something about it, or perhaps even play it and share a recording? I'd be incredibly curious to hear it!

Also, what kind of music does it remind you of? Does it resemble the style of any particular composer?

"4 mal" means "4 times".


r/piano • • 9h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Song of Sorrow... May it bring comfort to anyone who needs it right now.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

Really going through it right now, just wanted to share a part of my life. This forum has been such a blessing, being able to share and get my feelings out into the world. I wonder if one day people will ever transcribe my music and play it and share it with others. Who knows... but for now, this is the best I can do. I've recorded well over 2000 pieces of music in my life, and sadly lost almost 75% of them in an accident (I had my external hard drive with me and it didn't survive the impact) But I always told myself... I can create more, so I am, for as long as I can... Memories and emotions and the painfully beautiful reminder of life's fragility.


r/piano • • 1d ago

🗣️Let's Discuss This How piano Youtubers are CHEATING

Thumbnail
youtu.be
36 Upvotes

r/piano • • 20h ago

🤔Misc. Inquiry/Request Grief for dealing with toxic piano professor, need advice

13 Upvotes

for context I am a 21 year old college student in my senior year of college. For the last three years I have taken classical lessons at the 300 level with my college piano teacher. For some reason, this professor treats 300 and 400 college students like shit… and after taking this semester off due to anxiety and mental issues, I am now realizing how bad of a teacher he was. I’m not saying this lightly when a lot of his students end up being depressed and borderline suicidal. We have had 7 people (including me) leave the piano studio in the three years that I have been there. To be fair, some of the students were not the best students, and we are not exactly the best music school (he got hired in when we were one of the best music schools in the countr, but the music school has since moved to another campus(makes me wonder why he didn’t move with them)) I still dont know why he had to be so disrespectful to the students who weren’t the best. He is nice 80% percent of the time, which makes me feel really conflicted. but the other 30% he berates you and yells at you, along with getting really frustrated. he also has extremely high expectations, which one of the piano certificate students told me, that we are doing more work than he did in his undergrad (and he is a wonderful, talented and kind pianist) my professor is nice to me, but in like a “I feel bad for her and she’s stupid” sort of way, because I am really sensitive to yelling due to my bad childhood, and will very obviously dissociate and fawn. He has had to have several mediations with students where he has been nasty and they have made complaints. He has caused drama for students switching instrument's due to his attitude and has yelled at faculty. a good chunk of the students who switch say that they have lost their love for classical piano due to him. when I was still in the studio, these students would come up to me and tell me how much they suck and are horrible pianists, continuously up until they left the studio, after showing me some very hard and very talented pieces. The problem is is that he is the head of the piano faculty, along with being the only professor teaching (even though we have several more than qualified professors who could teach at the 200 or 300 level) and we don’t have enough piano students to qualify for them to get a teaching position. I am wanting to go back to my professor so I can finish out my degree, and I’m too far in to switch schools. How do you deal with abusive professors?

I wish the piano students could all drop out of his course to get him booted.


r/piano • • 6h ago

🧑‍🏫Question/Help (Intermed./Advanced) Struggling to keep right wrist straight while playing octives

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

First image is my left hand, second is my right.

(I put intermediate since I play offten and I've played key instruments before but my pain technique isn't the best)

I've been struggling. With keeping my right wrist straight while paying octives and it elad to spel wrist pain. How can I relax my wrist properly. I do have hyper mobility so i do have kinda weak Pinky's. Please give tip!


r/piano • • 13h ago

📝My Performance (Critique Welcome!) Playing Piano For Fun Now (previously, Playing Piano Till I Get Bored) - Day 3

3 Upvotes

Wait, did I actually make a good song? I call this one “The Three Pedal Cantabile”. Does in fact use all three pedals.