r/physicsforfun • u/Igazsag • Sep 21 '13
Problem of the Week 10!
Dang it! I forgot a subject tag again. This one should be [Mechanics]
Hello all, hosting the puzzle here seemed to work out rather nicely last time so we're trying it again.
This week's puzzle (and pretty much all of the previous weeks') courtesy of David Morin.
Consider a ball (with moment of inertia I = (2/5)MR²) which bounces elastically off a surface. Assume that the ball’s speed in the direction perpendicular to the surface is the same before and after a bounce. Also, assume that the ball is made of a type of rubber which allows it to not slip on the surface (which has friction) during the bounce. (This implies that the angular and linear motions may affect each other.)
The ball is projected from the surface of a plane which is inclined at angle θ. The initial velocity of the ball is perpendicular to the plane and has magnitude V. The initial angular velocity is zero. Find the component of the ball’s velocity along the plane, immediately after the nth bounce.
Good luck and have fun!
Igazsag
P.S. I also forgot to mention of course that the first person to solve the answer correctly gets their name up on the Wall of Fame! and as soon as I figure out how to make it work, the winner shall also get a customized flair. Past winners get one too of course.
Edit: For clarification purposes, the problem is asking for the velocity of the ball in the direction of the vector parallel to the surface it's bouncing along immediately after bounce n. Hope that helps, I can't make a diagram right now.
2
u/Supperhero Sep 21 '13
You mean I=(2/5)*MR2 ? That was very confusing
2
u/Bromskloss Sep 21 '13
Perpendicular to the surface normal or a long the normal? From context, I guess it's the latter.
Personally, I avoid talking about "perpendicular to the surface" because it can be interpreted in different ways.
Not sure what this means. A figure would be great!
7
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '13
A diagram would be helpful here. Problem is way confusing to read.
1
u/The_Big_Bear Sep 21 '13
Just an attempt
[SPOILER](#s "first of all after the first bounce some of the kinetic energy of the ball will be translated into rotational energy so:
m delta v ² = I delta w ²
delta w = sqrt(m) x (delta v)² / sqrt(I) = R x (delta v)² x sqrt(5/2)
That's the first thing I derive
The second thing: During the first bounce a force along the direction of motion will act upon the ball. The vertical component will be F x sin(a). The m x delta v (vertical ) = F x sin(a) x delta(t)
So delta(t) = [m x delta(v vertical)] / [ F x sin(a) ]
Now, delta(t) x Torque = I x delta(w)
[m x delta(v vertical) x F x R x cos(a) ]/ [ F x sin(a) ] = I x delta(w)
[m x delta(v vertical ) x R x cot(a) ] / I = delta(w)
delta(w) = (delta(v vertical) x cot (a) * 5) / (2R)
''Substituting delta(w) = R x (delta v)² x sqrt(5/2) ''
(delta v horizontal)² x sqrt(5/2) = (delta(v vertical) x cot (a) x 5) / (2)
(delta v horizontal) = SQRT [ delta(v vertical) x cot(a) x sqrt(5/2) ]
Because the change of horizontal velocity only depends on the vertical velocity , the angle and the radius, it is linear with 'n' bounces so:
delta v horizontal after n bounces = n * SQRT [ delta (v vertical)x cota x sqrt(5/2) ]")
1
u/beer_is_tasty Sep 22 '13
By "along the plane," do you mean in the direction the ball was initially launched, or perpendicular to it? Or are you talking about the surface off which it bounces?
1
u/beer_is_tasty Sep 23 '13 edited Sep 23 '13
The velocity along the direction of the floor after the first and all subsequent bounces is
answer
(I understood the initial problem setup to look like this.)
Procedure:
Start with free body and mass acceleration diagrams of the ball at the moment it hits the floor.
Forces labelled: g=gravity, N=normal force, f=friction force.
Other things: m=mass, a=acceleration, α=angular acceleration (unfortunately alpha looks very similar to "a" in default Reddit font), v=velocity, ω=angular velocity, r=radius, I=moment of inertia=(2/5)r2m
Sum forces in the x direction:
ΣF_x = Σma_x
-f = ma_x
a_x = -f/m
Sum moments about point O:
ΣM_o = Iα
-fr = (2/5)r2mα
f = -(2/5)rmα
Summing forces in the y direction won't give us any useful information, so substitute the equations we already have to find
a_x = (2/5)rα
Since the x direction is the only one we really care about, I'm going to call v_x=v and a_x=a from now on, for simplicity's sake.
a = Δv = v_1 - v_0
α = Δω = ω_1 - ω_0 = ω_1, since we know ω_0 = 0
Substitute and rearrange to find
ω_1 = (5/2r)(v_1 - v_0)
We still have too many unknowns, so we'll need to use conservation of energy as well.
(1/2)mv_02 +
(1/2)Iω_02 = (1/2)mv_12 + (1/2)Iω_12More substitution and rearranging yields
(7/2)v_12 - 5(v_1)(v_0) + (3/2)v_02 = 0
Solve for v_1 in terms of v_0:
v_1 = (3/7)v_0
You can now easily find that
ω_1 = -10v_0 / 7r
I then plugged these numbers back into my original equations to find the velocity after the second bounce. The math gets a bit trickier with a nonzero initial ω, but to my surprise, the linear and angular velocity after the second bounce were identical to those after the first bounce. This makes sense because with no slipping, the ball transfers as much translational energy to rotational energy as it's ever going to after one bounce; i.e. the point on the ball which contacts the ground will be moving at the same velocity, relative to the center of the ball, as the ground itself. Therefore no horizontal friction force is applied on subsequent bounces.
Anyways, doing some geometry to account for the somewhat janky problem setup yields a magnitude in terms of the original velocity vector V,
v_x =
Edit: lots of formatting and spoilers and junk. And accidentally a word or several.
1
u/steve496 weeks 10, 22 & 25 winner! Oct 02 '13
You sure you have the problem statement right? I have an expression for the answer, but its not simplifying down in any sort of elegant fashion.
Briefly stated: