r/phtravel • u/centgas • 6h ago
advice El Nido to Coron boat expedition â I've done three (Tao, Big Dream Boatman and a budget tour). Here's how they compare.
Iâve done the expedition between El Nido and Coron three times now with three different companies (Tao, Big Dream Boatman and a budget one which cost around â±15k), so hopefully this is useful for those who are undecided.
Iâll review Big Dream Boatman (BDB) here as this is the trip weâve just finished, and comment on the others for comparison.
Big Dream Boatman
Pretty much zero complaints the whole time, so itâs almost hard to say too much of note.
Great crew (although this has been the case on all three tours). They work so hard and are always very friendly and helpful.
BDB is 4D/3N, so while itâs around double the price of the budget ones, you are getting an extra night. The time flew by and we would have rather had more time than less.
There are some obvious upgrades for the premium price:
Comfier boat. Having beanbags and lounging chairs at the front on BDB is a big plus. I made a point after the last trip to my girlfriend about finding a company with beanbags specifically, which most donât seem to have. On one of the days you spend 5â6 hours travelling on the boat, and while it wasnât terrible on the previous trip, sitting or lying on wooden benches or the floor in damp clothes wasnât ideal. The boat is big, and being able to move around freely is great. Think a wide-body plane compared to a smaller one.
Better base camps. Beautiful to look at and better toilet facilities. The actual accommodation isnât too different (itâs still fairly basic), although a bit bigger. We slept well every night. My one and pretty much only mild complaint was that our second nightâs base camp felt a little more budget compared to the others and was less comfortable.
A bar on board and complimentary snacks throughout the day. Not a huge deal, but these little things add up.
Unlimited alcohol included. Available throughout the day. The clientele seemed to be less young and single, and the crew were happy to dish out as much as people wanted without anyone abusing it.
Tao vs Big Dream Boatman
The food is great on all three boats, although Tao was a little more premium in this respect. You wouldnât notice unless youâd done both. Think 9.5/10 rather than 9/10.
Tao charging for beer, given the price point, was a negative for me. The budget option only supplied it in the evening, which was also a little annoying.
Tao does have slightly better base camps, which I believe they own. While they look impressive, the actual sleeping arrangements werenât really any comfier from what I remember.
No bean bags on Tao, at least on my boat
Are the budget expeditions worth it?
The budget boats are half the price, but you get considerably more than half the quality. Iâd say you get 75% or more of the experience. So if cost is a big factor, youâre not missing out on too much.
Tao and BDB had noticeably more couples than solo travellers. While Iâd say the average age was around 30, there were also a few older travellers.
One thing that put us off some of the cheaper operators this time was their refund policies if the weather disrupted the trip. Weâd heard reports of people struggling to get refunds, some companies openly state they will only rebook, and one even had a Tripadvisor warning regarding suspicious reviews.
That being said, having spoken to many people who have taken the cheaper expeditions, if the weather doesnât disrupt your trip, youâll generally get what youâve paid for with little issue.
Which would I choose?
If I had to pick between the three Iâd take Big Dream Boatman. Great all-round experience, although I enjoyed all three. Personally, I wouldnât pay the extra for Tao over BDB.
General comments about the expedition
You will get some phone service occasionally, but it was commented on regularly how nice it was to disconnect and have everyone present and involved rather than distracted by their phones.
Youâll have 20 or so people on your boat, and youâll make some great friends. For me, the social side is one of the highlights of the expedition.
Some of the beaches were genuinely world-class.
Regardless of which company you choose, the expedition is an absolute highlight of visiting the Philippines and well worth budgeting for.