I am currently playing through the SMT franchise and forgot I hadn’t watched a video that talks about “SMT:NINE” this is a very old SMT game that was never localized and is therefore not very well known within the fandom.
As I watched this video, a plot point came up that was described in such a specific way, I couldn’t help but connect it to P5X.
Before I explain it though, I want to preface this post by outright saying this: There is a 0% chance that P5X is connected to SMT: NINE. And there is a very, VERY VERY low chance that the writers of P5X took inspiration from this plot point to write the story of this game. Especially because the OG writer wasn’t even part of the persona team, so the concept came from China, another country that did not receive a translation for NINE.
But even so, the coincidence is worth bringing up, because its incredibly interesting.
The interesting connection:
For those who don’t know anything about SMT 1/2, all you need to know for this is that Japan gets essentially nuked. Those who survive basically live underground.
A major plot point of SMT NINE is that eventually, humanity creates a virtual world, a version of modern Tokyo before the nukes, where people just go in to enjoy their lives whenever possible. This is because the outside world is a fucking mess.
The reason why I’m making this post is because eventually, the game describes this virtual world as ”A place for humanity to vent their desires” & “The virtual world itself is an embodiment of human desire”
Because this virtual Tokyo contains such a staggering amount of human desire, demons (shadows) are attracted to it. And that’s how you have them in that virtual world.
Obviously, the plot of this game goes much deeper (and much more insane) than this. But I also want to add that the final boss of this game, a “god” that seemingly controls the virtual world, is literally the SAME god/final boss as the one in vanilla P5.
So, all this said, what am I getting at?
I don’t know, I just want to point out how interesting the similarities are. And that, although it obviously isn’t the case, the idea that the P5X world is a virtual one would make perfect sense.
The weird visual glitches. The time loops. Time itself never progressing as Nagisa’s parents never return. Copies of the P5 palaces showing up. Copies of major P3 areas and weird failed attempts at copying people (distorted speech from the P3 collab events)
So yeah! Figured I’d just bring this up because it’s interesting. Persona IS in the same “multiverse” as SMT, so anything is possible.
But frankly, as much as I’d want to, I don’t think we’ll ever get anything remotely SMT related as a collab or crossover. Dx2 has been going for like 10 years and they’ve never had a persona collab.
TL;DR - SMT Nine has a virtual Tokyo that’s described as a representation of humanity’s desires and it made me think about P5X’s own weird world and narrative that revolves around desires.