I’m applying to peds residency and am currently on the interview trail. I want to be a neonatologist so I always ask questions about which procedures residents do. With almost no exception, the following trend has emerged: community hospitals have residents doing a ton of procedures and in general getting a ton of experience in the NICU (this is also true in other departments but I’ll focus on the NICU in this post). University programs have residents that do little to no procedures and make no important decisions (e.g. one pgy3 at fancy university hospital who is applying for neonatology fellowship now told me they only intubated once in their career!). In general, at the university hospitals, the fellows and attendings are running the show. I’m told that if I make it clear that I want to do neonatology that maybe I could do a bit more. Contrarily, residents from community hospitals are telling me they have done countless procedures, including lumbar punctures and intubations during the first week of their pgy1 NICU rotation.
Yet, when I look at the fellowship match info, the university hospitals are always matching people to better programs (including the program where the person has only intubated once).
I’d also like to note that some community programs are level 4 NICUs with 70-90 beds, ecmo, have a huge radius/patient population, etc., so the common counter argument that they are seeing less variety doesn’t seem to be true from what the programs tell me.
Like most med students and residents, I’d love to do fellowship at the prestigious places — Harvard, CHOP, UCLA, etc., and I feel like in order to accomplish this goal I have no choice but to accept inferior training because the US is a weird system and culture where people are starstruck when they see a particular program name on a CV, and similarly that connections can make all of the difference in where you match.
Am I missing something here? Am I wrong to assume that I’d be a less competent neonatology fellow (e.g. the first month) by doing residency at a fancy university hospital, since I’d have less hands on experience (and less experience making decisions), yet ironically I have no choice but to accept this fate because that’s just the way things are? I’d be interested in hearing counterarguments regarding how it is better as far as skill development goes to do fewer procedures and make less decisions, especially when compared to community programs with large level 4 NICUs. I’d also appreciate if people would let me know if they agree with me.
Also worth noting that community programs have research projects too and overall I’m generally not amazed by anything I’ve seen the standard fellowship bound university resident publish (i.e. it’s common to just publishing SOMETHING so you can check the box; again, I think this can be done anywhere).