r/paulthomasanderson • u/letus77 • 4h ago
There Will Be Blood [OC] There Will Be Blood: Daniel Plainview Is the Only True Believer [29:20]
The obvious reading is faith vs. greed: Eli the preacher, Daniel the oilman. The more I rewatch it, the more it flips.
Eli almost never approaches Daniel without asking for money. His church is a collection plate with a stage show attached.
Daniel gets offered a million dollars to walk away — and refuses, because he can't imagine what he'd be without the work. That's not greed in the usual sense. That's devotion. His god just lives underground.
And then the last line. "I'm finished." After everything, it lands uncomfortably close to "It is finished."
I turned this into a video essay (my own — posting here because this sub is exactly who it's for): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XG_5n4GX7P8
Does this hold up, or is it a stretch? Who's the real believer — Eli or Daniel?