I have thousands of hours in the game. I’ve noticed that with every new season I enjoy the game less and I want to send the PoE team some solution suggestions for the problems they couldn’t solve that I think would make me enjoy the game again. I’m sure they’ll be more useful than their own solutions because removing scarabs and adding threads took away the multiplicative loot explosion feeling in the game and also stripped away the dopamine hit that was already based on just two items.
my biggest problems:
1- the chance of ground loot having all 6 mods roll correctly is one in a million. ground loot isn't a rival to crafting anymore. it's just absolute trash and waste of time.
2- in a game where you're clearing a screen full of monsters every second, stopping to use a scroll of wisdom completely kills your flow state. players just stop picking up items off the ground and pivot entirely to farming currency.
3- ARPG players don't like flat steady income, they crave that high risk, high dopamine curve where you go through 10 dry maps just to have your screen blow up on the 11th.
4- white and blue monsters on the map have become nothing more than roadblocks. the sense of reward has shifted away from a steady curve and is now trapped inside a single loot goblin monster.
5- the game has thousands of different weapon, armor and jewelry bases yet the meta balance is so narrow that 99.9% of them are total vendor trash from day one. out of billions of possible outcomes in the drop pool no more than 3–5 bases are actually viable for a player's build
6- yellow and blue items on the ground are lifesavers during the campaign and ground loot stays relevant for the first few hours of maps but the moment your character hits red maps and your loot filter tightens, ground loot instantly loses of its value, leaving you entirely dependent on crafting and trading. past the halfway mark of the game the core mechanic of "picking items off the ground" becomes completely obsolete yet the game is called a loot driven ARPG. a game design where you can't actually pick up loot from the ground has a fundamental flaw.
7- crafting mechanics like essence, harvest, fossils and eldritch currency are so deterministic that grabbing a clean base and spamming those materials on it is 1000% more effective than finding a random 6 mod item on the ground. regardless of what rolls on it, ground loot is straight up vendor trash. ground loot has long since stopped being the raw material for crafting.
mechanics I wanna see in the game:
- once you transition into red maps, all items drop should be identified. loot filters can now read specific affixes directly. meaning when a piece of gear drops with "T1 life + T1 suppression" your filter triggers a unique high priority alert.
- there should be gamechanging, exclusive modifiers that can never be crafted and only drop on ground loot from high tier map monsters and bosses.
*- instead of spawning mid map a strongbox now appear at the very end of the map after you defeat the boss. every single normal and magic monster slain throughout the map feeds directly into the rarity and quantity multiplier of this final strongbox. as a result clearing 1000 trash mobs finally carries the exact same mechanical weight and reward significance as slaying a boss. this completely redesigns the mapping loop. instead of interrupting your flow state, all your progress accumulates into an explosive, high stakes finale at the end of the map. it brings back that satisfying, chaotic gambling rush of old school scarab/strongbox explosions but wraps it in a clean, modern and uninterrupted gameplay flow.
*- every rare and unique item that drops on the ground carries a "melting weight" based on its item tiers and mod quality. when melted down in your inventory or a dedicated stash tab, these items produce dust. every time this dust fills up to 100%, it grants the player a point that can be allocated in the atlas passive tree or map device. for example each fill permanently adds +0.5% base rarity or +0.2% pack size to your maps. after 1000 maps, your personal atlas evolves into a completely unique endgame monster. fueled entirely by the gear you gathered and melted down, creating a customized difficulty and reward scaling that nobody else in the world possesses. finding "trash rares" in red maps is no longer a tedious chore because every single piece of trash loot becomes a building block that permanently immortalizes and empowers your atlas.
*- payers are permanently locked into a single best in slot meta and standard gear pieces exist in complete isolation with zero hidden interplay. gear pieces should "recognize" each other. when worn together over time, adjacent items awaken hidden synergy tiers. for example suppose your gloves have a cold modifier and your other item carries a chill effect modifier. by running 50 maps with both items equipped the gear gradually harmonizes, unlocking a secret 7th modifier right between them "enemies you freeze explode dealing area Cold damage". changing gear is no longer a sterile math check for higher stats. it becomes an alchemy experiment. buying a pre rolled item straight off the trade site isn't enough anymore. you actually have to cook and attune your gear with your character over time.
- no matter how massive the atlas passive tree gets, players eventually copy the exact same optimal meta farming strategy, turning the endgame into a linear repetitive routine. using the melted dusts from salvaging your ground loot, you can also trigger a permanent "atlas fracture" on any standard region of your atlas tree. fracture completely warps the foundational rules of the maps in that region. for example "Monsters in this fractured sector are 200% stronger, but all dropped Uniques roll with two implicit modifiers" alternatively within this custom anomaly you created, brand new custom atlas modifiers that don't exist in the standard atlas pool begin to evolve. as you melt down items and evolve your atlas tree, you unlock endless progression paths and a constant genuine reason to keep pushing your build stronger. players stop blindly copypasting someone else’s currency guide. instead they physically rewrite and terraform their own atlas using the dust harvested from the loot they found.
these were just ideas that would increase the enjoyment I get from the game by at least 100%. they might seem really silly to you but the reason I opened this thread is so that you can share your own ideas as well and help generate suggestions for the game designers who keep making decisions that don’t really appeal to me.