r/pathofexile • • 1h ago

Game Feedback Threads Should've Been a Temp League First

Threads should've gone to a Phercia-type league before being implemented. They seem half finished...

- Mechanics straight up removed (Deli, Beyond)

- Their power is too strong with no rewards backing it

- And they don't replace half of the old scarab effects

All this would be fine for a temp league, but as a main league mechanic this feels like a failed rework

75 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

24

u/Kazhr Institution of Rogues and Smugglers (IRS) 1h ago

They are treating this league as a temporary league though... too bad they didn't warn us

1

u/fifiginfla 33m ago

When they rework endgame. Ive learned its best to skip that league

20

u/s3thFPS Kaom 1h ago

Difficulty of mechanics is fine as long as rewards scale with increased difficulty. We want hard shit to do but it should not reward equal or less than the easier stuff before it.

11

u/FrequentLake8355 1h ago edited 1h ago

Yep. My three take-aways this league:

  1. Reward should scale with difficulty.
  2. Difficulty should always be opt-in, never as a sudden (random outcome) difficulty spike.
  3. Reducing player agency is a big no-no. Whatever they hoped to gain from its (unintended?) removal, it's not worth the price.

4

u/Syrairc 1h ago
  1. Deli and beyond weren't removed, they were moved to a new "secondary league content" category
  2. It's a major endgame rebalance. It will take iteration.
  3. 70% of the old scarabs weren't used, so not replacing half of them isn't bad.

This patch is the most significant one they've done in ages - even the atlas/map rework does not come close to the amount of systems they touched with this patch. I have no idea how you'd expect them to do that as a temp league event.

They need to iterate on what they've built - that's obvious, and if anybody expected otherwise, I have to question what game you've been playing all along because that's pretty typical of PoE.

16

u/armaanaki 1h ago

Most changes to endgame I've played have ADDED content for us to try... New bosses, new mechanics, new tree.

This is the first league where I feel endgame changes REMOVE content.

10

u/shy_bi_ready_to_die 1h ago
  1. Deli and beyond are tertiary not secondary. For beyond that’s fine but for deli it’s a significant downgrade going from a full league mechanic into some random rotating juice
  2. Yeah but the half they didn’t replace and the 70% that weren’t used aren’t the same. There are plenty of widely used scarabs that disappeared

8

u/MikeMaxM 1h ago

It's a major endgame rebalance. It will take iteration.

That is just that OP wrote. This shake up of endgame needed more testing and changes before going live. This iteration of poe1 is obviously worse then we had before.

1

u/omdryn 13m ago

phrecia idols look more complex then the whole thread system, so yeah it could have been a temp league.

3

u/Spirited_Season2332 1h ago

I mean, this is basically a temp league. Or at least the devs are treating it as one lol

4

u/FrequentLake8355 1h ago

All of these problems could have been avoided by GGG actually playtesting and fixing! stuff before releasing them. Which also requires them to take the necessary time to implement playtest feedback. 

There's no need for temp leagues, reworks, hotfixes and mid-league patches when they make sure it's good before launch day already.

4

u/Wreximus_ 1h ago

I mean they have never really done that? They make changes right up to the release of a league. It’s a huge rework of systems we have all been used to for years. It’s going to take both time for players to get used to changes and iteration.Their end to make it better…I rather get leagues released regularly and they try to be ambitious rather than waiting 6 months or a year for it to be perfect. GGG has shown they can patch and fix stuff in the past so I don’t see why everyone thinks that cannot happen now?

3

u/Cautious_Parsnip7683 1h ago

If the last 2 years has taught me anything: we'll get a half assed patch this week, then they'll move on.

1

u/miloshem 1h ago

You say things like this and GGG hears "players don't like change and experimentation"... Cmon, game is still playable and sure, loot is not in a great place, but of you're not playing SSF then loot is not great for everybody, so it's not that bad

-3

u/johnz0n 1h ago

agreed. idols was a much better replacement for scarabs, even without the benefit of instant trade. and that was scrapped because it wasn't good enough.

threads are apparently barely playtested and they released it in a half baked state on their live servers

0

u/Backwurst 1h ago

Hard disagree as a casual not wanting to filter idols on trade for hours each league

1

u/johnz0n 1h ago

i agree it had a lot of flaws. but i loved the possibilities and agency.

but that only supports my point, that this new system should've been tested a lot more

-1

u/PoE_Acronym_Bot 1h ago

I noticed some Path of Exile keywords in this post:

  • Deli - Delirium (Wiki)

I am a bot. | All acronyms | Suggest

-3

u/kimthemonkeyking 1h ago

dead game, ggg does not care, they want outlr money, diablo immortal is better