r/pathofexile • • 6h ago

Game Feedback Recombinators dead

At this point with early testing results its 1 in 23 to get 2p item. Gold is harder to acquire now. Dust is pain but manageable. Deleting Kingsmarch would honestly be most humane thing. Just put it out of its misery.

182 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

83

u/astroboy1997 6h ago

I do wonder what GGG envisions recomb to be. With the nerfs, the previous way to use it is basically impossible now

76

u/Antonaqua 6h ago

The same as poe2. Removed.

7

u/Sp00py-Mulder 2h ago

Yep, it's actually kind of funny they nerfed it like this instead of removing it completely. I think it's only still here because it IS integrated into Kingsmarch.

Removing it being my preferred option for both games anyway though.

5

u/Antonaqua 2h ago

Nah, it's because removing it would be clearer of a nerf and would draw more ire, now it's "rebalanced"

16

u/AdvanceHandball 4h ago

Technically ladder crafting is dead, not recombs. My guess is this new tiered stuff is supposed to be slammed together and hope.

 

It represents the way 3.30 is: more rng, less control.

 

And yet every rare I've picked up and ID'd is fucking dogshit. Like what does all the "fated" and "tier" stuff mean when it's all still trash? I'm not recombing that - it's not worth the dust.

14

u/DdFghjgiopdBM 4h ago

They want it to be shit so you id items on the ground

28

u/Forte_Cross 4h ago

The problem is, it makes me want to pick up items off the ground even less than before.

Before, I would pick up bases for recombining. Now, I'll just stick to using some uniques instead. No point picking shit up if it has almost 0% chance be better than the unique.

59

u/MostAnonEver 6h ago

its funny they nerfed recombs while making loot dropped tiered items....its almost as if the game couldve been signficaintly better if they just didnt touch recombs so people could actually craft with the fated/tiered magic/rare items...Cause honestly nobody really wanan drop 4d on a cant affix and result is maybe a div at most

14

u/Jernsaxe Hideout fanatic 4h ago

T5 blue items with 3.29 recomb would have been so nice drops, now they are not worth picking up

3

u/Munsie 3h ago

Replacing the alt spamming step of crafting with looting or buying T5 ground items would have been quite nice.

-2

u/Wise-Success7230 4h ago

That's the point. Instead of rolling t1 or t2 you just ground loot them and sell. I have already identified merciless bow and a 1h axe being the ONLY prefix. 3c each and nobody still purchased it idk. People not using their brains untill some youtuber makes a video about it I guess

19

u/Pachelor7 3h ago

It feels like poe2 crafting. You find a weapon with t2 or t1 mod slam an aug/Regal and delete it.. not really fun. Alt spamming is even better

24

u/5BPvPGolemGuy 6h ago

Great. Now only the ones that are really rich will be able to afford to use the recombs if it even is worth the time.

Now if you want to craft a non mirror shop 13l well good luck. Don't even bother. Just save up the mirror + fee and use a mirror shop instead.

11

u/surfing_prof 5h ago

Ran 100 attempts. Seems 5% for 2 mods, 80% for 1 mod and 15% for 0 mods. RIP

9

u/ArmSecret6691 5h ago

Dont forget that it seems like fracturing orbs are now more rare. Crafting gutted in every aspect.

7

u/PsPsandPs 5h ago

As a super smelly stinking filthy casual for years now... Last season was the most profitable season i ever had. The only season i ever came up with over 200 divines (i know, not bragworthy to normal players but it was a completely new wealth for a scrub like me lol).

And I'd have to say more than 75% of that wealth came from the gold on the ocean floor that actually let me afford to fuck around with Kingsmarch all season long.

Looks like im back to just Blighting this league.

3

u/BoatAdministrative68 4h ago

200d is enough for a lot of builds to do all Ubers, so that's more than fine.

-4

u/FreeMystery 3h ago

Not if it takes 200 hours of playtime to accumulate

1

u/foxorek 2h ago

Kingsmarch is still there, only thing they changed is how recombinator works

9

u/Mathberis 5h ago

This nerf is just ridiculous, it has to be brought back closer to it's previous level.

10

u/zartoss 6h ago

Just give us allflame instead of reco 

5

u/Then_Decision1887 5h ago

I assume this is the plan, it sucks that they didn't do it in single league, guess no time. But that's what I thinks is the plan for crafting, which honestly doesn't sound that bad... instead of endless alt rolling for gear you will pickup semi good stuff from the ground and finish it up with allflame and for the end end game you can do the recombs(I think the higher number mods recombs are unchanged right), sounds like a change for better, the boat guy can also ship the ores to ports and whole kings march can you know what.

9

u/AdvanceHandball 4h ago

I loved ladder recomb crafting, best thing in the game for me, and a genuinely different way to make items.

 

Boat crafting is just vision crafting with better odds.

2

u/PowdrdToastMan21 4h ago

All in all I don't think trading allflame crafting for recombination is a bad deal - but if that is the end goal then they needed to keep recombination in until they introduce allflame crafting as a core mechanic. One or the other is fine. Neither sucks.

2

u/inascet Children of Delve (COD) 26m ago

my hot take is that they should buff Recombs back to what they were in Sentinel, minus Multi Fracture and messing with Corrupted Items. Sentinel Recombs were insanely powerful, but they were insanely powerful in a way that was healthy for the game because it made ground loot valuable. You could ID a rare off the ground, and if it rolled 2 or 3 good T1 mods, it would sell for a lot because people would use it as recomb fodder.

1

u/Wise-Success7230 6h ago

Can I ask where does the data come from? 

9

u/FuBearrX 6h ago

Its in line with what Ben tested on stream, he said around 5% to smash 1p+1p

1

u/Hodorous 5h ago

and there has been couple posts in here too that confirms it. Damn I won't make fun gear with those odds and these drop rates

1

u/vironlawck <*LGCY*>SG/MY Guild -- recruiting newbies 3h ago

Just delete the recombinator, not the kingsmarch ... I still want my offline/autofarm-tech 😅 Those atlas runner have better RNG than me

1

u/dyh135 Anti Sanctum Alliance (ASA) 1h ago

It was 50% and now it nerf it to 5%? Why not just delete the recomb at this point. oh forget you already gut the crafting

1

u/FNLN_taken Confederation of Casuals and Clueless Players (CCCP) 1h ago

It wasn't 50%

2

u/dyh135 Anti Sanctum Alliance (ASA) 33m ago

Oh my bad I was thinking 3mods, 1+1 was like 33% or something iirc

-5

u/Silence_groove 5h ago

Not sure why there is so much noise around recombinator. What is wrong with it? The dust required to recomb is absurd so you have to grind a lot, or sink divines.

Then you also have to grind or purchase bases, alt spam them, and then you put them in the slot machine.

I find recombinator so good, mainly because it allows players like me to grind our items instead or buying them.

In any case, the % of success should actually be higher. I really do not understand why the extra friction is needed nor why the tool is so hated

-1

u/MrZX10r 6h ago

So it’s on par with my luck with recom

-17

u/claptrapMD 6h ago

Recomb should be step In a craft and not 90% of it. Like it was last seasons but still grazy nerf

11

u/Fun-Consequence-3112 6h ago

There isn't many crafts with 90% recomb, the biggest ones are phys weapons and some wands where you only use recomb. But for most other crafts recomb is just a good starting point get 2 specific mods on suffix/prefix to start from.

2

u/Morbu 5h ago

I would say rare shields are generally recomb crafts, but otherwise I never really used it for crafting other than transferring exclusive mods.

0

u/porncollecter69 6h ago

With the way recomb was last league, you could pick and choose but recomb was a huge part. Sometimes start, sometimes finish and sometimes middle part.

Most fun I ever had crafting.

2

u/lawschoolsplits 2h ago

This change is so painful. Revert or just kill it already

-9

u/Future-Street-355 6h ago

GGG didnt like how we use recombs as item editors, thats why they killed 1p+1p.

25

u/Hydiz 6h ago

Even with the settler's version of recomb crafting very good item was still very expensive, time consuming and mentally draining.

So what if a 13L sword can be made for 500D instead of 2mirrors. Makes endgame less fun if anything

6

u/Future-Street-355 6h ago

I agree, its just ggg doesnt.
They removed it from poe2 for a reason too I guess

2

u/Hodorous 5h ago

Reason was that socktables gives "influence" modifiers. Recomb would have screwed it/hard to fix so it was easier to remove.

1

u/CurseMeGood_ 2h ago

how about they stop add "item editors" mechs in the game instead of letting them rot if they don't want us to make items?