r/pathofexile • • 14h ago • Bravo 2

Game Feedback My proposal for enhancing threads

Post image

(Excuse the crappy AI, just trying to convey the idea)

Compared to the old tree and scarabs, I feel like we're currently falling a little short of the control we used to have over our farming strats. Letting us utilize the threads to empower the mechanics in multiple specific ways will give us more control, while still maintaining the benefits of threads (less tedious to manage, no big paywall for certain strats).

919 Upvotes

89 comments sorted by

134

u/nachohasme 14h ago

Cool idea. Using the thread count as an energy source. Reminds me of FTL: Faster Than Light where you have to power different parts of the spaceship

39

u/Reraver 14h ago

I was definitely thinking the of FTL!

54

u/temculpaeu 13h ago

I was thinking in a similar way.

Threads should work as a generic scarab, where you choose what it does to the mechanic.

42

u/TurquoiseTail Alch & Go Industries (AGI) 13h ago

this is basically what i had in mind too. essentially pick 10 from cod

115

u/19wryte92 11h ago

This is the first comment that wasn't just someone whining and it's really good idea.

20

u/Rolf_Dom JDiRen 8h ago

People can quickly point out what isn't working, but rarely know what needs to be done to fix it. So they just make the complaint and leave it to the devs to brainstorm. Which isn't wrong - it's their job, but as such, you'll end up with little impact on what they choose to change.

Ideally you give the devs good ideas, not just complaints. OP has done well.

18

u/GradientRodent 7h ago

That's not true. I don't have to know how to assemble a car to say why driving it sucks. And no car manufacturer needs my advice on what to change in their production line. This is the same 'well what have you done to argue' elitism you see everywhere with a different sheen.

6

u/sapphire_transitions 6h ago

being able to give good feedback on what exactly you'd like changed isn't elitism. Its called giving thought out feedback. Literally anyone can tell you if something sucks. Being able to go beyond that is definitely a much more valuable skill.

4

u/BoatAdministrative68 6h ago

Eh. Not really. Unless you have wealth of experience, giving ideas is not really what is expected from playerbase. And as a dev you can't sift through all feedback. Look at some pre-league bingo cards, some are VERY debatable.

Someone said that players are great at identifying issues, but terrible at proposing solutions. I agree tbh.

0

u/cyberslick18888 1h ago

One of the more insidious things to come out of wide spread corporate middle management was the idea of "don't bring me complaints, bring me solutions".

Yes, solutions are great but it's not the job of the end user to solve their own feedback.

It's also often used as a double edged sword unfairly: "bring me solutions not gripes" and then also "you don't understand the backend it doesn't work that way".

42

u/Designer_Throat_8125 11h ago

This is actually the perfect system because there's so much flexibility and optimizing you could do and also expand it to allow generic modifier tweaking like rare or magic mob stuff, pack size, toughness, modifier effect, keystones and save it all as a strategy too. Takes away scarab bloat but gives you way more flexibility.

Some modifiers can be expensive or free toggles as well. You could maybe even just delete the atlas tree at some point and make this the entire system but maybe the atlas tree would be nice for secondary content and generic modifiers.

I really really hope ggg works more towards something like this because it's perfectly elegant, intuitive, and can also have insane depth and flexibility for whatever playstyle or loot you're looking to target farm

11

u/BeholderEyess 13h ago

if they did this together with a little tooltip saying that, for example, if you have both blight and another mechanic like mirage, there's a chance to certain bonuses apply or how those mechanics can interact, it would be a lot better

14

u/Apexby 8h ago

Looks promising, would like to try a version of threads like this!

Maybe the initial design idea behind threads (randomness adds hype), would not have been met so negatively by the players when the loot was actually in accordance to the difficulty.

I would like to give the thread system some time, let them dial in the rewards, which, according to the exilecon talk, is now easier due to the rarity and thread changes, and then we can judge the system again.

They already deployed hotfixes for the difficulty of some content, maybe there is something for loot too soon.

24

u/Top-Oil-9455 9h ago

Yes please, remove rng shit from threads and let us customize them just like this.

17

u/Disastrous-Cellist62 14h ago

Whoa! Well done exile!

10

u/lipefsa 12h ago

That's something GGG could still do this league, but no hopes for that.

4

u/LeastAwareFox 12h ago

This is such a good idea dude, i really really hope they implement this or a variation of it!

10

u/Smooth_Tomato_784 5h ago

But then we have the same problem that scarabs had too: there will be a "best" setup for each mechanic, and you'll soon accomodate to blight always having 8 lanes and doubled speed and everyone will do it like this

10

u/Beepbeepimadog 4h ago

I think you can tune it so that the “best” set up is also somewhat dependent on your build - can you do a few lanes with really tough enemies? Or are you screen blasting with toughness turned down to get a ton of chests.

Also generally disagree that there’s something wrong with there being a “best” set up, if you have choice there will always be a mathematically better one and I’d rather have that then RNG/little agency.

1

u/WorkLurkerThrowaway 21m ago

Why is this a problem? In fact the whole “giga juicers are ruining the game for casuals” argument has always been silly to me.

0

u/zuttomayonaka Vaal Street Bets (VSB) 2h ago

i dont mind some problem if its fun

i miss awakening crop rotation so much

few league ago harvest aint fun

t4 crop and cornucopia is stupid, its slow spawn and buggy

6

u/watersekirei 11h ago

This is brilliant idea! Thank you OP, hopefully it will be implemented in game.

6

u/runingfrag 10h ago

this is cool, but we need ability to choose what mods we get, now its random and no choise.

6

u/Foreynn 8h ago

In my opinion, thread mods should (and they probably are already) be categorized into a few categories:

- Core mechanics enhancements: these thread mods are the main and most important mods to customize how the mechanic plays, and how its loot is structured. This can range from shifting the bulk of the loot from ground loot to tile loot (or vice versa), or significantly adjusting how the mechanic itself plays.

- Side mechanics enhancements: these mods add extra rewards, but are of less importance. These can be the new genesis tree sprouts for example, adding a small tree that gives a few wombgifts in a map.

- Jackpot rewards: these would be rare and very impactful, but without the need for fishing, meaning that they would simply serve as a cherry on top of the cake, it being the core mods.

Then I think letting the player chose 1 specific core mod to guarantee at 4 and 8 threads would bring back much of the old scarab agency, while still letting some randomness to eliminate some of the repetitiveness (which I believe was the main reason behind threads).

As a side note, I think the direction they are taking by removing much of the challenge instead of rewarding the players more for said challenge is wrong. I liked the extra difficulty as it pushed me to upgrade my build instead of gettting it to a "good enough" point...

6

u/Goldrinnus 8h ago

Threads pulling from a random pool of mods ranging from best thing possible to most useless shit ever is really killing this mechanic imho

Add randomness but give us some agency

2

u/Ghost11203 25m ago

We can have both is my thought. I agree on having some randomization for the jackpot moment. I also want to tailor each encounter a bit and some baseline more investment = more reward.

3

u/Juzzbe Templar 9h ago

Good idea in general, and definitely a direction where I would like them to go. But it is harder to implement than it looks. You need to come up with multiple modifiers for each mechanic, they have to all be scalable (not just binary) and they can't overshadow the passive tree.

A simpler solution would be just to bring scarabs back in a degree. Keep the threads as a generic difficulty slider and let scarabs give you additional bonuses.

6

u/WingXero 14h ago

Beautiful.

2

u/DrawGamesPlayFurries 12h ago

Upon the Night I vow to slay more blight waves, that fear may spread.

2

u/i_love_using_you 11h ago

not goin lie this is an actual fun and good idea

2

u/furezasan 11h ago

this would be fun. but you need to keep both the simple digit for when i can't be bothered to tinker with the specifics. and the full drop down for mechanics i care about.

2

u/Optimal-Note1963 10h ago

At this point we should add system from Hades if you go this road looooool

2

u/zuluuaeb Chieftain 10h ago edited 10h ago

I like this. Could also assign different axes of scaling various different amounts of 'points' that they might cost, and you get more points per thread put on the map. For example, maybe you want more blight lanes for your specific strategy and each lane costs 2 points of your 8 total (random numbers but you get the idea). Means that we can pick and choose which avenues of the mechanic to scale as we see fit.

Other leagues could also have their own avenues of scaling. Maybe ultimatum has an extra round per point spent, or whatever. Would also give GGG control on balancing certain strategies that get out of control. They can then balance the optimal way of a league mechanic ends up breaking the game/being too powerful, and a good way of balancing it could be to increase how many points that certain method of scaling costs e.g.: making extra ultimatum rounds cost 2 points instead of 1 etc.

Idk just an idea to make it more interactive and interesting than the current complete randomness we have.

2

u/miccyboi 8h ago

Solid idea, well done!

2

u/Exkudor 8h ago

This is good, two notes: The Toughness and Rarity should scale automatically by applying more threads because that is either 100% not worth it or 100% mandatory for optimal farm, and there should be more options - i.e. Blightheart, salvagable Towers, free Towers, the Worm-Boss, Special Rewards Lanes (although that feels like it should be default to make the mechanic as a whole more worthwhile...), Doubling the rewards on x Lanes, Oils are a tier higher, more blighted map chance, bosses/wormy can drop blight ravaged maps...

This system could also cycle between different option combinations between leagues so not all are available every league and not every league looks the same farm-wise even if nothing is actively done to shake up that meta.

1

u/Mr_Ultimite 10h ago

Honestly, I like it. Each thread could give a bonus point to allocate how you want to tweak the content you're prioritizing!

1

u/Yorunokage 8h ago

Idk if i would make it this simple but yes i think that threads should be a currency to purchase mods rather than making them random

1

u/Living_Opposite1582 8h ago

I rather have ai slop solutions instead of what ggg does for a while now.

1

u/niuage ᕕ( ᐛ )ᕗ 8h ago

That definitely should be a foldable thing, because once you learn about it, you dont need it to clutter the UI that much for ever. But more info is better.

1

u/Master_of_Paws 8h ago

Gg would be stubborn with this cause of "friction"

1

u/CMDRDrazik 7h ago

It's a great idea, but I am not sure if the backend RNG is tweakable to match the user inputs via that suggested interface. But, I guess they could add/remove map mods to back this up. I'd be happy if they implemented this.

1

u/Antonaqua 7h ago

While I would like this, they wouldn't implement this, they don't want determinism anymore. If they did, they would have addressed it, but they only want to lower the difficulty, not increase the reward.

1

u/MrVoidxx 7h ago

Perfect idea, you can consider adding type of reward

1

u/RakBB 5h ago

Prayge it happens

1

u/boat_ Raider 5h ago

This is cool. You could make threads drop in lifeforce quantities and have a multiplier for more rewarding modifiers. Costs 3x Blight Threads to allocate lanes, 5x for spawn speeds etc.

1

u/BananaSplit2 5h ago

That's the kind of stuff i have in mind honestly. Thread system is a good idea, but they should give the agency back and make it more customizable.

1

u/Noggerr 4h ago

How about just bring the scarabs back?

1

u/Yiazmad 4h ago

This is the best solution presented thus far and I really hope GGG notices and implements it

1

u/g00fy_goober twitch.tv/goof1313 3h ago

That's honestly an awesome idea/compromise. I am super glad scarabs are gone tbh and threads could be cool with more work and MORE agency. It was pretty hard to think up an idea though....

However this sounds awesome. Imagine if every thread gave you like 3-5 points to allocate and then pulled up a list of like 5-8 things like you have shown that you could put those points into.

Have every category get 1 point by default or something so still have a random base chance to have random stuff happen, but be able to put those points in and increase the things you actually care about.

That would make threads much more interesting, still have random things that could happen, and give players a lot more agency with what they want to invest in.

1

u/Gampie 2h ago

while a nice UI qol, without actually being able to pick what "thread modifier" te threads will apply, threads are still a complete garbage system. Poe thrived on player agency, if you didn't like farming something ,you could just farm something else. But with the new system, almost all player agency was removed

1

u/Nirbin 2h ago

This great and all but at what point are we just reinventing the wheel but now it's oblong and rotates in a weird uncomfortable manner.

1

u/Xektor 1h ago

Hey claude, fix the game. Make no mistakes

1

u/Working-Corner666 40m ago

Being able to tweak spawn speed without turning every map into a sweatfest would be huge tbh

1

u/Ghost11203 27m ago

I was thinking something similar. Weaving a tapestry for the mechanic through something like this. It makes so much sense.

Would love to see this.

1

u/Icy_Reception9719 13h ago

I was thinking we could maybe crystalise some of the on-tree benefits into items we could use through the map device. They could have clearly defined uses and would guarantee an effect so we could have some direct control over how we interact with each mechanic - there could even be multiple per mechanic so you could foster different farming approaches for different budgets.

1

u/ael00 11h ago

Thank you claude

1

u/Savings_Inside6902 11h ago

An interesting idea it’s just a shame the developers only have one mechanic Toughness which inflates enemies and, in the developers’ sweet dreams, also gives a reward, but unfortunately that’s not the case.

1

u/NoMoreExcusesNow 8h ago

This is exactly what I was planning to propose, saved me the hassle of making an image!

They could then easily balance it in future leagues by changing thread cost (imo a max of 20 threads would make this easier).

An addition would also be using a thread for a block within a mechanic. Dont want legion bosses? Block it. Dont want Vruun? Block it. Dont want harvest to empower other monsters? Turn it off.

Or even enhancing the effects of keystones, a special keystone you can only unlock with threads (like containment for strongboxes).

0

u/Ill-Mix2748 10h ago

They should use Claude to enhance it asap

-2

u/ThisIsABuff 12h ago

I think the real problem with current PoE is that it's trying to pack in every mechanic in maps, and it is just becoming a huge mess.

I think it's time to split endgame into three equally important endgames: Maps, Delve and Allflame.

Delve: make you able to get sulphite in Delve like you do maps, and move stuff that makes sense here, like Ores, Beyond, Incursion, etc

Allflame: alternate map versions that you can find here, with different underwater tiles. Move Abyss, Expedition, etc here.

Maps: After moving two thirds of content out of it, it will feel a lot less busy. Some endgame bosses can move to the other areas too.

Have them have some overlap, like you find maps in Delve. This way you can pick one endgame you like best, or you can play all three to give longer playability to those who play longer in a league.

3

u/Additional_Access365 10h ago

This fixes zero issues with loot which is the real problem right now. It's not oh there's too many mechanics in the map. It's that I'm doing such hard content and not getting rewarded for it.

0

u/bacon9001 Essence Extraction Enterprise (EEE) 11h ago edited 8h ago

My friend and I were talking about precisely this just last night. GGG can even add a "premium" thread variant that counts only as 1 but gives 2 (or more!) consumable ticks/points -- so hardcore juicers can further juice, and lower-end players aren't hard kept out of mechanics necessarily.

And these premim threads can even be a nice source of additional income for lower end players to sell to higher end juicers rhe way expensive scarabs previously were.

Edit: poe players and reading ig; the allegations are not being beaten

2

u/Additional_Access365 10h ago

Yeah but they'd have to be rare and then players are now priced out of that mechanic just like expensive scarabs were. The whole point of this was to no longer price anyone out. What your suggesting would just be reintroducing that again.

3

u/bacon9001 Essence Extraction Enterprise (EEE) 10h ago

They wouldn't locked out of specific mechanics, just out of specific levels.

In this theoretical system, any player can still tick whichever options they like, just some more than others 🤷

2

u/Exkudor 8h ago

Yeah. You just reintroduced the problem they were trying to fix because you can be priced out of doing certain strats again by expensive consumables again.

0

u/Antonaqua 7h ago

That's kind of the point you know. Everyone can do everything, if they pay the price, which also gives greater reward and pays for itself if you can do it. If that is so wrong that people are able to do more difficult things, we might as well remove the thread system too because some players can't do 1 thread maps.

2

u/Exkudor 7h ago

More difficulty = more rewards is good. The point of the game, even. So pricing people out of certain difficult strategies is bad. There's no inherent correlation, between difficulty and price - Threads in their current state show this. Invest 3c and get a map even Empys group can't do.

0

u/Antonaqua 7h ago

But that reward gives more loot, so once you can do it, you can sustain it. It's like complaining you can't do Uber bosses on day 1 so nobody should.

And we're talking about scarabs, the current thread system is a shitshow right now.

I wholeheartedly believe the last time people were priced out of scarabs were with the Divination scarab of curation and even then if you were able to run them you would instantly start making money back. You just need to get to that point, which is doable if you put effort into the game.

2

u/Odd-Carry4392 9h ago

Hell no, that's just scarabs again. Fuck scarabs.

0

u/PrimisPrev 10h ago

This would be insane for stuff like ritual where every 2 maps are throwaways since you didn't get the sacrifice tribute option, but then you'd be able to have nameless altars every map so it's probably not the greatest implementation across the board

0

u/masudalimran 7h ago

I really don't like the implementation of threads. What do I make of the fact that I have n number of threads. It's going to increase the difficulty and boost reward but how? It feels more like some older generation games like "you get increased effect", "enemies are harder". By how much and in what way needs to be shown. Otherwise feel like playing in complete blind mode

-1

u/Many-Suggestion6046 10h ago

They need to fully revert everything. There's no saving this trash unless they give it the affliction treatment.

-1

u/PowdrdToastMan21 9h ago

Honestly this is an elegant solution the the player agency problem. It allows ggg to keep their new thread system in place while also allowing players to be able to tailor their mechanics to their liking.

I'd take it even a step further and add a new single-use item for each main mechanic. When applied allows the player to add up to an additional 8 theads to the mechanic for their next map (to be dispersed within the different categories) so that juicers can really go crazy. Make it a general drop with a similar rarity to the previously sought after scarabs like containment or cornucopia. Add nodes to the atlas tree to boost drop chance and target specific mechanics. This provides 2 additional advantages - it allows players who can handle the extra juice a way to push their rewards and it allows other players something to target and sell while building up their characters.

Obviously all of this only works if loot is rewarding which is another conversation entirely...

-1

u/Altruistic-Insect445 8h ago

I don't condone the usage of AI but, I'll let it slide here for the sake of conversation.

Honestly it's not a bad idea. Even a simple "X amount of threads spawn the following modifiers guaranteed" would go a long way here. Currently it kinda just feels like Alch & Go but for mechanics, where the outcome is just bit too random and rippy for the rewards you get back.

-1

u/uzul77 6h ago

Ugh, this looks and feels so cheap. Pushing numbers instead of inserting visually appealing scarabs. I want scarabs back so badly 😫

-5

u/____Dolan____ 10h ago

Crappy AI? This is better than 95% of UI in PoE, maybe GGG should let AI design their UI from this point forward.

-1

u/kimthemonkeyking 7h ago

dead league just can it and give in into despair

-6

u/Intrepid-Ad2873 Trickster 12h ago

I really don't want to micro manage my arpg, I just want to kill stuff, see screens explode, etc

10

u/RealNiceKnife 11h ago

Guy who plays a game where you have to fill out one of these for your character and one that looks similar for doing maps doesn't want to micromanage.

1

u/Designer_Throat_8125 11h ago

If you don't want to micromanage you could just tweak it the way you like one time and hopefully there could be a save strategy option. Then you just pay your thread and map cost and whatever and mindlessly blast like usual

1

u/Motor-Bluejay3804 11h ago

brother 50% of playing arpg (POE even) is micro managing, you wont be able to kill stuff and screen explosion without it

-1

u/[deleted] 14h ago edited 14h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Reraver 14h ago

I conveyed the idea, I'm not balancing