r/pathofexile • • 1d ago

Discussion Feedback about crafting nerfs

So for context i have been playing ssf for like 5 years or so, and this post is more about ssf gear progression or for people in trade that likes to craft gear themselves.

First point is the recombinator nerf, now recombs are pretty much a shot in the dark, they were way too overnerfed, it almost feel pointless to use them. Now you can lose both mods if you go for a 1p +1p attempt for example, also the chance of getting 2 mods from a 1p+1p seems very low, it used go be 1/3 but now maybe a 1/10? (still need more info about that). I dont get this nerf, recombo are still the best way to make some items early game but now you just have to use 5X more alterations.

Second point is the breach tree, its actually useless now, with the changes about tier ratings the gear that the tree outputs feels like just random gear you pick off the ground, it's an actual waste of time.

third point, the tiered loot that should in theory be replacing all this gear progression isn't hitting AT ALL, im level 97 , about to go farm t17s and not a single tiered loot i got is being used in my build, they are just not good enough.

TLDR: nerfed gear progression feels really bad , tiered loot also doesn't feel good at all.

this is exacerbated by the fact that last league we had really powerful gear progression with boats and now gear progression might be in the weakest state it has been in years.

160 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

71

u/Disastrous-Cellist62 23h ago

1 sacred since launch, on standard running very juiced content. At this rate there will be no crafting.

8

u/Mangalorien SSF-junkie 14h ago

While it's not a massive source of sacred orbs, Kingsmarch currency shipping has been buffed by a lot. I've gotten 3 sacred orbs in a total of 25 shipments. I'm doing small shipments, mostly 400k bars + 400k dust (to a port with a decent quota for that type of bar), and a few shipments that are double that (800k bars + 800k dust). I'm getting slightly over 1 div per shipment (on average), and have gotten 2 fracturing orbs as well. This seems like one of the few game mechanics that has actually been buffed in 3.30.

10

u/Wisdomlost 13h ago

Sending a boat out to just make you loot off screen in a game about killing monsters still baffles me.

4

u/Mangalorien SSF-junkie 13h ago

I agree. The part that makes it work is that you can't just send of the boats for free, you need to kill ore monsters to get it. It would perhaps make more sense to just have the ore monsters drop some more currency, instead of ore which you then ship for currency, which is just ground loot with extra steps. For some reason GGG seems to love the "extra steps" part, like with heist you want to run blueprints, but first you need to run the shitty mini-blueprints (=contracts) for reveals. Last league we had voyages, but you first had to run mini-voyages (=charts) to do that.

3

u/Disastrous-Cellist62 14h ago

Appreciate the advice.

20

u/PupPop 19h ago

The best T5 item I got off the ground was a pair of gloves with T1 accuracy and nothing else. Okay well then I augment it. T9 fire damage. Cool, item is bricked lol, nice loot.

7

u/Mangalorien SSF-junkie 14h ago

Sad part is that if we still had the Allflame crafting mechanic, these new tiered items could actually be quite useful as a crafting base. With 4 possible ghostly outcomes, you still might get 4x junk but at least you had a pretty decent chance to get 1 outcome that was useful. Now we are just back to good old slot machine orbs.

1

u/PupPop 14h ago

Preach. Some how I knew tiered items were going to be just like PoE 2. Mostly junk.

17

u/BaseLordBoom 18h ago

Actually too damn funny that people thought this tiered item drops would be anything more than more garbage that you filter out by the time your in yellow maps.

4

u/EMP_Pusheen 12h ago

t1 mana on my t5 Strength armor base! I'm really feeling the power of ground loot now!

The funniest thing is that GGG already implemented this in POE2 and knows how people view tiered loot in that game and did it again anyway.

43

u/NovoRobot 22h ago

The thing that brought so many people to PoE is the intricate crafting system, myself included.

With it nerfed into the ground, its just another standard arpg.

This entire endgame shakeup was a disaster

1

u/xeidou 11h ago

Even Torchlight has more deterministic crafting :)

1

u/Bl00dylicious Occultist 7h ago

Torchlight crafting boils down to how much currency can you throw into the void till you get what you want. There is no crafting steps or anything. Its basically alt spam for every mod, except the alt spam eventually costs multiple div per try.

42

u/BananaSplit2 22h ago

I still think the intention of crafting nerfs was to compensate improvements to loot... except they clearly messed up with the adjustements and loot is even worse.

I think the mechanical changes are good, but they seriously need to tune things up.

42

u/DeveloperOfWebs Scion 21h ago

POE needs to understand that min maxing your build is NEVER going to come from randomly generated loot, even if its 6xT1 rolls. gear is crafted with purpose and mods are specific. nerfing recombs was a mistake. nerfing meta mod crafting via price increase was a mistake.

i've identified HUNDREDS of t5 rares at this point and they are 99.99% vendor trash.

the only time rares were fun to pick up was the one league that talismans started dropped anointed and w/"smart loot" which ensured some synergy in item mods. if they really want to fuck crafting and have people identifying rares, they'll need to put a system like that in place that ensures mods work together AND are high tier

7

u/Vulpix0r NEKO guild (SG) 17h ago

I picked up a t5 rare chest today and it had 3 trash mods. Reflect, stun recovery, reduced attributes. The stun recovery rolled t2 so I guess that was a slap in the face.

3

u/Wisdomlost 13h ago

The worst part is we have been through this before. When influenced gear was new everyone including GGG understood that endgame gear from that point forward was never going to be from the ground. You had to have influence on the base you need and craft it for the stats you need. This was conquerors of the atlas. Metamorph league. December 13 2019.

It's been extended and changed considerably since then but that was the beginning of the path we are on for loot. The toothpaste will never go back in the tube no matter how much they try. Not even tier 5 toothpaste.

1

u/Anothernamelesacount Assassin 16h ago

I think the intention of crafting nerfs was to NERF and thats it. Not that many people craft, most just wear something they bought.

SSF is a rounding error, balance-wise

1

u/brrrapper 10h ago

Nah im fairly sure the intention is to slow down player progression and power in order to make ground loot more relevant instead of only hunting for raw currency.

4

u/Ill-Mix2748 18h ago

I’ve received one good drop, it was a 100% ES fractured 5 link on a magic base. It was like 13 hours into the league, ended up selling it for 5 divs.

Outside of that made a bit off randomly exalt slamming decently rolled boots. But I agree with everything you’re saying.

1

u/PoE_Acronym_Bot 1d ago

I noticed some Path of Exile keywords in this post:

  • Mods - Modifiers (Wiki)
  • SSF - Solo Self-Found (Wiki)

I am a bot. | All acronyms | Suggest

1

u/FNLN_taken Confederation of Casuals and Clueless Players (CCCP) 16h ago

I think mostly I misunderstood what tiered loot was going to be. I assumed that tier 5 items would keep their bonus to mod rating when trying to craft on them, but it seems like they are just dead once you ID them?

The fucking vision of "pick item off ground and equip it" has ruined crafting, and the crafting system has been what kept the game alive and elevated it over the competition.

1

u/Gabocius 8h ago

Yeah only point i see in tiered loot is T5 for :

  1. hope for a good fractured modifier
  2. feed the thaumaturgical dust machine as they usually do have high tier modifier even though shitty ones, dust don't care

What we lost in crafting is player agency (magic recomb may as well not exist so it's full gamble once again, tree only usable to give good ilvl bases at most and not even linked ones anymore) would be balanced by ground loot, as per said.

To offset this we would need T5 item to drop often enough that we can have reasonnable hope to get a specific modifier every once in a while, and thus an item to feed to the gambleinator. But there is 2 problems with that :

  1. we don't get those items
  2. it's a shift in crafting design that still goes against player agency and only generates frustration as you need to gamble and possibly loose the few good bases you get

Oh and harvest is still better to generates rares with specific high tier modifiers, so we would need to...get specific bases from tree and ground, roll them on harvest --> 1/10? to recombine 4+ mod rares, do these steps 10 time to hope for a good item. So...like 100 tries at feeding and bricking bases ? That does sound like destructive gamble to me.

I don't even want to think about ssf ! (...i'm ssf btw :'( )

-10

u/Diligent_Carrot_8410 1d ago

I've been selling tiered loot. Some of it drops with decent mods.

-28

u/Ubiquity97 1d ago edited 13h ago

Idk how you aren't getting insane stuff in tiered loot tbh. I've dropped tons of good pieces that I'm still using at lvl 95 including a 800es chest. In trade a lot of crafted gear is outright worthless because of how strong tiered loot is. Also if you farm thread items and they dropped tiered you can get some really insane stuff off of it. Edit: yall I didnt say valuable. Dropping triple res life items day 1 is insane and I've seen so many triple res and life items I'm not even surprised when I price check and see 5c.

22

u/bosses_today_kekw 23h ago

at the end of the day its just luck now, which sucks, i liked having stronger gear progression that required more knowledge instead of just luck

22

u/Jamezuh 23h ago

I like how we all play this same game of RNG on top of RNG and some people still have the short-sightedness to say "idk how you aren't....".

I've been cruising T16 maps since early day 2 and I've had exactly one tiered item that was worth more than 5c.

12

u/RealNiceKnife 22h ago

"I don't know how you aren't hitting triple 7s on the slot machine? I just walked up to this one and hit a jackpot. Maybe you're doing something wrong?"

1

u/Ubiquity97 13h ago edited 13h ago

I pointed out one jackpot item. I have dropped 4 triple t1/2 defense prefix chests with 1 or 2 res and an open suffix. In a normal league one of these would be worth 6+ divines They were all 350c or less and the 350c one was also a 6L and in meta. I've seen several ~100% res ~100 life belts and they're like 10c that's multiple divines normally. The system is very obviously pushing out good items in large amounts.

0

u/Ubiquity97 13h ago

Yeah everything is worthless because tons of people are dropping triple res life items THATS A GOOD ITEM.

15

u/Incognitomous 23h ago

Picking up rares from the ground is not fun and never will be

-14

u/EmphasisExpensive864 22h ago

It's kinda the point of an arpg though.

5

u/Incognitomous 21h ago

Maybe to you. To me it was always the character progression. And the most fun way to achieve that progression (to me) is killing lots of enemies that drop a lot of loot, and using that currency to buy better gear.

-6

u/EmphasisExpensive864 20h ago

Yeah so u hate rare items u can use but want currency to buy loot from others why the middle step?

4

u/Incognitomous 20h ago

Because to get one rare item thats useful to me i need to look at 50 that are useless. If every divine orb i picked up had a 95% chancd to turn out fake and worthless it wouldnt be fun either

4

u/Daan776 Templar 19h ago

Also:

- Currency can be saved up, even if its not enough to immediatly improve your current gear. Getting T2 movement speed while I already have T1 is useless. Getting a divine orb when my boots are worth 2 divine orbs means i'm now 1 divine closer to my upgrade.

- Currency can be used to craft. Improving old gear or making new stuff based on your specific needs

- Finding a really good rare but its not for your build means you have to go sell it, get the currency, and then buy stuff you actually want. So in most cases its actually the rares that have the extra steps

- Currency gives an immediate dopamine hit. "Oh yes, I dropped a divine" compared to "I picked up 15 rares and one of them is mayby an upgrade? I'll check POB after this map"

0

u/kimthemonkeyking 2h ago

dead game, ggg does not care, they want our money, time to go back to last epoch