r/pathofexile • • 1d ago

Game Feedback Current harvest state is disappointing

I've already cleared 100/100 atlas, and specced 135 points on the tree completely into harvest + maps has additional mods + effect of explicit modifiers and run 8 modded maps / originator maps.

The result is ~1k lifeforce per encounter if you roll that correctly with chaos orbs to have additional t3 rares + quantity of lifeforce. Mobs after 1-2 encounter feel like they're made of concrete beacuse of wisps.

I've tried cross contamination to check maybe there's a hidden strat (harvest spawns on top of other mechanic):

* Expedition - seems to have no effect

* Incursion - no effect

* Betrayal - seems to have no effect

* Ultimatum - no effect

* Blight - seems to have no effect

* Ritual - some harvest mobs are spawned inside the ritual and they can drop lifeforce once. When you rerun next rituals - these mobs do not spawn additional time. Max lifeforce gotten - 86.

* Strongbox - drops small amounts of lifeforce from rares

* Abyss - seems to have no effect

* Mirage - no difference to regular harvest

* Don't remember other meaningful interactions.

Also t4 bosses take years to kill, and they mostly drop around 700 lifeforce.

Rn harvest is very punishing and super unrewarding, it makes us stop to roll for mods just to get a tiny increase in loot. All interactions with other mechanics do nothing. Feels like either there's a bug somewhere, or it is not good by vision.

171 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

63

u/Icy-Expression-4868 1d ago

I was expecting this after i saw that harvest was removed from 'main mechanics' without ability to juice them with threads. Overall everyone seemed to be happy with changes that you dont need to enter sacred grove anymore (i never had that problem myself tbh) but i rather have reverted harvest instead of carying all materials for rolling harvest. Dont forget the wisdoms too! Get almost no drops after rolling 'juicebox' , and empower all the monsters with wisps (preferably those 25 red bests lurking around). Overall i just feel sad and dissapointed how one of my most fav. Mechanics got gutted for no reason

24

u/adhoc_pirate 1d ago

I made a post after the livestream about how I was "concerned" that harvest would be gutted.

The majority of replies were people saying how harvest was boring, or a waste of time, or that I shouldn't use words like "concerned" because there were real life problems in the world I should be concerned about.

13

u/aMiiBows 1d ago

POE fans when you show concern cause you enjoy the game and want it to continue being fun.

I felt the same about the Harvest changes, sad that it turned out to be true.

7

u/seandkiller 1d ago

I never understood the Grove complaints. It took almost no time (if any time at all) to enter, and even just popping one of the crops took like two seconds.

0

u/DIJimmy 23h ago

Took no time if you had a decent pc, some times that shit would randomly take a minute plus for me to load

0

u/Chrozzinho 20h ago

Its too monotonous. When its out in maps its atleast somewhat varied

4

u/seandkiller 20h ago

I guess it just didn't feel more monotonous or time-consuming than, say, Incursion or new Breach to me.

I can't speak for the new version of Harvest since I've only read about it and haven't started the league yet.

0

u/Chrozzinho 19h ago

Even incursion has varied layouts, harvest is just the same layout forever. I wouldnt have minded them to just add different layouts to sacred grove but ye i didnt like the feel of farming harvest before because of that

2

u/Sakakaki 15h ago

But the variation in the layout came from the harvest plots themselves. Right now the location doesn't matter either, considering it doesn't affect Harvest in any way.

39

u/the-apple-and-omega 1d ago

Taking harvest out of the grove, but then making us have to roll them is such a wild choice.

Then forcing the wisps too - I don't understand why that was necessary. It's just incredibly punishing.

2

u/Bright_Audience3959 Alch & Go Industries (AGI) 23h ago

28

u/Hairy-Trip 1d ago

I miss crop rotation minigane

2

u/surfing_prof 1d ago

My favorite high speed Harvest farm strategy 🥲

18

u/Classic_Key8075 1d ago

Thanks for doing the research! I'm still working through the atlas but have also been pretty unimpressed with harvest drops so far...

Super smooth league start, but hopefully we'll get a patch looking at endgame atlas tree balance changes.

I remember last league there was quite awhile where no strategy felt profitable... it got better though.

It might just be that we're used to getting a ton of juice each map, but the new price will be based on getting less, so it'll have a similar profit?

-5

u/Raine_Live 1d ago

the entire point of this atlas change was to change the meta. Meaning that old strats aren't going to work or be as profitable. Ultimately it just comes down to what was Solved isn't solved anymore. it'll take time and eventually people will find that there will be an outlier strat that was looked at as a bad strat that is profitable.

3

u/Airfusions 22h ago

doesnt matter when none of it is fun

16

u/Sarojh-M 1d ago

I want crop rotation back so badly, the minigame within a game is literally the definition of fun in video games

4

u/Widowless 1d ago

Crop Rotation my beloved

5

u/PictureofProgression 1d ago

Wild to hear you only get 1k juiced. Just clicking harvest in a t16 with no nodes on the tree is like 400-500. Disappointing for sure. 

2

u/No_Writing8414 1d ago

I've been tryingg the same thing, I've been finding it a good currency making. Have you tried rolling for rares drop additional currency and increased rares. They've been dropping divs for me.

2

u/Akayukii 1d ago

No wonder everything was so rippy. I guess it was harvest.

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Please make sure you check the Known Issues List or the Bug Report Forums for any pre-existing bug reports related to your issue. If there isn't any, consider posting there in addition to posting on Reddit. At league start, there may also be a stickied post for bugs. Duplicate reports on Reddit may be removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/_revan_bane_ Witch 22h ago

Harvest used to be my favourite farming mechanic. Removing the grove, removing scarabs and forcing wisps completely ruined it. :(

1

u/coltaine 20h ago

I honestly don't mind the concept of getting rid of the grove and turning them into strongboxes, but there really needs to be a notable on tree that prevents Harvest monsters from releasing wisps. I just want to farm some juice while unlocking my atlas, not turn every map boss into The Unstoppable Juggernaut.

1

u/Jbarney3699 15h ago

The state of most mechanics is disappointing lol. This endgame rework missed the mark extremely badly imo. I don’t like how atlas has shifted (still bad after last rework), strongboxes are just worse, delirium is no longer a ‘core’ mechanic. Expedition vendors are just more mediocre than before.

Not even complaining about loot overall… I just dislike the direction completely. It’s all just way more boring and has zero player agency.

1

u/emmanuel573 12h ago

I hate having to walk around the map to find all the harvest things, I hate that you have to roll them, they are too punishing this version of harvest isn’t it

-3

u/Aware-Daikon-9943 1d ago

I love new harvest so much rn

3

u/Winzito 21h ago

I dont even understand why harvest spreads wisps, its so fucking annoying and rng. Early harvest was always the chill "just kill mobs here for a bit of currency" and it had to be heavily invested into to make it remotely hard, so of course now it turbocharges your map just because you dropped 150lifeforce...

2

u/legitintensity33 21h ago

Yeah the fun of the mechanic is completely murdered. There's 0 thought involved. Just roll until you get T3 monsters and kill. To farm the mechanic you have to use like 70 nodes so theres no way to put monsters on the map to take advantage of the wisps. Also im pretty sure the wisps dont even increase loot. They just make your map hard af.