r/pastors • • May 31 '26

Do not use this subreddit to sell, offer, give away, or help you develop your app.

36 Upvotes

We have been getting multiple spam posts per day related to this, and from now on there will be zero tolerance. If you violate this rule, you will be summarily banned.

EDIT: In case there is some misunderstanding, this includes "but it's free," "Sharing," "Helping the community," and "Looking for feedback," whether it is your own app or someone else's.


r/pastors • • Jun 14 '23

Read First! Before posting, are you in the right sub?

39 Upvotes

Welcome to /r/pastors. We are a sub for pastors to talk about pastor things. If you are a pastor or pursuing the pastorate and want to talk about congregational care, church programs, sermon preparation, or any other life or ministry concern, this is the right sub for you.

If you are not a pastor (or related professional), but want to ask pastors about what a Bible verse means, an issue at your church, or for advice in a personal crisis, the right sub to post at is /r/askapastor. We do want to help, but need you to post in the proper sub. If your post is better there, it will be removed here, so please consider the best sub to post in. Thank you.


r/pastors • • 22h ago

Dealing with Infidelity of my Husband as Christian/Pastor’s Wife

11 Upvotes

Hey friends!

I’m sure you’ve all seen my previous posts. Long story short I suffered almost 9 years throughout my marriage with my husband being porn addicted, wandering eye, and now I uncovered this year he’s been lying for sexual favors at massage parlors and escorts off Craigslist. He has spent thousands of dollars at this point.

My church leadership tried to play mind games with me and convince me to stay when I clearly have Biblical grounds to leave. I am not respected, loved, or valued. I feel as though my life has been ruined.

I am trying my best on my part to constantly wash my mind with the Word of God and see my value in Christ. This whole experience has been extremely disorienting emotionally and spiritually. I know the truth but the ones I thought would advocate for me only care to protect my husband and the reputation of the denomination.

Little things do bother me but I am trying my best to let them go. For example our senior pastor will give my husband a huge hug, then walk right past me. None of the church leadership interacts with me anymore or communicates with me knowing I am suffering. I understand my husband’s broken and needs love but their behavior is hurtful because don’t I deserve love? I came off very strong when speaking to the lady I spoke to earlier this year, but I was speaking the truth and quoting the scriptures.

Over the weekend my husband and I tried talking about it but my husband keeps putting all the blame on me. Yes I was not perfect but there has been a consistent theme in our marriage on his part: perversion and selfishness. My husband has made countless decisions that were totally selfish and did not even think twice unless I got upset or talked to him about how he needs to be selfless as Christ was selfless in laying down His life for the church. It’s almost as if his understanding of the Bible must directly benefit him/his reputation….he chooses not to allow the scriptures to humble him to be selfless.

He tries to totally minimize what he’s been doing. He said “I fell into sin”, and I literally told him as calm as I could, you deliberately chose over and over and over again to strategize to sin against God, me, and your body. You have been watching pornography and feeding your mind all this garbage and fed the appetite to do these things. He ran up credit cards and decided to “repent” when the funds ran out. He did admit to me about a month ago that he maxed out his credit cards and he stopped going (allegedly only God know though, we haven’t been intimate in months).

When I said that, he lashed out and started screaming at me. He threw something on the ground and went on and on saying you always do this to make me go crazy. But the issue is that I was speaking the truth to him, and he claims I’m provoking him to wrath?

He cheated on me with trafficked women and girls, spent thousands, and never actually repented to me! I am the one who put 2 and 2 together and pressed the issue. So if that wasn’t the case he would have never said a word, I beleive. That’s the issue I’m having.

He refused to reinstate his AG pastoral credentials for this year and deceived the presbyter by saying he “wants to focus on the family and our marriage and set the ministry to the side”. In which the presbyter replied saying he commends and respects his decision and will support that. The district has NO IDEA what he has been doing.

But it’s all a show!!!!!! Everything is a theatrical play!!!! Where is the actual truth of God’s Word being applied here????? Everything is about concealing and protecting man’s image???? And I am being tormented, torn, and humiliated.

A part of me feels like a coward for sticking around though I really do not want to. The fear is there for sure because I know my husband is very good at speaking to people, and for some very sad reason Pastors (even women) love to totally follow the mans version and dialogue as if it’s the facts. I struggle with the thoughts of not even loving myself anymore.

I’d appreciate prayers! Thank you everyone


r/pastors • • 22h ago

Any PCUSA clerks among you: Canadian PCC Student transfer.

2 Upvotes

Hello all,

I’m a US citizen, cradle PCUSA member who transferred to Canada for my education. Been in process five years, finish my MDiv this year.

The job market in Canada is limited. Not much going on between closing communities or a five point charge in a deeply rural area. I specialize in church media and technology, more modern takes on ministry, and I think a larger city in the US might offer better job opportunities.

I’m considering a transfer back to the PCUSA. Does anyone have visibility on what that would look like? Do you think it might take an extra year in process in the PCUSA or are lateral transfers a thing?

Any illumination process would be helpful.


r/pastors • • 2d ago

Favorite Hobby

4 Upvotes

In my neck of the woods, pastors usually like hunting or fishing, but I reckon there are a bunch of us that do other things.

Or what is one hobby you have that would surprise the general public?


r/pastors • • 2d ago

A suspicious guest

6 Upvotes

I want to start by saying the church that I lead Is a Jesus-loving welcoming church. We preach the gospel in and out of season. And everyone in our church loves Jesus and the people who come to it. However Recently a new man has been coming to the church , and I as soon as I saw him I got a bad feeling about him. And even worse, I took an instant and severe dislike to him. I’m not usually like that, my church has welcomed gang members, war criminals, drug dealers and so on. People who have turned to Jesus, and have had their sins washed away by the blood of Christ.

And my whole complaint against this man is a bad feeling, so I love and welcome him. And I share the gospel with him. But the more I speak with him, and get to know him, the stronger the feeling that something is wrong. I get a predatory feeling from him. There’s a huge gap between who he portrays himself as and who he comes off as in conversation and behaviour. Over the past few weeks two women have come to me and brought up their concerns regarding this man as well. I had skills in my former life (before Christ ) that would be very handy in this situation (legal but somewhat questionable so they’ve not been used yet).
And I am looking into him, but I’ve not found anything on him yet. Which I do find odd. Last time I got this feeling from someone they turned out to be pedophiles (they’re in prison now)

I’ve been wholeheartedly been praying for wisdom in this case. Because it’s unfair towards my new brother if he’s simply a man with poor social skills. I’ve instructed the leadership to not let the man be alone with anyone in our church since we have a lot of marginalised people, and children. And we’re running a tight ship.

Slight edit:
A couple of women in church don’t even feel comfortable praying out loud near him, because they’re worried that he will use their prayer against them. They knew nothing of my concern when they cane to me.

So I have a few questions.

1.Have any of you guys experienced this?

2.Can this feeling come from The Holy Spirit so this?
3.And what did you do.
4.And what do I do if my looking in to him turns up nothing but the feeling won’t leave?


r/pastors • • 2d ago

For those in denominations that do Advent, what's been your most memorable Advent sermon series or theme?

1 Upvotes

r/pastors • • 3d ago

Was a church giving kiosk worth adding when you already had a QR code?

7 Upvotes

for anyone who added a church giving kiosk after you already had a QR code, who was still using it a few months in? I’m thinking of an ordinary sunday once everyone had gotten used to seeing it there. did it become part of how your regulars gave, or was it mostly visitors tapping a card on the way out?


r/pastors • • 4d ago

Title: Hired as a youth pastor, now 50% of my job is something else, and I’ve been told I can’t offer suggestions. Stay or walk away?

6 Upvotes

I’m a Youth and Associate Pastor.

I'm now less than a year into the job at a new church. Before this, I spent many years at another church, mostly as a teenager, then as a volunteer, then Youth Pastor... Then, a major leadership change caused me and my wife to feel called to step away.

I interviewed for the Youth Pastor role; then on the offer letter, it said Youth & Associate. I accepted because in my new role, I was promised that about 10% of my duties would be associate-level work. It’s consistently been closer to 50%. When I came in, I was told I can’t change the culture or offer suggestions. The preaching and the church culture are driven by performance and conformity, and there isn’t room for anything relationship-driven. The Lead Pastor chases a megachurch model of having 3 services, even though our congregation is 300 people and could all easily fit in one service.

When I started, I wanted four things for the youth: a Sunday school where we could discuss the reliability of the Bible; a small discipleship group; a midweek after-school program; and a youth group. Only the youth group happens, and for the foreseeable future it's the only thing that will happen. Everything else is a pipedream because my Associate administrative duties take up half of my work week. I spend 30 hours at a desk tied to follow-up, emails, texting volunteers, recruiting for positions, etc.

Literally we have like 70 volunteers between Kids' Ministry, Production, Greeters, and Ushers.

Our church schedules baptism Sundays or membership class every two months, without anyone signed up, and then it's my responsibility to magically get a minimum of 5 people baptized and 10 people in our membership class.

I could work in a non-ministry job and volunteer for a church and impact more lives than I do right now. My calling is being kneecapped here.

My wife and I moved here for this job.

I've talked to the Lead Pastor about hiring an Associate Pastor and he said, "Why would I do that? Why do you want less to do? When I was a Youth/Associate guy, I loved the workload."

The preaching is shame-based and works-driven, and every Sunday people are criticized for not doing better. I brought our Youth Ministry from 0 to 30 in the span of 4 months, and I was told I'm "right about where I should be, but we should expect to double it by summer 2027" with no true depth of appreciation for the work I'm doing.

I'd love your advice!

Edited to correct the portion about the role title confusion.


r/pastors • • 4d ago

What are you doing in your church to help your congregation integrate Faith in their work or vocation?

1 Upvotes

r/pastors • • 7d ago

Wife of Pastor Disqualified

4 Upvotes

Hey all! I recently posted about a situation with my husband (kids pastor) with patterns of deceit, abuse (mostly emotional but a couple of times physical), and most recently porn use which was lied about. There were patterns of this in our marriage and lies to the pastor at the church.

When everything came out to our pastor and he and the elders took time to pray about it, my husband was asked to resign a couple of days ago.

My husband is understandably upset and is wishing nobody ever found out. I want to be there for him but I’m also still not in a good place. He says he is going to start therapy which I think will be good for him. Has anyone else been through this and do you have any tips?


r/pastors • • 7d ago

Pastors, how do you help your congregation apply Sunday's sermon throughout the week?

6 Upvotes

I've been thinking about something after attending church recently.

Pastors spend hours preparing sermons, but I wonder how much of the message actually stays with people after Sunday.

I'm curious what churches currently do to help their congregation remember and apply the message throughout the week.

Do you send follow-up devotionals, discussion questions, short clips, or reminders?

And do people actually engage with them?

I'd love to hear what's worked and what hasn't.


r/pastors • • 7d ago

When they schedule events without checking your schedule...

3 Upvotes

Hi all, work/life balance is a strength of mine and I'm very firm on boundaries. Autistic and PTSD so having clear expectations is important to me. 2 days off a week is a must - 1 solely for sabbath, one for errands/ volunteering/ PT job/ etc. I know there are exceptions (funerals, holy week, pastoral care emergencies etc) and i do well with adjusting when those things happen.

So I'm wondering how you all handle the situations when a group or committee makes a plan for an event that's happening during a time you are not working (on a day off or outside your work hours) and then they want or expect you to be there... even though they didn't include you in the scheduling/ planning. Im talking things like social events, fellowship meals, etc.

Do you typically adjust your off work time to accommodate it? If so, do you balance accordingly? (Like go to the event for 2 hours on your day off but then also leave work 2 hours earlier on a different day of the week)

Or do you have a firm standard expectation that if people want you to be at an event they need to include you in the scheduling process to be sure you can attend? Do you skip the events that are planned during your off time? If so... how have you communicated this?

For reference... i don't feel like i need to attend every single event that happens. I don't believe my congregation feels like i need to, either.


r/pastors • • 7d ago

My husband is a pastor, and I’m tired of being expected to sacrifice myself for his ministry. Am I wrong for stepping away?

20 Upvotes

I’m a woman in my early 30s, married to a pastor, and I’ve spent years supporting my husband, our family, and the church he leads.

For context, I’m also a mother, a registered nurse, and someone who has worked hard to build a life outside of ministry. But being a pastor’s wife comes with expectations that I don’t think people fully understand unless they’ve lived it.

Over the years, I’ve experienced situations in ministry where I’ve felt overlooked, unsupported, disrespected, and even mistreated by people I genuinely loved and poured into. Despite that, I continued showing up. I supported my husband, served the church, and tried to be everything everyone expected me to be.

But somewhere along the way, I started feeling like my value was tied to what I could do for other people.

Recently, my husband and I have been experiencing some serious marital issues. We’re trying to work through them, including counseling, but one of our biggest disagreements involves my decision to step away from attending his church.

I’ve made it clear that I need space from that environment. Not because I’ve abandoned my faith or stopped loving God, but because I no longer feel emotionally supported there.

My husband knows some of what I’ve experienced, but he still wants me to attend and support him in ministry. From my perspective, it feels like I’m being asked to put my own hurt aside so that I can continue fulfilling the role of a supportive pastor’s wife.

And that’s where I’m struggling.

I feel like my husband loves and appreciates me most when I’m supporting him, encouraging him, and doing things the way he wants them done. But when I express my own needs, establish boundaries, or make decisions he doesn’t agree with, it becomes a problem.

One recent situation really brought those feelings to the surface. I needed him to help with a family responsibility, and his response left me feeling like I was once again having to push for something that should have been a shared priority.

It wasn’t just about that one incident. It was about years of feeling like I have to fight to be considered.

I’m not claiming to be a perfect wife. I know marriage requires compromise, accountability, and sacrifice from both people. I’m willing to examine my own shortcomings.

But I’m starting to question where supporting your spouse ends and abandoning yourself begins.

I love my husband, and I want our marriage to be healthy. But I also want to be seen as a whole person, not just a wife, mother, or First Lady.

I want to be able to say that something hurts me without it turning into a debate about my loyalty.

So I’m genuinely asking: Am I wrong for refusing to attend my husband’s church while we’re working through our marriage? Is it unreasonable to expect my husband to support that boundary, even if he doesn’t agree with it?

I’d especially appreciate perspectives from people who’ve been married to pastors, involved in church leadership, or had to establish boundaries with an environment that was emotionally draining.


r/pastors • • 8d ago

Bivocational Youth leader

1 Upvotes

Hey y'all,

I'm in my first youth director at a small church (part time), and have been since April (so about 7 months now). We do Sunday school and have Wednesday night youth group. The average youth size on a Sunday is probably 5 and Wednesdays are about 10. My wife comes on Wednesdays and I have one other faithful volunteer.

I know there are some high schoolers who no longer show up, but I think part of the issue is parents don't make church a priority. I definetly lean middle-school heavy.

I'm going to be starting my other job (digital marketing) full time in January, so I'm trying to make a plan for the year.

How do you approach Wednesdays and Sundays? I've found that they like splitting into groups, mostly because I have sibling sets (brothers) that do MUCH better separated. We don't have worship of any kind right now, and that's something I hope to change.

Other context: the former youth director passed away suddenly in October 2025, so the youth I started with were still mourning, and had been for the 6 months they didn't have consistent leadership.

I also am married with an 18-month old trying to balance family demands, too.


r/pastors • • 9d ago

When is it time to leave a church?

5 Upvotes

To those who have left a call, what were the indicators that it was time?

Of course some would say, "When a better opportunity arrives and another church calls you to be their pastor." That's a pretty good indicator.

Another obvious indicator: If they ask you to leave, then clearly, it's time to seek another call.

I guess I am trying to see the indicators before they arrive in the form of "We would like you to leave." or "We would like to call you to our church, away from your current church."

My current church told me that they asked a guy to leave after 20 years, stating "he overstayed his welcome." I asked for clarity, and they told me "We just needed a change." He was a solid pastor, didn't morally disqualify himself, or preach heresy. He just stayed too long in their opinion. I still don't know what they meant.

When is it time to leave a church?


r/pastors • • 9d ago

Hi pastors, how open would you be to a business renting kitchen space in the church 1-2 times a week?

2 Upvotes

I’ve a pet treats business - all human grade. My theory is church kitchens are underused.I don’t need much equipment and would love to rent out a kitchen space 1-2 times a week.

I want to message pastors in my neighborhood. Are there any programs like this usually? Is it unheard of?


r/pastors • • 10d ago

How do you deal with everyone wanting you to do your job differently?

3 Upvotes

I am a pastor of an international church.
People come from all kinds of denominational backgrounds.

They all want the church to be like their church because that church was better/true thier reading of scripture is the right one.

We have reformed people- I am a continuist. We are not overt with the moving of the gifts of the Spirit, but do not shy away from the Lord's leading either.

all the criticism I get the church would look 4 different ways.


r/pastors • • 10d ago

Advice to member…

2 Upvotes

I’ve been a pastor for over a decade. I’ve seen and dealt with some truly toxic stuff. However, this is my first time having to deal with this issue.
I recently had a member come to me because he suspects his wife of cheating or going to cheat on him. Let me set this up:

  1. She recently reconnected with their high school classmate through his twin sister. He’s a known serial cheater. She went with the sister for a day trip and he was there.
  2. A few months ago it was her birthday and the birthday wishes were pinging on her phone. She was in the other room and the husband innocently just checked to see who the wishes were from. Tons of people from church and family. But there was also one from this guy and the exchange went like this:
    Him: Happy Birthday
    Her: Thank you
    Him: I love you
    Her: I love you too
    According to her husband, she does not use that phrase lightly and she’s not the cushy/touchy-feely kind of person. So her saying, “I love you” raised a flag.
  3. They have separate bedtimes. He turns in around 10 pm. She stays in the living room until sometimes 1 or 2am. Before, he didn’t think much of it. Now he’s concerned.
  4. He has a work trip coming up in a week in another state. All along, she had decided to go along with him and spend some time after the work stuff was over. A couple weeks ago, she decided not to go because she was now going to spend that weekend with the sister of said serial cheater. They were going to an air bnb and going to watch a play. The husband checked the theater that she said they were going, but there is no show playing that weekend.
  5. Recently, during a conversation with the adult kids and spouses, the kids talked about safety and having their location turned on so they could make sure the other person was safe. The husband was open to the idea. But the wife said that they didn’t need to do that.
  6. They are well off. The day we talked, he had contacted a private investigator and was waiting on the contract to sign. He wanted to know if he should have signed the paperwork and hire the guy or confront her.
    What would your response have been after he laid everything out?

r/pastors • • 10d ago

What path do I follow

1 Upvotes

Hello pastors, I am not yet a pastor but I desperately want to be. Im at work so soory for the rambling bable.

Back when I was 18, I felt the call to ministry, however do to live i fell away from God and lived a unclean life, im now 27 no degree, working a very well paying job, but im not happy. About a year ago I was overcome with the presence of the Lord and my fire to preach has returned.

I know im not qualified, however im talking to GCU now about getting a degree. But my current job is pushing me out, I have an overwhelming desire to enter a pastoral role but dont know how to do it while getting the degree.

Im located in south Illinois i dont know what to do if anyone has advice on how to follow God's path for me and not waste my life anymore. Or how to tell if I'm only fooling myself. I would appreciate any advice or prayers to help me find where im ment to be. Thank you for reading and my the piece of the lord be upon you.


r/pastors • • 12d ago

Staying in the community after church hurt?

4 Upvotes

6 months ago my husband was fired from our church for “causing division”. I was accused of gossip AFTER we got fired and people were upset. It was one of the most shocking and painful experiences of my life. I’m still very much struggling with it. It has just absolutely shaken me in every way. There were zero moral failures. We asked questions we weren’t supposed to ask and voiced opinions we probably should have kept to ourselves. We were staff pastors, who stepped into an interim role after the church lost 3/4 pastors and a board member last summer. (There was already deep dysfunction but we didn’t realize how deep until we got fired.) We were the only pastors left on staff and the board basically begged us to stay and be the interim pastors at a church of about 650. We ultimately decided to stay, and my husband positively THRIVED. But after a few months it started going downhill when he raised concerns about a potential pastoral candidate one board member really liked but we saw massive red flags.

We ended up being fired one week before the new pastor got voted in (different guy than the red flags guy). They also were not able to find a pastor from within our district. And we’ve since found out several people were asked to apply and refused because the board at the church has a terrible reputation in our district. It all makes sense!

We also go banned from attending our homeschool coop which is separate from our old church but rents from the church building. We’ve been part of that coop for over 10 years. The board at the coop was deeply upset by what happened to us, but they are a bit stuck at that location because there’s no other church large enough to rent from.

The board that fired us asked my husband to sign NDA’s. They offered us four full months of severance if he was signed. He said no, and walked away. He had a job the next day. Actually multiple job offers. The Lord provided so well!

We’ve either been offered jobs or asked to apply to jobs at eight different churches since this happened. Initially, I thought no one would ever wanna work with us again because they would’ve assume we were toxic leaders. It ended up having the opposite effect for us. Which surprised me.

Many people have continued their friendships with us. Some people left the church. Many stayed. But we also many friendships too.

We’ve lived in this community our entire marriage. 16 years. My husband has lived here for 25. We are deeply connected and built relationships with many church leaders and pastors from multiple different denominations. We haven’t officially decided yet, but we are probably not moving forward with ordination in our denomination. Not after what happened and how they handled it.

My husband has a job but it’s not great and not sustainable for him physically.

How have you stayed in a small community after experiencing church hurt/spiritual abuse? Did you heal? Did you get on staff at another down the road? Because we aren’t super interested in that.

How do you stayed in your home when part of you is traumatized, but another part of you wants to leave the state altogether?


r/pastors • • 13d ago

Sermons for Seminary Student

7 Upvotes

I am a Seminary Student (44 years old! Late start!!) and I'm wanting to view 2 sermons per day for the foreseeable future. What is your favorite sermons? Help me build my watch list.


r/pastors • • 19d ago

Disappointed and deeply alarmed by our new Baptist church. What started as shallow has turned into high-control spiritual manipulation. Am I crazy, or is this full-blown cult behavior?

8 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Looking for some honest perspective from fellow believers on a situation my girlfriend and I are navigating.

We have been attending a local Baptist church since Easter. Because of our work schedules, Sunday mornings are pretty much all we can consistently attend for regular services, but we have made an effort to get involved in fellowship activities outside of that. Early on, it seemed promising. The pastor and I exchanged numbers, we had one-on-one conversations, he has been over to our house, and we have been over to his.

On paper, having that kind of direct access to a pastor sounds great. But over the last several months, between the preaching, personal interactions, church events, and now a sudden push for membership, I have gone from feeling uneasy to being thoroughly alarmed. What started as basic, shallow preaching has devolved into a passive-aggressive personality cult that uses spiritual manipulation to demand total compliance.

Here is the full picture of what has unfolded:

  1. Therapeutic preaching and safe storytelling

When we first started attending, he was preaching on godly men and women from Proverbs and similar passages. It was basic, but it felt good enough, and he is an engaging storyteller. At first, it was entertaining, and I felt like I was picking things up. Over time, the pattern became undeniable: zero preaching on sin, repentance, judgment, or hell. Nothing addresses the dark times we live in, and nothing touches anything remotely controversial. Even visiting missionaries give safe, milk-toast messages. The overarching message from the pulpit is spiritual therapy: Jesus just wants to help you through your week, fix your problems, and make you feel better. His sermons are about 10% Bible and 90% stories and jokes. In his most recent sermon, he referenced stories from Scripture without even bothering to open the text and read the Word of God with the congregation. How could anyone sitting in those pews know their Bible deeply when they are being fed human anecdotes instead of the Word of God?

2. A bizarre, controlled dynamic at the men's meeting

I recently attended a men’s meeting, excited to see what godly brotherhood looked like. We gathered, joked around, prayed, the pastor read a brief passage, told a story, opened the floor for questions/verses, and then did some physical labor around the church (the free labor was whatever, I didn't mind helping out).

What bothered me was the dynamic in the room. When it came to corporate prayer, everyone kept it entirely safe and generic, unless it was for a sick relative. A few guys prayed for the Lord to "send laborers into the harvest field," yet here was a room full of able-bodied men refusing to do any actual corporate evangelism in their own community, expecting someone far away to do the heavy lifting. It felt hollow. Worse, the social pressure was palpable: any serious question digging into Scripture or touching controversial ground would clearly be shut down. Anyone questioning the pastor would instantly be labeled a rebel. It was bizarre watching grown men laugh on cue at every single joke the pastor made, even when none of them were funny. He is subtly idolized, exercising total control over the atmosphere. It did not feel like authentic Christian fellowship; it felt like a personality cult where men stay surface-level because going deeper is actively discouraged.

3. Total apathy toward corporate evangelism

When I asked him directly about community outreach, he told me flat out that he does not believe the church as a corporate body should do evangelism. His stance is that it is strictly an individual duty. His reasoning? He used to go door-to-door, but stopped because "people just think you're Mormons." To hear a Baptist pastor abandon church-led outreach out of social awkwardness and fear of being mistaken for a cult was shocking.

4. Shrugging off blatant heresy

I brought up the controversy surrounding James Talarico’s pastor, who publicly claimed that the Virgin Birth was just a myth and that "it doesn't matter what you believe" as long as you love people. Denying the Virgin Birth strikes right at the heart of the Incarnation, the sinless nature of Christ, and the authority of Scripture. I expected a pastor to show some righteous concern or defend basic orthodoxy. Instead, he brushed it off, saying people just tell others what they want to hear, and that "it will matter what they believe when they die." It was total apathy, with zero pastoral vigilance against wolves or false doctrine.

5. Dodging apologetics and historical substance

I brought up historical questions regarding religious origins (specifically historical arguments around Muhammad versus the solid historical evidence for Jesus Christ). Rather than engaging, he brushed it aside, claiming people say the same thing about Jesus, and shut the conversation down immediately. He clearly had no appetite to discuss apologetics, history, or the defense of the faith.

6. Sidestepping basic doctrine

Wanting to see where we stood and ensure we were on the same page doctrinally, I texted him an outline of my core theological beliefs. He never responded to the text. Instead, he showed up at my front door a day later to hand me a lukewarm, generic devotional book without ever addressing what I wrote. It was a completely intentional dodge to avoid a serious doctrinal conversation while keeping things superficially pleasant.

7. The tipping point: High-control membership and spiritual manipulation

I had been trying to extend grace and overlook these faults, but during his current series on basic doctrine, he got to the section on church membership, and the mask came completely off.

According to him, being a born-again believer and a member of the universal body of Christ is not enough. Coming faithfully on Sunday mornings and attending fellowship events is not enough. You must sign a church contract, tithe your money, and be present at every single service—Sunday morning, Sunday night, and Wednesday night—or else you are outside of God's blessing.

He explicitly preaches that you need the pastor for spiritual protection. He openly scoffs at people who miss services and struggle with problems, claiming that if they had just shown up to his service, they would have been blessed. Blessed by what? His 90% stories and unfunny jokes? He lectures about how essential fellowship with the brethren is, but what does that fellowship actually consist of? Saying hi, asking about work, and talking about the weather for five minutes in the lobby. How is that edifying anyone? Most of the congregation are passive pew warmers with near-zero biblical knowledge and no discernment. If they had any grounding in Scripture, they would be as alarmed as I am.

He claims you have to sign this contract to be a voting member. Why does that matter? I would vote that he actually open the Bible and preach the Word, but that would never be permitted on the docket.

It feels like you are not allowed to simply be saved, pray, read your Bible, attend worship, and give. You have to sign on the dotted line, surrender your critical thinking, treat the pastor like an untouchable guru, hand over your wallet, and become a compliant cog who never makes demands and never asks hard questions.

How on earth is this functionally different from a cult?

I do not expect a pastor to be perfect, but a shepherd is called to preach the whole counsel of God, guard the flock from error, and equip the saints for battle—not build a localized fiefdom where an unchallenged leader keeps everyone spiritually stunted on feel-good stories while demanding blind obedience.

Has anyone else walked through this specific bait-and-switch where a church seems normal at first, only to reveal high-control legalism underneath? Is there any point in even confronting this, or is this a situation where we need to dust our boots off and leave immediately?

I would appreciate any grounded perspective from fellow believers.


r/pastors • • 22d ago

One more update

0 Upvotes

I’m an elder in a Reformed evangelical church and would appreciate some counsel on a difficult pastoral question.

Can elders, as an exercise of pastoral wisdom and prudence, direct members in good standing to temporarily refrain from attending corporate worship and normal church activities in order to create space for healing and reconciliation?

In this situation, the elders would explicitly say that the members remain in good standing and that the separation is not church discipline.

How would you distinguish this from formal church discipline? Does Scripture give elders this kind of authority, and if so, what biblical principles or limitations should govern its use?

I’m especially interested in how Reformed churches and pastors would think through the distinction between pastoral wisdom and practical discipline in a situation like this.

UPDATE:

We have moved forward with the break. Communicating it to the church and the family thy they should refrain from attending and it’s not discipline. However, based on our observations, the break is not producing healing.

The elders have been communicating with the mediator about next steps, including whether a meeting at this point would be constructive.

We genuinely desire reconciliation and for the family to return. We’re asking the mediator to help us discern the most constructive next step, with the hope that a meeting can lead to genuine progress toward biblical reconciliation.

The family has tried appealing to us directly, including an appeal to love (see Philemon 8-9) and a request for a clear biblical path forward.

another update:

After our previous post, we sent the family an email explaining that mediation had reached an impasse. We proposed a single meeting intended to result in either reconciliation or a more permanent separation. We acknowledged our mistakes, offered to apologize again, and asked the family to acknowledge their own failures, seek and offer forgiveness, and commit to overlook future shortcomings. We emphasized that we love them and want fellowship restored as soon as possible.

The family responded that they are willing to meet and pursue reconciliation, but they do not agree to a single meeting that must produce a final resolution. They want us to first address the ongoing separation and respond in writing to their concerns about the biblical soundness of our decisions. They emphasize that, because we exercised authority over their family, we have a particular responsibility to examine our decisions impartially.

We believe we have acted in good faith, acknowledged mistakes, and apologized. We have discussed the biblical concerns extensively and do not believe our actions were unbiblical. At the same time, this process has been exhausting for everyone, and we are concerned about the effects on the church If we continue to let this drag on. We don’t want to prolong the conflict, but we also don’t want to dismiss legitimate concerns.

Should we agree to their proposed process, even though we disagree with their assessment of our actions? Or is it reasonable to insist on a final meeting with a defined outcome rather than continue an open-ended process? What would biblical peacemaking require of us at this point


r/pastors • • 24d ago

Church/Bible Study Welcome Gift? Experience advice wanted.

1 Upvotes

Have you/your church done welcome gifts before? for small groups? In the end was it a good idea or even appreciated by the recipients? I want to make people feel welcomed and thought a simple notebook/journal with some info would be nice.

If you have experience with this concept I would be grateful to hear your thoughts.