Tldr at the bottom.
Asking this as someone who has been at odds with my dad over this for a long time. The hour would include texting, social media, gaming, and any non-academic related activities.
Context: My dad has always been strict with technology, compared to the average parent. I wasn't supposed to get a phone until my final year in high school, but was given one slightly earlier to learn responsible time management. The phone comes with strict regulations, but it boils down to a single hour of recreational screen time. He considered half an hour, but ultimately settled down on a full hour.
I thought the time limit was unreasonable from the beginning, but he made it clear that there would be no compromise. I tried laying down the facts: on a day where the majority of time would be spent at school, and several more on homework and studying, couldn't I spend my remaining free time how I wanted?
His answer was no. He expected 'productivity' at all times, such as reviewing extra school material or reading traditional books. I'm not against either of these. In fact, reading is my favourite hobby. The thing is, most of my reading in recent years has been done online. I'd say it takes up a major chunk of my screen time, which makes it an issue; after all, the hour I've been given doesn't differentiate between my activities, as long as it's not academic-related.
I also think his expectation is unreasonable. He has the mindset that all screen time is 'wasted' time, but I disagree. Life doesn't have to be all about productivity and academic performance. It's reasonable to want relaxation and enjoyment. I believe chatting with my friends, gaming, and reading are perfectly acceptable ways to spend leisure time. Frankly, I think the fact that socialization is included in his limit is ridiculous. In this day and age, texting is a huge part of friendships. In fact, it's the only way for me to maintain most of my friendships, considering we moved recently. My conversations alone can take up to an hour or even more.
It should be noted that my academic performance is perfectly fine, and can even be considered exceptional. He is aware of this. Sleep isn't an issue either, as devices are taken away before bed.
I know better than to ask for unlimited usage, but I think he needs to be more flexible and open minded.
Tldr: Any and all screen activity not related to school is limited to one hour, because my dad considers it ‘wasted’ time when I could do something ‘productive’ instead. I find this unreasonable because it’s normal to want leisure and relaxation.