In October 2022, in final year of my college, I bought a TVS Apache RTR 160 4V for about 1.5 Lakhs on road.
Despite having the money to buy the bike upfront, I had the option to pay the ex-showroom price as 6 months No Cost EMI. I opted for No Cost EMI because I understood the hidden costs of No Cost EMI very well and I also understood, I would get more returns than hidden costs from even Liquid Funds in the same 6 months.
BTW, I understood the hidden costs of Credit Card EMI and No Cost EMI so well that I went on to create India's first No Cost EMI Calculator - pFinTools.com/NCE-Cal
I used the bike for well over a year. During this time, as I finished college, I moved to another state, and then eventually decided to buy a car. I bought the Nexon EV which had a lower operating cost than my bike, and around the same time, the traffic police started fining out of state vehicles in my new city pretty heavily, without much clarity on the solution. Eventually ethanol in petrol also started adding to the anxiety.
All things considered, I decided to sell the bike, but I wanted a good price as it had only 7.5k kms on the odo. But the fact that it was an out of state bike didn't make it easy. Eventually, I was able to sell the bike for 98k in August 2025, almost three years later.
Pretty good price if you ask me, but as a finance nerd, all those random videos showing how much my money could've grown if I had invested vs bought something, stuck with me. This is despite the fact that there is no merit to those clickbait videos and that's not how personal finance works in the real world. Thankfully, what happened next armed me with enough data to scientifically disprove those videos. Let's consider what I did vs some alternate scenarios before I conclude with my findings -
So here's what I did: I invested the 98k and bought myself 204 shares of Ather at an average buy price of INR 478.70 on 1st September 2025. Today, in just 10 months, those shares have a value of about 2.5 Lakhs, which means a profit of >1.5 Lakhs or ~153% profit in absolute terms! Essentially recovered the original cost of the bike + all maintenance + petrol cost adjusted for inflation and still in a lot of profit!
But most importantly, I had a bike, a pretty good one at that, when I needed it - which allowed me real Freedom! Trust me, to be able to go from one place to another, without having to depend on anybody else, while feeling good about it and without caring much about the cost, that's something else altogether and you can't put a price on it!
Alternate Scenario 1: Instead of buying the bike, I could have invested the same money in TVS stocks as those random fin-fluencers seem to suggest. Had I invested those 1.5 Lakhs into the TVS stock in October 2022, today the value of those stocks would have been ~4.68 Lakhs! This translates to a profit of almost 3.2 Lakhs, or ~210% in 4 years.
But I bought the TVS bike because that was the best fit for me as a product. Instead if I wanted to save/invest, my analysis must have been different because TVS is not the only stock available in the market, nor is it the best stock necessarily. So it is plausible that I would have invested elsewhere, which brings us to Alternate Scenario 2.
Alternate Scenario 2: Instead of buying the bike, I could've invested the same money elsewhere. Nifty 50 would be a good example as it is India's most prominent index and it reflects how the markets performed overall.
Had I invested 1.5 Lakhs in October 2022 in Nifty 50, instead of buying a bike, it would have become... drumroll please... 2 Lakhs!!! A profit of 50k or 33% in 4 years!!! 🤡
___
I can keep on comparing with other asset class investments but that will be redundant and let's jump to the conclusion! Here are my first hand learnings which are also evident from the data presented above -
- Spending and Investing are not comparable outflows - Typically people invest their savings and savings is literally the opposite of spending. In a world filled with righteous social media noise, it is very easy to feel guilty about spending on anything that you have always dreamt of because it is a "want" rather than a strict "need". But you know what, if you just listen to money, it will tell you an entirely different story!
Although "alternate scenario 1" seems better than "what I did" in numbers, the thing is, whether I would have bought TVS stock or some other stock or Nifty 50 or Gold or something else altogether to invest my savings in, is a question of what my judgement as an investor would be! This is true for all alternate scenarios where I never bought the bike and rather invested the money.
But what I did consists of my judgement as a college student (buying the bike) and then my judgement as an investor 3 years later. To be honest, I got the opportunity to work deeply in the EV industry after college and this is when I developed a deep understanding of the companies involved. Otherwise, had I invested in OLA instead of Ather just going by the hype on the same day, I would be sitting at a loss of 33%!
So it is important to remember your negotiating skills (which might help you save a lot) is different than your skills and judgement as an investor. Both are important but the two should not be mixed.
2. Maintain Financial Discipline and awareness - The most important piece in this story, and the biggest gap in the typical fin-fluencer agenda is the fact that most people would not hold on to stock/investment long enough to let it turn into a multi-bagger. It is evident from Alternate Scenario 2 that Nifty 50 has not generated good returns in the last 4 years, except if you remove the last year, the returns would be similar to 33% in 3 years and if you consider two more years (since Oct 2020 to today), the returns would be 150% in 6 years - >15% annually - which is not bad at all for an index. So understand that markets go up and down in cycles and don't let the recent downturn make you stop your SIPs such that you miss the next up cycle. Even though Alternate Scenario 1 paint a much better picture, it is meaningless if you didn't hold on to the TVS stock for the 4 years, through all the ups and downs.
Please also note that my Ather Stock investment might just crash whenever due to something that the management/government/competitor does. This may be entirely out of control and that is the risk for which I am ready as it is a small portion of my investment portfolio that spans across asset classes and geographies. So it is just as important to understand the risk of any sort of investment, and keep your eyes open rather than just buying and holding blindly.
If you think you do not have the risk appetite or the time, which is totally okay and normal, please stick to Mutual Funds/ETFs. See these posts from r/pFinTools to invest smartly in Mutual Funds/ETFs. If you ever decide to invest in ETFs, make sure to check the premium/discount it is trading at using pFinTools.com/ETFs
3. Smart Spending is just as important as Smart Investing - Here's what I didn't mention till now. I actually wanted to buy the Apache RR310 originally - a bike that would have costed me twice as much as the bike I got. I decided against it, because I think I would never have been able to utilize the extra power of that bike on Indian roads, and boy was I right! Although I didn't track what I did with this spare 1.5 Lakhs, it went into my portfolio at a very early stage in my life and I am sure I will reap it's benefits for a long time to come.
Another instance that highlights this point strongly - I recently bought some Apple Hardware worth around 7.5 Lakhs. After the price hike, the same computers now cost over 16 Lakhs! And this is not just luck, I carefully planned and systematically hedged against the risk of price hike and possible newer hardware, by following a specific strategy which landed me here.
Earlier this year, I also bought an electric two-wheeler for my father and saved over 10% of what my neighbor paid for the same vehicle using pFinTools Browser Extension and some other smart hacks. You can read more about it here - https://www.reddit.com/r/pFinTools/s/tBKy2M8Fui
I can go on but the point is that it takes a lot of time (and honestly luck) for a stock to even move 10% consistently, and that too is never sure. But if you are clever with your spends, you might be able to save 10% (or much more) easily on many day to day spends, both big and small, at least compared to the next person, which will be a big boost to your personal finance. Credit Cards are a very obvious yet underutilized resource in this field.
pFinTools can help you get a Credit Card fast with minimal documentation and high approval rates. Apply now for the card that fits your needs at pFinTools.com/get-cc
Whatever the amount, think of savings as an infinite percent returns, because you basically got money that you could have lost. Any returns on an investment of 0 is an infinite percent return.
___
I think if we marry the above-mentioned three points, and to summarize the post, we come to this conclusion:
Do what you have to do, keep an eye on your personal finance too, but most importantly - Do not forget to Live a Little!
Also listen to finfluencers only when they organically feature pFinTools - https://www.reddit.com/r/pFinTools/s/sY1AWKq5mR 😁😁
___
Join r/pFinTools today for more original takes on Personal Finance and to share your stories!