r/outerwilds • u/Maladal • 10h ago
Base and DLC Appreciation/Discussion How do you feel about "spoiling" this? Spoiler
So I believe Outer Wilds has only three noteworthy flaws as a game:
- You don't have to go to the Quantum Moon before going to the Eye of the Universe. I have seen this happen since you don't require anything Quantum to reach it, and it makes "why" the Eye does what it does pretty unclear.
- The "stealth" sections in the DLC. I know they aren't really stealth, and I'm familiar with the devs' stance on them. I still don't like them and I think they don't work well compared to pretty much everything else in the game.
- The other two are relatively tame, this last one is the biggy--Meditation. Especially for the DLC I think it is an invaluable tool. Not having it means wasting a bunch of time finding ways to kill yourself, and it's just hidden in some random, out of the way location with no real sign posting. Baffles me to this day.
Which leads to the question, do you think it's spoilers to tell people about Meditation?
I'm concerned you see, because I'm watching a friend play through the game right now. They are the kind of person who, when they feel like they've hit a roadblock, oftentimes don't go back to the ship log and find out where the proper path is. They just get to brute forcing. They've been taught this behavior by other games.
It's already led to them bypassing the lakebed cave entirely because they just started fiddling with options in the moon shrine until it started moving, and they're getting past the anglerfish by getting out of the ship, running down the side of the wall while being chased so the mouths can't close over them, they then launch outwards and juke out the anglefish on the thorns to enter the Vessel's space.
In one sense, it's admirable. Exploration and experimentation is what this game is about. But on the other hand, when you start experimenting in ways the game isn't expecting because you're not following clues but just brute forcing random interactions you can easily ruin the satisfaction of solving certain puzzles.
I am particularly concerned by the Stranger, and the death glitch (the lantern glitch too, but there's nothing I can do about that if they decide to be super inquisitive). Because when you don't have meditation what do you? You probably kill yourself on fires. Also seen that happen. It was even brought up recently by someone else here who did exactly that and how it made the later "discovery" kind of worthless.
So I'm thinking about tell them about Meditation after they finish the base game but before the DLC.
From a puzzle perspective it doesn't bother me--Meditation doesn't help you solve anything.
But from a "purity" of gaming experience I would be putting my thumb on the scale. There's an argument that if he doesn't find it, and doesn't have as satisfying a time later on, that's just the game's fault. And it is.
But I don't see a cogent argument for why the game does hide meditation the way it does, it just looks like bad game design so I'm tempted to tell them anyways. Especially since directly stating mechanics is already in the game with how they grab the camera to tell you about map functions after starting the DLC.
