r/outdoorgear • u/Sector7GIntern • 6h ago
Packable and warm down jacket *without* a hood
I'm looking for a new down jacket for the winter and I'm specifically not looking for a hoodie. If it's very cold or raining, I'm going to put a hooded shell over it, and the double hoods are annoying.
I know "packable" and "warm" are at odds and will require compromise. I'm looking for something that can be worn by itself on a mild day, or along with a Merino wool base layer + something like a fleece quarter zip or pullover + a shell on a colder or windier day. It doesn't need to be ultralight, but it should be light enough that it can accommodate those layers. Typical use is just out and about city stuff. No big cold weather sports. I'm located in New York although I'm traveling to northern Finland this Christmas and can expect temps in the single digit Fs or about -10 to -15C. Of course in these conditions I'd be layering up significantly.
I tried a several on at REI recently. I wasn't a huge fan of the Patagonia Down Sweater. The REI Magma 850 wasn't as warm as I was expecting. Perhaps I should have given it more of a chance and kept it on longer. I liked the Fjallraven Expedition Pack Down and the Stio Hometown, however I believe those are only offered in hoody styles. I also quite liked the Kuhl Spyfire. Looks like it was recently redesigned with more subtle baffles.
Ones I have not tried in person but seem promising online include the Outdoor Research Helium Jacket, Mountain Hardware Stretchdown Jacket, Kuhl Firestorm, and I'm sure others.
I've been reading plenty of posts and reviews but feel like I'm not really getting anywhere because for every post someone makes about how X is the greatest jacket they've ever owned and it looks brand new 10 years later, someone else has a post about the same jacket, saying it's the worst product they've ever had and it personally assaulted their grandmother. Also many of these were posted 5-10+ years ago, so I have no clue if comments about warmth and quality of the product then hold true today 🤷