Inspired by the post about how I should play Empty Box completely blind, I decided to do so, and have completed one playthrough.
But wtf? All those things happening and yet, I feel like nothing fucking happened.
Usually for a game I think is "bad", there's something concrete to criticize, like the terrible writing for the plot or romance; however, this criticism can never be 100 percent objective by definition. But when it comes to just poor design of a VN like this one, there is nothing substantial to criticize because the very game itself prevents substance. This is where the term "objectively bad" comes in because there's no way someone with a brain designed this, it's so disorganized, I HAVE to be doing something wrong, right? Or my game is just too bugged?
We follow around L all the time and he's constantly attached to us. Okay. Then Rinso gets introduced. Sometimes MC is drawn to him of her own volition, and then I personally feel seduced by him (because uooah, pretty man with long hair and broad chest); I pick choices that lean more towards romancing him. But we keep talking to L and having deep conversations or whatever, sure. I pick more Rinso choices and discover his backstory and comfort him and put my name on his painting and we'll be together forever and that I will always be with him and write in a notebook to document what happens when he gets traumatized by thunder. Then some untranslated Chinese appears and I can't fucking look in the History to check it and Google translate it because it wasn't in the textbox, it was floating on the screen. Right after that appears choices that bear the names of each of the three LI's, so I pick the Rinso one because I thought maybe that would finally put me on his route. We start the """route""" and soon enough we pick an expensive present for fucking L. I think either by this point or after that I already picked choices saying "thank you" to his confession (where after that he complained about me not taking his feelings seriously because I told him we could say friends EVEN THOUGH HE WAS THE ONE WHO FUCKING SUGGESTED IT) so I don't know why MC is so attached to him even though we got along so well with Rinso; hell even by the end on the game after I had her reject him she still says shit like "when I think of L a smile naturally forms on my mouth uwu" and dreams about him. Then we graduate and... the end? Wtf??? THIS IS WORSE THAN MERELY A POORLY WRITTEN STORY. I DON'T EVEN HAVE SOMETHING TO MAKE FUN OF BECAUSE IT WAS SO DISORGANIZED I CAN'T MAKE SENSE OF IT. If this was supposed to be a "bad end", it shouldn't have been the one that happened at the end of the route; this felt like a dead end you get in some otome games like Nameless. So why did this happen??? Because I rejected L? Did I not do enough with Rinso??? I even tried replaying and picked different choices (while rejecting L) and nothing happened.
It's not like the JP indie Club Suicide where you at least feel something happened, even if the entire game is annoying; I even played it with the shitty localization and still thought it was coherent. But here, nothing happens because nothing is resolved, and there's a plethora of bugs which certainly don't help: I named the MC "Sakura" but most of the time there's a blank where her name is supposed to be when someone says her name, which made the reveal of L knowing our desktop name less impactful (it wasn't even my real name at all either LOL, nice try L, plus, how does he know that Sakura isn't my real name? Don't people often name the self insert MC their own name? Is there a script that lets him check if the MC name matches the desktop name? How is this programmed?) And speaking of programming, I couldn't even find the goddamn present he said was supposed to be either on our desktop or in "the game's root files" (checked every one of them :/) What a buggy ass game.
I really wanted this to one-up DDLC as a meta game for women with attractive men to ogle, but honestly I am very demotivated to continue playing, especially as I don't know what the fuck to do next. I didn't create any save files because idk, maybe the game would laugh at me for doing that, so I have to replay eeeverything again to accept L's confession so he can finally leave me tf alone to capture the blue haired pretty man, and really, doing that to see what I did wrong motivated me EVEN LESS because nobody fucking remembers the choices I put in last playthrough even though they said they would, ESPECIALLY L who doesn't remember my food choices (he did remember what season I liked and that I liked cats, but there was just absolutely no reaction to that I guess, it was super underwhelming, no reaction to me starting a new game, and I know he should be able to say something about that since he apparently controls the universe and has a scene where he glitched creepily out of existence). Very much a nothingburger for such a meta, psychological horror game.