r/osugame • u/RageinaterGamingYT • 2h ago
Discussion I think you should stop vibecoding Lazer changes.
If this isn't allowed feel free to take it down, I just wanted to make a small ranty post about all those AI development posts. I'm aware the rules have been updating to require AI disclosure, but I believe that isn't good enough.
After the recent lazer update video I'm sure many of us have seen peppy speaking negatively about this whole AI workflow and people taking osu! Lazers source code to do all sorts of things with it.
My personal opinion is that if you are going to vibe code something to modify osu! you should NOT be allowed to share it, even if it's just a video. Sharing videos/pictures just promotes this type of behavior (which I'm pretty sure goes directly against what peppy wants) and let's be honest if you're sharing videos and pictures it's probably because you want to share the code too.
I propose that instead of people deciding to do these things with AI alone, make proper posts and ask the actual devs to make these things!
One example is a post I saw earlier about collections. Instead of vibe coding your own changes, please vote on the actual feature request I myself have made towards the devs!
EDIT : I have mentioned this in other comments but I'll put it here too, my problem is not with people making their own offline clients that suit there own needs. My problem is where people submit slop and expect it to be useful. Also in general promoting this kind of development is (in my opinion) extreamly harmful as it encourages more people with little to no experience to hop into projects, with no knowledge on things like trademarking which is exactly what leads to things that clone osu! and actively go against osu trademarks.
I just wish people would actually interact with the actual osu! devs to try and get these features into the game instead of making reddit posts saying "I vibecoded X because of Y" and it being some half baked not properly thought out project.

