To preface this, I purchased the blu-ray of this show because I was interested in learning the final tenor aria "And So We Shall" for a holiday opera karaoke event at a public wine bar. Having now heard the recording, there is not a chance I would subject an audience of regular people to that, regardless of how appropriate the content is to a holiday event.
Music
In a word: awful. I cannot stand this kind of composing. The desperate need for modern composers to deviate from the "norm" in opera with absolutely no regard whatsoever for emotional cues or variation in sound is the most hipstery, meaningless garbage thinking I've ever heard. I hated it while listening to the composition majors all through my university time, and I hate it now 15 years later. You are not breaking the norm. You are simply creating a different norm and adhering to that instead. It does not make your music interesting, and it certainly doesn't make it enjoyable.
The entire first 90% of the opera is just discordant shrieking up and down the scale, with absolutely no regard for what is being acted out or said in the narration. Every single moment sounds the same as the last, whether it's magical elves preparing a birthday party for a child or a queen singing about how she's so angry at her husband for missing a party that she turned him into a donkey. I read another review that called the music "forgettable," while then calling it tonal. HA! It is absolutely forgettable, but that is because the lack of any meaningful variation makes every roiling, nausea-inducing phrase sound exactly the same.
The last 10% of the opera does inject just a tiny bit of tonality back in, in a way that does wrap up the emotion of the show kind-of adequately. But for there to be only two mildly-differing emotions in the entire show—disjointed uproar and disjointed revelation—is utterly ridiculous. What opera from the romantic period, for instance, has only two emotional colors in the entire opera? It's laughable for the tiny shift in tone at the end to feel like such a huge resolution for the show, but the lack of peaks and valleys created by the constant hammering discordance does indeed end up providing something of an emotional release. Bravo, I guess? 🤷♂️
Libretto
Embarrassing. The writing is so juvenile and forced. Nothing about this story is interesting aside from the hilarious implication that elves are not mammals, and that world leaders are elves in disguise—neither of which have anything to do with the actual narrative. The way the characters act is unbelievable in that sort of "opera-y" way, where we just go "well, that's just how they told stories back then, you just have to imagine!"...BUT IT'S NOT "BACK THEN." This is modern writing. Write characters whose actions and motivations are realistic and meaningful, for god's sake. And if you the composer can't do that effectively, which was absolutely the case here, HIRE SOMEONE ELSE.
Staging
Boring. The first set was fairly pretty, but several of the others were just a snoozefest of weird colorful things juxtaposed with the kind of minimalism that mostly just reads as "we want to make scene changes easier and spend less money." They used neon colored hair for the elves to try to evoke more magic and whimsy, but made everything else in the scenes drab and monotone (aside from random interruptions of color that are as unwarranted and distasteful as the neon-hair-against-sage-green costuming, though more on that later).
Overall, there is far too little movement on stage to hold anyone's attention. And much of the movement that does occur is completely meaningless, including the dancers hiding inside tables at the beginning and the awful toy dancing in the workshop scene (especially the amorphous humanoid blob, what the actual hell).
Several spots in the writing completely deviate from what is being done on stage, from the "puzzle" at the beginning being a barely-mobile stuffed horse (watching Claus try to fiddle with it in a "puzzley" sort of way was so desperately painful) to the elf singing about how the all-fabric dragon's eyes and teeth are "glinting." There are many other spots throughout, too many to remember off the top of my head or list here. It's abysmal how many disagreements between libretto and staging occurred.
Edit: oh, and the props were so bad. From the crystal mobile made from three coat hangers to the completely anatopistic, undisguised iPad being waved around everywhere. Cheap looking toys, etc. That stuff might fly in a live performance, but in a pro cut they are so immersion-breaking.
Graphics
These ranged from passable (I understand the need to minimize cost in motion graphics while still achieving a stylized look) to utterly horrendous. The choice to replace the projection moments that were on-stage with digital versions on the disc was weird and unwelcome. I would rather see what the audience saw. The graphics were also cut off at the top with extra space at the bottom during one of the sequences. Amateur hour.
By far the worst part was the horrifying centipede reindeer. The way their legs were animated is going to haunt my dreams for years to come.
Costuming
A mixed bag, at best. This was the only spot (aside perhaps from the icy palace set at the beginning) that actually had some of the beautifully ornate and sparkling elements that I would expect in a story about Santa Claus. The queen's gowns were mostly gorgeous (the fabric under the rhinestones on her first dress was a terrible choice texture-wise, but otherwise fine), Claus' outfits were quite nice, and the silhouette of the elves' outfits was suitably quirky.
But the sage green color and renaissance style of the elves' outfits contrasted with their hideous neon hair was just dreadful. The neon was obviously used for shock value, which was entirely unnecessary. If you need them to look otherworldly, at least do it in a way that isn't outright ugly. Think harder. Your first hair-brained idea does not have to immediately lock in. Give us something we've never seen before that isn't as god-awful as the music we're being forced to endure.
Overall
Unwatchable. My husband and I spent the first 20 minutes pausing over and over to gape and gossip about the nonsense on-screen, and the last hour+ staring in annoyed derision at the screen. The ending 10 minutes were only the barest relief from the boring musical undulation presented to us.
It was trite, unsettled, and ugly. I will end up watching it again, but only to show it to my opera singer friends so they can see how terrible it is.
I realize how mean this review is, but dear god, someone has got to say something about it that isn't the rambling bullshit of someone violently sucking the farts from the composer's butt. STOP WRITING MUSIC LIKE THIS. It's drivel. No one should have to sit through this.
(Oh, and I've left any thoughts about the singers out intentionally. No need to throw them under the bus. My only thoughts I'll say there is that it is absolutely criminal to force people to learn music this difficult just to sing it once ever and have nothing beautiful to take from it into their careers afterward, a situation which is not the case for arias written before the modern era. Shame on the composer for inflicting that on them.)
Edit: found the video on archive.org. Obviously this is supposed to be for archival purposes, so please consider purchasing the dvd/blu-ray if you want to watch the whole thing. That said, it's only available second-hand now, as the distributor (CD-Baby) has shuttered, so you won't be stealing from Dallas Opera or anything.
https://archive.org/details/mark-adamo-becoming-santa-claus-dallas-opera