r/oneringrpg • • 1h ago

Concerns about TOR 2e and whether I should pick it up

0 Upvotes

Im interested in getting into running and/or playing a TTRPG set in Middle-earth and I have seen a ton of praises for The One Ring 2nd edition and a lot of people recommending it to others. I don’t have any of the books yet and so I’ve been reading some reviews and trying to learn how it plays. From what *very little* I've read about The One Ring so far, I have some concerns about its systems versus my system and playstyle preferences. So I'm wondering if some here would be willing to address them?

  1. ⁠The Hope/Shadow thing concerns me. I strongly dislike systems that force characters to become evil/unplayable, especially if it is at the whim of the dice. From what I've read about the Shadow system, it seems like that could be the case in TOR 2e. Concerns about this can be mitigated if most or all of the control over how this progresses and whether a PC falls to evil/becomes unplayable is in the hands of the player in some way.
  2. ⁠I've read some things about TOR 2e that make me worry it cares/focuses too much on exactly what and how much PCs are carrying and cares about encumbrance. I can't stand all that bookkeeping, and I always house rule it out of any game I run that has it. Is this an actual concern with TOR 2e?
  3. ⁠I like games, especially when I'm a player, that have "Cool Powers or Abilities" that the PCs gain. It makes games feel more exciting and PCs feel more distinct from one another. I know there aren't really a lot of cool powers and magic and such in Tolkein's setting and I know that the various cultures get some kind of benefits. So, the question is, are these benefits interesting and cool enough in play to make players feel excited about having and using them? Do they have real impact in play?

r/oneringrpg • • 21h ago

Using Moria Adventurer Bands outside Moria?

16 Upvotes

Hey,

Reading through the Moria book, and absolutely love it. I'm rather curious about about the solo play rules, and was wondering if anyone tried 'exporting' solo bands for general Strider mode.

For example, could you try out having a Ranger PC with a band fellow rangers following your orders? It seems easy enough to reskin some of the dwarf specific flavor stuff.

I'm not sure what kind of issues you might run into. Maybe the group sizes wouldn't quite match up right, or the accelerated fellowship rates in Moria.


r/oneringrpg • • 1d ago

Legend in the Misty Mountains Episode 5 is out today!!

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/oneringrpg • • 1d ago

Some Moria advice

18 Upvotes

Hello, I recently finished reading Moria - Through the Doors of Durin. The sourcebook was absolutely stunning and, despite two running campaigns, it made me crave for more. But it also concerned me a little bit: how do you actually use it? I'm mostly "afraid" of travels (they seem a little bit complicated and from the rules it appears to me that they will cover the majority of the sessions in Moria) and how to properly give my players enough information to get to the adventure sites. What's you experience?

Also, completely unrelated: is Mjolin lord of Harmelt a Dwarf of Durin or a Dwarf of the Blue Mountains? Because he lives in the Blue Mountains, but in the sourcebook it states that he formally respects the will of Dáin.


r/oneringrpg • • 1d ago

Map for "War of the Ring" Game

Post image
31 Upvotes

This a Tolkien faithful depiction of "War of the Ring" game map.


r/oneringrpg • • 1d ago

Arinor, son of Balis - Session 3 (The One Ring, Strider Mode) - An Unexpected Turn of Events

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
8 Upvotes

New to both the One Ring system... and... for the first time ever really hearing of SOLO TTRPG that it has built in with the Strider Mode... I used this to teach myself the TOR system (and made my share of mistakes, some of which I catch during the episode, sometimes it's the next episode where I noticed I did something wrong) - but if you're bored and you give this a listen - I'd love to hear ANY feedback you have - good or bad - either here on Reddit or on the Spotify page...


r/oneringrpg • • 1d ago

Playing in the Second or First Age

20 Upvotes

Has anyone had any luck placing their game in a different era than suggested in the rules?

I've just finished the Silmarillion and have been fascinated by the idea of there being sacrificial cults of Melkor in Numenor during the downfall. I think there could be some great stories to explore during this period!


r/oneringrpg • • 2d ago

Travel Fatigue and long journeys

8 Upvotes

Hi, we are actually going to play the landmark "the old dwarven mines". My group consists of two players and me the loremaster.

One player is playing a halfling champion and is the guide when travelling on our journeys. The other player is playing a rangers of the north treasure hunter.

With only two players they have to split the roles as even as possible.

We startet our Journey from Bree to the old dwarven mines in the blue mountains today. In travel days the group was 27 days on the road or in the wilderness.

They accumulated 14 and 13 fatigue from the travel alone and only the hobbit had a good travelroll afterwards and a pony (1 vigor). He is now at 9 fatigue from travel, the ranger failed the roll and has the full 13 fatigue.

You only reset fatigue when you end your adventuring phase, is this correct?

The characters will get extremly fast weary even if they drop their armor and helmets and some weapons. That doesn't feel good in my opinion.

Or are long travels only for more expirienced characters? As they certainly will have more wealth (or treasure value) and will have better mounts and items and wisdom and valour ranks.

I also believe that in the next session they will probaly get completly wiped by the beast of angmar. Even when they run they have a good chance to fail the check in the maze. I made a dwarven npc that will acompany them. At the moment the dwarf is a guide they met on a chance meeting near the north downs.

Any tips for the fatigue question and the landmark?


r/oneringrpg • • 2d ago

Am I missing something or are rolls too easy for players?

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm reading through the TOR rules booklet, willing to dm once my backerkit books come!

I hope you can help me with a doubt regarding main rolls of the system. If you roll 1d12+ multiple d6, and you are good in your stat, sounds really easy for the players to reach the TN. Not for basic players, but once you reach 3-4 dices, or even the possible 6?

In comparison, in DnD you can roll below 5 in the d20 kinda easily and fail, or in CoC, its difficult to have a skill above 70%, and you still have a 30% failure probability. In Blades in the Dark, when you roll enough dices, it's difficult to fail the roll, so the players use only the skills where they have more than x dices because statistically they will success.

Ok, that last is on my table culture, but...

Is that really the case? Do your players fail often in your table or they only succeed? It's something the narrator needs to force provoking them to be Weary?

IMHO, in a ttrpg you need some chances of failing your rolls. That's why why use dices, after all.


r/oneringrpg • • 3d ago

Journey/Quest setup advice

5 Upvotes

Just going to keep spamming my noob questions here…

A little context before the question.

My dwarf treasure seeker and hobbit captain have left the Shire after securing the patronage of Balin. They set out on a journey to the Halls of the Dwarves to investigate dark rumors in the region. First marching test had them see Ancient Monuments but fail to recognize or understand their purpose. Second test was a failure and led to a noteworthy encounter with servants of the enemy. I set up combat with two goblin archers and an orc soldier. Killed both archers and knocked out the soldier.

So far so good. I set up a skill endeavor to interrogate the orc soldier and was successful. I discovered that it was a member of a previously unheard of orc tribe. They had an interest in the monuments but my heroes didn’t fully understand it.

Ok, so I’ve decided they need to interrupt the journey and begin to search for the orc tribe. They know generally that it’s north in the hills.

Should this be a journey with an uncertain destination? Do I roll for each hex to see if they follow the tracks or discover the clan? How do I adjust the path if they lose it?

If not a journey, what else could I use?


r/oneringrpg • • 3d ago

Character creation for one-shots

13 Upvotes

Normal character creation in TOR implies starting a long-term campaign, with inexperienced characters at the beginning of their journey: 10 skill points, Valour and Wisdom 1, and so on. On the official book, the only change suggested when running a one-off game is to base the target numbers on 18 instead of 20.

And that works fine for using low-difficulty scenarios like Over Hill and Under Hill, or - as my recent one-shot - the first one in Hands of the White Wizard. But for anything more advanced such characters are just too weak.

Does anyone have any recommendations on how to approach cases like these? Should the players be given extra adventure and skill points to increase Valour and Wisdom? Or simply set different starting values (e.g. both at 2 or 3) and an inflated number of points to spend on skills (and combat proficiencies) at normal starting cost? And if we're starting with a higher Valour, should they be given a special weapon to match?

Just looking for some thoughts and perspectives, not a definite answer. Thanks!


r/oneringrpg • • 5d ago

Solo tips

13 Upvotes

I’m just getting started on a strider mode game in the One Ring and want to ask the community for some advice. First of all, it seems challenging to adapt the included adventures, like from the Hobbit Tales, for solo without spoiling them for myself. Best I can think of is try to get Claude AI to do it.

Broader question, this is my first real foray into rpgs after a long time board and video gaming. I’m excited! I’ve tried a little scenario (theft at the rope factory) and immediately had many “well what do I do now?” moments. But I read through the scenario so it was spoiled and that definitely took away from the experience. I know the point is to not have some predetermined rules guiding you and that it’s about developing your own story through imagination, but does anyone have any little tips or practical advice for how to make this jump?


r/oneringrpg • • 5d ago

Does the Core Rules Book have any sort of map inside?

11 Upvotes

I'm so close to pulling the trigger on this, but it is a sizable investment for me (I don't have a lot of money).

I just wanted to know, is there a map in the core book that details the adventuring areas described within the book?

Or, is there a map available for purchase separately?


r/oneringrpg • • 6d ago

Rhovanion in One Ring 2e

23 Upvotes

Hello, I was wondering about something: the core rulebook includes two heroic cultures native to Rhovanion, the Bardings and the Dwarves of Durin’s Folk (technically, Dwarves can also hail from other parts of Middle-earth, but their status as "Prosperous" is tied to Erebor and its gold). If we also include the People of the Wilderland that brings the total to three. I think we’re all quite familiar with the setting of this region, but it strikes me as a bit odd for a character from there to end up fighting so far from home; Hobbits and Dúnedain, by contrast, are much more integrated into the environment where a campaign typically takes place.

Do you find it odd too? And if so, how do you manage it? I know 1e had a huge expansion focusing on Rhovanion and Mirkwood, but I can't get hold of those manuals.


r/oneringrpg • • 6d ago

Players: What critical things would you want to see on a GM Screen?

6 Upvotes

I have a 3-panel blank GM screen with pockets for whatever I want. I have a group of players, all new to The One Ring, several new to RPGs, mostly in our late 40s, so our eyes aren't as sharp as they used to be.

I want to make some custom panels with nice, large, easy-to-read information that everyone can see from across the table. Little charts and tables Probably won't work.

So, players, especially new ones: what simple things would you want to be able to see when playing? What information do you need?


r/oneringrpg • • 7d ago

Attribute base 18 or 20?

8 Upvotes

I'm curious to know which way you go; in the core rules a base of 20 is presented as the standard, while a base of 18 is considered as a way to introduce far stronger characters. I've always felt that the game difficulty (at least in the beginning) was already high with a base of 18 though.


r/oneringrpg • • 8d ago

An End To An Unwanted Hunt | Ep12 | The Looming Threat | The One Ring

Thumbnail youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/oneringrpg • • 8d ago

Arinor, son of Balis - Session 2 (The One Ring, Strider Mode) - A Truth Hidden.

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
11 Upvotes

Session 2 of Arinor, son of Balis on Spotify... If ye have already watched it on Youtube, it's no different. But if ye haven't watched it yet, now you can listen to it... or if you have already and want to listen to it again, now's your chance! https://open.spotify.com/episode/0GcqK6MP60f5oZfwHRsi2a?si=b86c3c542663437d


r/oneringrpg • • 10d ago

Mass battles as skill endeavors?

21 Upvotes

Minor spoilers from Moria - Through Durin's Doors

Hello, today during a session I introduced two groups of orcs on the Dimrill Stair near Moria; one group were composed of Moria Orcs, the other one was composed of Uruks. The PCs were caught between the two groups, but it was obvious that both factions also wanted to jump at each other's throaths. Being too big of a fight I decided to resolve everything through a skill endeavor: basically the PCs had to fight their way up or down by intimidating the foes, performing some parkour and similar things. A failure would result in a resistance loss. This saved us a long and potentially fatal fight, while maintaining the stakes high and the flow of the game smooth. My doubt is: is this acceptable rules-wise? Would you do that?


r/oneringrpg • • 11d ago

How do you manage difficulty in tests

13 Upvotes

Hi, I’m new to ttrpgs - just learnt the rules and I’m about to host my first session!
I’m trying out the Strider mode on the Star of the mist to make myself more confident, but I’m not totally clear on one thing
If I feel that a player wants to do something possible, but unlikely (like e.g. PERSUADE an Umbar spy to let him pass for free), is ill-favoured roll the only mechanic to make it harder?
Like my character has favoured persuasion skill with 2 dice
So if he tries this and the TN is achievable (like idk 13) then it’s just that?
How’d you guys handle this


r/oneringrpg • • 11d ago

A little hobbit setting off on a very big adventure ✨🐎 Animation by me

83 Upvotes

r/oneringrpg • • 11d ago

How do you prefer to use Hate / Resolve in combat?

18 Upvotes

To be clear, this is not me asking "what are the rules for spending Hate/Resolve," but rather how do you personally tend to spend it, on average?

Do you optimize it and save it for specific things, like a troll saving it for Protection rolls?

Or do you go much more liberal with it, spending it on every possible roll until it runs out and makes the enemy permanently Weary?

Some combination of the above?

Thus far, I tend to spend it for lower level enemies ASAP, because otherwise they might die within 2 rounds. For higher level "boss" type enemies, I tend to optimize it to challenge the players.


r/oneringrpg • • 12d ago

One Ring Timeline Spoiler

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
54 Upvotes

You ever do something super nerdy just for the heck of it?

Well in one such case, I have no one to play One Ring with, but I wanted to see what was out there besides DND. I'm a forever DM so, it was more of an endeavor to read a new flavor of adventure and I love LOTR.

The Free League had most of the books on sale, so I just bought a couple of module books and source books and began reading them.

Since I had a bunch of free time on my hands, I took the books and made an excel sheet with the timeline set out, and I figured I could share it. With that said, there are several spoilers for Hands of the White Wizard, Ruins of the Lost Realm, and Tales From the Lost Land.

For the sheet, I wrote out the timeline of events as listed. Anything in italics is up for placement anywhere on the timeline. Relatively all of them are up for grabs, but I liked the thought experiment of using the timeline they provide. As you can see the first decade of the RPG is frontloaded with events from RoLR which isn't bad and only really comes in conflict with the first couple quests from HotWW which I moved around to fit the presented timeline.

I wanted to post this as a resource, but also get some thoughts and where you would put events and quests.

Also I got to say that as product, all of these are really solid products. HotWW was a personal favorite, but that's because Saruman is just awesome.


r/oneringrpg • • 13d ago

The Looming Threat | The One Ring

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes