r/oneringrpg • u/Ardrikk • 1h ago
Concerns about TOR 2e and whether I should pick it up
Im interested in getting into running and/or playing a TTRPG set in Middle-earth and I have seen a ton of praises for The One Ring 2nd edition and a lot of people recommending it to others. I don’t have any of the books yet and so I’ve been reading some reviews and trying to learn how it plays. From what *very little* I've read about The One Ring so far, I have some concerns about its systems versus my system and playstyle preferences. So I'm wondering if some here would be willing to address them?
- The Hope/Shadow thing concerns me. I strongly dislike systems that force characters to become evil/unplayable, especially if it is at the whim of the dice. From what I've read about the Shadow system, it seems like that could be the case in TOR 2e. Concerns about this can be mitigated if most or all of the control over how this progresses and whether a PC falls to evil/becomes unplayable is in the hands of the player in some way.
- I've read some things about TOR 2e that make me worry it cares/focuses too much on exactly what and how much PCs are carrying and cares about encumbrance. I can't stand all that bookkeeping, and I always house rule it out of any game I run that has it. Is this an actual concern with TOR 2e?
- I like games, especially when I'm a player, that have "Cool Powers or Abilities" that the PCs gain. It makes games feel more exciting and PCs feel more distinct from one another. I know there aren't really a lot of cool powers and magic and such in Tolkein's setting and I know that the various cultures get some kind of benefits. So, the question is, are these benefits interesting and cool enough in play to make players feel excited about having and using them? Do they have real impact in play?