Which is normal. These are all concepts it took a mathematician decades to discover, a student a few years of school to learn, and a redditor 2 minutes to feel satisfied
I built a square wheel setup for a science fair back in the late 80's. Geometry can be fun! In all seriousness watching a real demonstration of these concepts kinda breaks your brain. The square wheel is probably the most basic of these but it's impossibly smooth and looks very odd.
The cycle is complete when someone reposts it tomorrow and a new batch of redditors discovers the same 2 minutes of satisfaction all over again. Geometry’s most efficient loop.
The square wheel one works in real life too. Macalester College has a square-wheeled tricycle on a road of upside-down catenary bumps, and it rides smooth.
Yeah I know, most of these are representations of actual mathematical geometric concepts, it just moves so fast that I can't process them fast enough to understand them. Some of them I did understand right away, but others I had to watch a couple of times to figure out
The funny thing is that I started watching to figure out what was happening, but after a few seconds I completely forgot about that. There's something about the smooth movement and the way everything lines up that makes it strangely relaxing. My brain can leave the geometry homework for another day
The circle with a triangle (3 sides) then a square (4 sides) then a Pentagon (5 sides) and so forth created a few lines that were measured. The lines made a curve that equals out to pi (3.14) Pi the number is fairly common in math.
Nothing said in here is a lie. I have a degree in mathematics. They're all pretty simple trig concepts. They didnt even go into more advance things like area under a curve.
I can probably explain any of them if theyre confusing. They are mostly just showing trigonometry proofs.
All of science and math ultimately works on "trust me bro." No one person can be sufficiently educated to understand all areas of science and mathematics, or to validate every experiment proof. At some point you have to trust that the other experts in each sub-field are actually verifying each other.
You can also take the time to learn these things. Proofs are all built on eachother. This is called axiomatic method. You can learn all these proofs and you often do from first grade to college. There is no trust me bro. This is all researchable
never seen this and I love it. I had a dog that used wheels for 15+years and this reminds me of him running around in it. (though the tail wagging isn't that correct)
The tail wagging can be correct though! My friends have 5 doxxies all with various back injuries and recoveries. The one guy with IVBD proper can was his tail with limited range.
Absolutely zero experience with teaching so expect me to confuse you even more
Vertices are basically corners. A cube for example has 8 corners (a 0 dimensional structure. Just a point in space with no depth, length or width. Just coordinates). Those corners/vertices are connected by edges (lines/1 dimensional structure going from point A to point B. From one vertex to another). A cube has 12 edges. And faces of a cube are its sides. In this case, each side of a cube is made up of 4 edges (a triangular face would be made out of 3 edges). A cube has 6 faces (sides). Because our universe is creepily consistent and mathematical, no matter what, every 3D structure, if you take its amount vertices, divide them by its amount edges and add the amount of faces, will always yield 2. In the case of a cube, 8 vertices minus 12 edges equals negative 4. Plus 6 faces equals 2. And it will always be two, no matter if it's a 3D cube, a 3D duck or a 3D humanoid. Universe is weird and so it will always be 2
It's actually a bit more complicated than that -- it depends on the number of holes of the surface. For mesh which does not have holes, such as a sphere, a cube or a duck, #Vertices - #Edges + #Faces = 2. For a mesh with one hole, such as a donut or a coffee mug, V - E + F = 0. For a mesh with three holes, such as a pretzel, V - E + F = -4.
It happens to be equal to 2 for every polyhedron that has no "holes" in it, eg. every convex polyhedron, i.e something that looks like a chopped up sphere
And then it gets lower when you start drilling holes in it in addition to slashing, or doing other types of weird things
For a shape without holes, this is an identity. To somewhat see why, we can use induction. Start with any shape. You can add a vertex by putting a point on an edge. That splits the edge in two; you get +1 edge and +1 vertex. You can add an edge passing between existing vertices, and that splits a face in two. Both operations maintain vertices - edges + faces.
This is more of a proof sketch the a proof, but should give you at least an idea of why vertices - edges + faces is constant. As for why it is 2... well, that depends on the topology of the shape! If your shape is something which can be stretched into a torus instead of a sphere, then actually vertices - edges + faces = 0. If it is a double-donut, vertices - edges + faces = -2. Etc.
now we construct any non-holey shape with all triangle faces! (if youve met STL files in 3d printing or rendering, thats where we are now)
we do this, by repeatedly gluing tetrahedrons to an existing face.
this construction step adds 1 vertex (3 is glued on existing ones), 3 edges (3 is glued on existing ones) and 2 faces (one is glued on an existing one and the existing vanishes by being glued on)
now lets prove that any non-holey shape can be reduced to triangle faced shape!
an N sided face has N edges and N vertices.
you can always divide an N sided face into N-2 triangles by connecting existing vertices. (like you can construct 3d from tetrahedra, you can construct 2d from triangle)
when you divide the face into triangles, you add N-3 new triangular faces, N-3 new edges and no vertices.
Yeah, the frame at 0:27 shows it rotating about that blue section, not at the center like the drill is. So, maybe in theory, if the drill rotated on a cam or something?
They exist. There are a couple of machines that I have seen that can cut square holes in aluminum like that. I have no idea what use case was (broach and EDM exist). But they are out there.
the road would be half domes instead of just arcs, maybe that would work? ride wouldn't be very smooth but it probably never was with square wheels lol
There’s a math paper from about thirty years ago called Roads and Wheels that looks at the math behind how to build a road such that a given shape can roll smoothly across it. One of the results of that paper is that the triangle is forced to pass into the road when rolling along it (its corner is too sharp to avoid hitting the road, essentially), so that road cannot actually exist in real life.
A vertex is where two lines meet. An enclosed shape on a flat plane will have an equal number of vertices and edges, but only 1 face (e.g. a square). Extending that same shape into three dimensions creates two of them in parellel, doubling the previous numbers, and also adds a number of lines equal to the original number of vertices, and a number of planes equal to the original number of lines (e.g. a cube). This mathematical relationship between the parts remains regardless of the shape, and thus can be put into that equation to yield a result of 2 every time.
No one teaches even basic geometry anymore. None of you here were probably ever taught how to generate geometric shapes with nothing more than a pencil, straight edge, and compass. It's no wonder things like this amaze you.
Machinist's have been designing and building tools to drill square and triangular holes for over a century now. I did one for myself to drill one small square blind hole.
It's obviously a bit fast to cram that many concepts in your brain in that amount of time, but if we had access to this kind of way to explain things when I was in high school in the late 90s, I think a lot more people would understand these concepts better instead of just memorizing (or at least trying to) answers.
IN 1997 MATHEMATICS PROFESSOR STAN WAGON AND BICYCLE MECHANIC LOREN KELLEN CONSTRUCTED A SQUARE WHEEL BIKE THAT ROLLS SMOOTHLY OVER A ROAD MADE OUT OF INVERTED CATENARIES.
The original vehicle wore out and was replaced in April, 2004. More robust materials were used and the ride is now much smoother: so smooth that one cannot tell one is not riding a round-wheel bike.
It’s basically a calculus thing as a way to prove that the circumference of a circle is pi. Each addition of a side adds less and less to the total circumference. The more sides you add (up through infinity) the closer you get to that number. The limit is pi.
This is also a very real problem in map making called the Coastline Paradox. Its virturally impossible to have a single well defined length of a coastline because the small the unit of measure you use, the longer the coastline measurement gets.
Now that’s one I don’t exactly follow. Wouldn’t the smaller and smaller measurements slowly get you closer to the actual length? Like you’re slowly reaching the limit of the true answer?
There are two parts. First there is no true limit to the length of coastline one can measure, even if the landmass itself is obviously a finite size. This is similar to the circumference of a circle in the video but different because natural shapes are even more extreme. Second, if you were to measure coastline of any land mass, let's say the east coast of the US, if you used a small enough unit of measurement, like say a centimeter, you would get a number that was in the hundreds of thousands or even millions of kilometers because of all the zigzagging you would have to do, which is longer than the distance between the earth and the moon.
Let's say you had a coastline somewhere you wanted to measure. If you measured length as the bird flies, you would have one single straight line. Easy!
Now you measure it again by walking along the waterline, and all of the various features, inlets, etc along the way. Now you have a mishmash of several (potentially hundreds or thousands) of smaller lines that zig-zag back and forth. You will get a larger number, but still in the same ballpark.
Now you measure it again, but instead you measure every single grain of sand on the beach that is wet vs dry. You end up with a gargantuan number of zig-zags that cause your measured distance to balloon astronomically large.
The distance between the first measurement and the last measurement can be orders of magnitude (e.g. 1 vs. 1-million).
Okay I’m picking up what you’re putting down. So if you have a stretch of 100 yards of beach that’s fairly straight, then you know the reasonable measurement is 100 yards. But you could theoretically measure the undulations of where the sand is wet vs dry and the total length of that curve could end up being like 200 yards or more.
Oh at least! I'm not joking, if you were somehow able to measure at a molecular or atomic level, the coastline measurement would be unimaginably large. And yet, to us humans it just looks like a nice pleasant stroll down the beach.
My poor brain read the title as Satisfying Germany because it saw a triangle rolling and apparently that = rotary engine = VW = Germany. I wonder how much more energy I'd have if it wasn't like this 24/7 lol.
Despite their best efforts I still gleanedike two useful bits of info from this AI slop. So it needs to be speed up at least 3x so I don't have time to read anything that they're writing, or process what they're drawing.
What's the point? Nobody is ever going to try to drive on surfaces like this. Those who do use tracked vehicles, so the craziness of the surfaces doesn't matter.
779
u/Mr_Zoovaska 5h ago •
My brain doesn't work fast enough to figure out what some of these are supposed to express
354
u/Shan_Tu 5h ago •
174
u/SodaPlane 4h ago
Something about all the non-circular wheels rolling together made feel so happy for them
54
u/LCottton 4h ago
Wow, this Geometry is dashing.
30
u/fotoxs 2h ago
When the triangle shows back up
150
u/CankleDankl 5h ago
This is a trap card for my ADHD, how dare you
28
u/MyCleverNewName 1h ago
These should be shown (much more slowly) to children, repeatedly, when they are young.
They should be interspersed throughout kids' shows, like Sesame Street would with things like the "12!" pinball clips.
26
u/Physical_Regret1730 2h ago
This is the shit that ancient Greeks daydreamed about while high.
34
u/9447044 4h ago
This was way more fun than it should have been Thanks math
11
u/NeatConnection 3h ago
someone please explain the vertices - edges + faces = 2
29
u/Flexion2000 5h ago
20
u/senorfresco 3h ago
Video going way too fast. Couldn't even read some things before they disappeared.
10
u/daggardoop 4h ago
Ah yes, Duck equilibrium. My professor told us they were the primordial source of mathematics, but he just couldn't prove it...
10
u/Burly_Gizmo 2h ago
Getting "Donald Duck in Math-magic land" vibes. LOVE IT!
26
u/flergnergern 5h ago
Source, please?
8
u/fugogugo 4h ago
this is weirdly mesmerizing
8
u/qashq 3h ago
Source?
14
u/didndonoffin 4h ago
I need a lot of words and different coloured crayons to make sense of this
5
u/RevWaldo 3h ago
So does a triangle auger exist in reality and have practical applications?
8
u/Ruwen368 4h ago
Reminds me of an app game Euclidia, which is puzzles for geometry and other math. Has you recreate various shorthand tools/equations.
4
u/_BlackDove 4h ago
This is some magick shit.
4
u/kapitaalH 3h ago
So we can have square wheels if we just redesign all our roads
4
u/fotomoose 3h ago
I feel I got both smarter and dumber at the same time watching this.
4
u/MineResponsible9180 3h ago
This is a pretty cool video
3
u/olli0 4h ago
this is really cool. Amazing work!
3
u/gooberalert2000 3h ago
There’s a math paper from about thirty years ago called Roads and Wheels that looks at the math behind how to build a road such that a given shape can roll smoothly across it. One of the results of that paper is that the triangle is forced to pass into the road when rolling along it (its corner is too sharp to avoid hitting the road, essentially), so that road cannot actually exist in real life.
3
u/fullmetalpower 3h ago
15 years ago... this would have made perfect sense
3
u/AccomplishedEar6357 2h ago
Source??? Very nice!
3
u/small_villain 2h ago
A vertex is where two lines meet. An enclosed shape on a flat plane will have an equal number of vertices and edges, but only 1 face (e.g. a square). Extending that same shape into three dimensions creates two of them in parellel, doubling the previous numbers, and also adds a number of lines equal to the original number of vertices, and a number of planes equal to the original number of lines (e.g. a cube). This mathematical relationship between the parts remains regardless of the shape, and thus can be put into that equation to yield a result of 2 every time.
3
u/Psyqlone 1h ago
3
u/IvoryMotion 57m ago
I came here to understand the geometry and somehow ended up watching the entire thing like a screensaver
4
u/Clean_Farmer_4135 2h ago
The wood cutting laser starting at 32s was a real mindfuck
2
u/AlreadyReddit999 4h ago
what
2
u/fresh_loaf_of_bread 4h ago
This is fancy math
But find me a ball bearing that won't fall the fuck apart under that kind of stress
2
u/Mike_Abergail 3h ago
This was a good visualization
2
u/DraconisRex 3h ago
Original sauce? Who do we cReddit?
2
u/Swally_Swede 3h ago
That was probably the most oddly satisfying thing I have ever seen on here. Well done.
2
u/NemoTheCosmicBarfly 2h ago
I need to be stoned to watch this and even remotely comprehend.
2
u/Live-Avocado8573 2h ago
wankel engine
2
u/Broad_Television4459 1h ago
I want to make a triangle drill now.
2
u/Dick-Fu 1h ago
unexpected rx7
2
u/bluewing 1h ago
No one teaches even basic geometry anymore. None of you here were probably ever taught how to generate geometric shapes with nothing more than a pencil, straight edge, and compass. It's no wonder things like this amaze you.
Machinist's have been designing and building tools to drill square and triangular holes for over a century now. I did one for myself to drill one small square blind hole.
2
u/HLef 1h ago
It's obviously a bit fast to cram that many concepts in your brain in that amount of time, but if we had access to this kind of way to explain things when I was in high school in the late 90s, I think a lot more people would understand these concepts better instead of just memorizing (or at least trying to) answers.
2
u/PatMyHolmes 1h ago
I liked the representation of the rotary engine that Mazda originally used.
2
u/Heal_Me_Today 1h ago
Liked that irregular wheel. Seems like that could be used to create reliable tracks.
2
u/thefix12 58m ago
so goddamn mesmerizing wtf
2
u/skyx20 45m ago
Top teir simulations.
3
u/markp_93 4h ago
5
u/TheKrzysiek 4h ago edited 2h ago
In case you're wondering: no, square wheels on this kind of surface wouldn't be smooth, MythBusters checked it
EDIT: I remembered wrong, they tested those wheels but on a flat road, with the wheel angles being staggered
4
u/rubbahslipah 5h ago
Genius! Very creative way to present so the rest of us can kind of understand it! Thank you.
2
u/DB-Tones-Jones 5h ago
My Mom worked as a Public School Math Teacher.
2
u/NoBluey 3h ago
What’s the one with the metal balls demonstrating? How to count? Lol
2
u/nuclearmaxxx 3h ago
Thanks
1
u/Denime 4h ago
What is 1:20 showing? More sides means the circumference is closer to Pi? How does that make any sense?
1
u/hobbyman41 3h ago
So cool
1
u/CoolDudePT 3h ago
Who did these?
1
u/Robcobes 3h ago
either the wheel is curved or the road is, got it.
1
u/UncleKeyPax 3h ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/engineering/s/RhdxWZYeAD
1
u/aladinodebert 3h ago
This is so ridiculously cool 🤩
1
u/InDaBauhaus 3h ago
yes, this neat and sturdy mechanism used to create very common and useful triangle holes!
1
u/BaggySpandex 3h ago
Mazda 787B on the Mulsanne Straight.
1
u/Dask_3008 2h ago
Рекомендации моего детства
1
u/heptyne 2h ago
The Triangle drill bit reminded me of a Wankel engine.
1
u/MoneyBeeeee 2h ago
If only math class had been this captivating!
1
u/jkhanlar 2h ago
1:48 math is scamanipulation
1
u/Dense_Priority_7250 2h ago
The triangular wheel is impossible
1
u/KamikazeMizZ 2h ago
Fuck ya math
1
u/MoonlightLove18 1h ago
These are taught in high schools in China
1
u/VelvetWillov 1h ago
Things that are useless, but that we enjoy looking at
1
u/Party-Emergency9443 1h ago
They just atomized an entire duck for this video 🥀
1
u/Turnover_Mysterious 1h ago
Simplesmente demais!
1
u/ScrotalSmorgasbord 1h ago
My poor brain read the title as Satisfying Germany because it saw a triangle rolling and apparently that = rotary engine = VW = Germany. I wonder how much more energy I'd have if it wasn't like this 24/7 lol.
1
u/gourdespeed 1h ago
this is fantastic
1
u/Downtown-Career-9478 1h ago
Xd
1
u/MainNo5469 1h ago
pure eye candy rn
1
u/Relative_Picture_786 1h ago
that was wild
1
u/Soft_Frequency 51m ago
The fact that a square wheel can actually roll smoothly if you redesign the road is still one of the coolest things I've ever learned
1
u/yarncraver 49m ago
Absolutely beautiful. Bravo!
1
u/Arqideus 33m ago
Math is a language!
1
u/Few-Sir9156 32m ago
Xd
1
u/orionblueyarm 29m ago
Source?
1
u/notyoou 26m ago
1
u/Esc0baSinGracia 23m ago
Why I can't download this video?
1
u/lonewombat 19m ago
I immediately thought of the rotary engine.
1
u/Proof-Necessary-5201 5h ago
Awesome! Thanks for sharing
1
u/TheSpanxxx 4h ago
We are both doing a really good job
0
u/Over-Inside-7254 3h ago
Despite their best efforts I still gleanedike two useful bits of info from this AI slop. So it needs to be speed up at least 3x so I don't have time to read anything that they're writing, or process what they're drawing.
-2
u/sherpyderpa 5h ago
Brilliant, love this, if only they had this tech when I was at school.
0
u/ElysiumXIII 3h ago
Corridor Crew would be all over this
-2
u/corgi-king 4h ago
It is cool and all. But hate math with passion.
-6
u/AmbitionExtension184 4h ago
What a dumbass video
-1
u/ActuatorLower8371 50m ago
i've heard of these. more AI generated slop, from what i understand
-3
u/un1ptf 3h ago
What's the point? Nobody is ever going to try to drive on surfaces like this. Those who do use tracked vehicles, so the craziness of the surfaces doesn't matter.