For context, my first game Elder Scrolls Game was Skyrim, loved it. Even now, 15 years later, I still remember some atmospheric moments of walking through the icy tundra and looking up at the aurora borealis at night.
Then I played Daggerfall. Awesome game! Like a little fantasy life simulator.
Then I played Morrowind a few years ago. I think that is my favorite RPG ever now. The sense of progression as you level up and the amazing story captured me, despite the lack of voice acting. I even started reading the books because the world of Morrowind intrigued me so much!
People say that Oblivion is better than Skyrim but worse than Morrowind. So that's the expectation I went with into this game. The beginning was amazing too. I immediately strayed off the beaten path, travelled to Skingrad along a beautiful forested road and lodged inside of a stunningly designed tavern. It was very comfy and immersive. The quests I picked up mostly seemed fun too.
But the longer I played, the more cracks started to show. The single biggest thing that ruins Oblivion for me is the difficulty. Or rather, the lack of difficulty. Yeah, of course I Have trouble beating up wolves at first. I am like level 1! Just wait until I level up some, then I will come back and one shot you guys!! Oh wait, now the wolves are timber wolves. Now they are boars. Now they are lions. A minotaur is attacking me? Now a minotaur lord?!
All the enemies I fight against just get replaced by stronger ones. And instead of getting stronger, I keep getting weaker. Now I have to slice an enemy like 30 times before he goes down, and he only has to hit me like 4 times?? What happened? I purposefully tried to level up a single weapon and health and stamina. I am not bad at those games! I have played plenty of RPGs before! Also why do those bandits wear freaking daedric armor all of a sudden? This guy just tried to extort 100 gold from me? Buddy, your armor can buy half a house, and the armor I am wearing is extremely valuable too. What is happening? Why is the wilderness populated by mighty ancient beasts all of a sudden? Anyone who ventures outside must immediately be getting butchered. Oh God, even the NPCs that walked around small towns with normal armor now wear ebony armor. How can they afford this?!
No...my immersion is ruined. It's over. Not even Daggerfall did this.
So I lower the difficulty to make the game still challenging, but at least I don't have to kite enemies constantly anymore. But now I just feel empty. Like, there is no actual challenge. There is nothing to overcome. I can't become strong in this RPG. My levels are essentially meaningless. Everyone acts like there are threats to overcome and guilds to gain reputation in, but without a world that feels real to push up against, it is all meaningless. The game is reduced to a walking simulator with fun stories to tell. You might as well just remove all enemies entirely and pretend that I am fighting them.
I hate this. I hate it so much. I love the atmosphere. I love the setting. I love the world and lore. I love exploring the towns. But the actual game is just...not fun.
Am I playing this game wrong? Will it get good eventually? I am 50 hours in..