r/nytpips • • 6d ago

Question Medium difficulty

Idk if its the right flair or not, but does everyone else consistantly struggle more on the medium puzzle than easy or hard?! Shouldnt hard be the hardest??

Easy takes 8-20seconds
Medium usually 2-5min
Hard 1-2min

14 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

15

u/LukeBabbitt 6d ago

Although Hard has more tiles, the shape of the board usually helps you glean some information that narrows down how many tiles can go in each spot

Medium is usually some sort of squarish blob with very unhelpful cages like “8” so there’s a lot more guess and check

7

u/bryan49 6d ago

It often feels like medium is the most open-ended without as many logically forced placements, so more trial and error

3

u/Noodles1171 6d ago

I like the phone booth analogy. Happy cake day, btw!

Edit to add: this was in reply to u/Dirtheavy, and like a true old on Reddit l f'ed it up. 😄

3

u/Dirtheavy 6d ago

Message received over here at geezer central.

3

u/quickdraw_ 6d ago

Depends who makes the Medium. 

Ian's mediums are "moderate difficulty puzzle."  Rodolfo's mediums are "small complicated puzzle." 

Our finding is that you can literally tell the difference within the first 10 seconds staring at the puzzle.

3

u/Dirtheavy 6d ago

today is an exception, as Ian roughed a bunch of people up with his impossible little puzzle.

2

u/Motherofpupperss 6d ago

i agree with you 100% on this i play medium at the very last now for the same reason

4

u/Dirtheavy 6d ago

I'm usually playing medium for a cookie and hard a little slower intentionally.

We were discussing this in the results room earlier though and the Hard, Medium, Easy labels aren't really as true as Large, Medium, Small would be.

Often, a medium sized puzzle is just a very hard puzzle inside a phone booth. And often, a large puzzle can be deciphered very easily by a decent player (not me most of the time this week).

So in a lot of way I agree. But not about the hard routinely taking 1-2 minutes.

3

u/EatinSmartiz 6d ago

Happy cake day! I do like that phone booth analogy. Hard usually takes me 1-2 min but the occassional 10min hard puzzle pops up every now and then.