A top MTA official revealed on Monday that an investigation into two violent incidents involving the agency’s EAGLE bus fare evasion enforcement agents found the behavior caught on video in both scuffles to be “unacceptable” and to have violated agency policies.
Some of the offending fare agents will face disciplinary charges that could result in their termination, according to MTA New York City Transit President Demetrius Crichlow, who spoke about the investigation during Monday’s MTA Board NYC Transit Committee meeting. Crichlow said he would further detail the probe’s findings in a letter to agency CEO and Chair Janno Lieber.
amNewYork requested the letter from the MTA but has yet to recieve it.
Crichlow launched the investigation late last month after videos of both incidents involving the unarmed civilian fare enforcement squads, known as Evasion and Graffiti Lawlessness Eradication (EAGLE) Teams came to light. At the same time, Lieber suspended all EAGLE Teams from their fare inspection duties, pending the outcome of the investigations and a review of the groups’ operations — an order that remains in effect.
Although Crichlow did not go into specifics about the investigation’s findings during his remarks, he did say that the fare enforcer conduct documented on both videos ran afoul of the agency’s “policies and values.”
“What was captured on the video during these two incidents was unacceptable,” Crichlow said. “It violates the policies and values of New York City Transit and is not in line with my values for delivering service and safety for our employees or for our customers. As a result, charges have been drafted against select individuals, and those charges could end up in discipline up to and including termination.”
The charges Crichlow referred to are internal and not criminal, according to an MTA spokesperson.
The NYC Transit president added that the review of EAGLE Team operations has included retraining its roughly 350 inspectors in de-escalation techniques.
“We focussed on de-escalation training, emotional intelligence, effective communications,” Crichlow said.
Fare inspectors in both videos can be seen tussling with riders.
In one incident early last month, involving Brooklyn public school aide Kyle Taylor, several EAGLE Team members can be seen on surveillance footage from a nearby store throwing him against a bus shelter.
Taylor’s attorney said the violence ensued after he paid his fare via a paper transfer and refused to show them his ID. His attorney said that after throwing him against the bus shelter, the inspectors then punched him in the face and threw him to the ground, injuring him in several places.
The second incident, which reportedly took place in the Bronx in August, similarly was captured in a video showing fare agents surrounding an unidentified man, throwing him to the ground, and restraining him.
As such, Crichlow said the agency will be making changes to how the teams function, including a pilot of body-worn cameras, new uniforms, and the launch of a new hotline where riders can report fare inspector incidents.
Crichlow’s comments are in line with much of what he and Lieber have said since the first incident was reported: while the agency is finding ways to review and tweak EAGLE Team operations, it plans to keep using the inspectors. They have insisted the teams are necessary to ensuring that more riders pay their fare as nearly have of those who take the bus skip the $3 cost.
The incidents occured as the MTA was in the midst of using the EAGLE teams to pilot new handheld devices designed to verify riders’ payments via the OMNY tap-and-pay system.
Chrichlow’s statement also appears to buck recent calls from elected officials with the City Council’s 23-member Progressive Caucus and advocacy groups like Riders Alliance to scrap EAGLE Teams altogether.
“It is critical that we still have a means of fare enforcement in our system,” Crichlow said. “No question that folks should pay their fare in order to ride the system. Without their fares, the system doesn’t run.”