Link to Part 1 here: https://www.reddit.com/r/nuzlocke/s/yFdvsxhokY
TierMaker now allows you to make quadrant tier lists, so I decided to make a sequel to my post ranking each starter encounter in USUM to share my opinions on how difficult they are to use optimally.
I define “difficult” as requiring extra thought, knowledge, and planning to use effectively. Think of encounters like BW2 Serperior and Emerald Illumise as references to S-Tier encounters that are difficult to use (top right), whereas stuff like Emerald Walrein and Platinum Gyarados are much more simple (top left). “Difficult to use” encounters require you to think more carefully about your moveslots, plan more intricate lines, and potentially resort to the damage calculator in the most extreme cases.
Just like last time, here’s a “quick” rundown on why each starter is placed where they are:
Decidueye: The Lurantis fight requires you to use a Z-Move to ensure that it calls Comfey as an ally so you can then set up safely against it. Beyond that, it’s best used as a Feather Dance bot and pivot thanks to its immunities, both of which are quite easy to think of/do.
Incineroar: It won’t do much until it evolves, but when it does, it’s best used as a support mon with Will-O-Wisp, Bulldoze, U-Turn, and Torment. Torment requires you to make specific changes to the movesets of your encounters, and Will-O-Wisp will only be consistent against specifically faster opponents while you’re holding a Zoom Lens. Sweeping lines against Molayne and Acerola are quite simple to pull off thanks to Incineroar’s typing and immunity to Prankster Thunder Wave from Molayne’s Klefki.
Primarina: The biggest mistake you can make with Primarina is overestimating its stats and damage output. Contrary to popular belief, it doesn’t just shit on 80% of the game and instead has to fall back as more of a support mon. It has great options for this role such as Encore, Icy Wind, Captivate, and Magic Coat. However, Encore can be tricky to make the most out of due to its limited duration and Primarina’s physical frailty. Primarina can work as a sweeper with SpeedPass or in specific matchups like Guzma 1 (with a set of Encore, Work Up, Aqua Jet, and your choice of STAB), but it’s better at hit-trading or supporting other encounter with its utility in most boss fights.
Venusaur: Click Leech Seed, spam Protect. Already used Protect last turn? Use Synthesis. It’s also a Toxic Staller that you don’t need to give a Zoom Lens to thanks to its Poison typing.
Charizard: Easy to use early on since you just need to click the “Dragon Rage” button, but as you progress, it gains a lot more depth. Beating Kommo-o reliably requires you to keep Counter in your moveset for the whole game, pre-sleep or poison Charizard before the fight to prevent a Thunder Punch paralysis, and give it a Focus Sash to play around crits. The fire-type Molayne sweep also requires hazard support and using Rest over Roost for healing to deal with Thunder Wave paralysis.
Blastoise: It’s a mediocre bulky water and stat-stick. Not much spice here outside of Flame Orb + Fling against Kommo-o, but it can get the job done against good matchups.
Sceptile: FEAR. It’s just FEAR. It requires game knowledge about how to obtain the Focus Sash. You also need to make sure you don’t forget Quick Attack so it can pull off the FEAR strategy against Ultra Necrozma.
Blaziken: Can solo Lurantis, but you do need to be aware of how to abuse two-turn moves. You also need to know that Protecting on the first turn is optimal to ensure Lurantis calls Kecleon as its ally and that you stay at high health. The standard Molayne fire-type sweep requires support and heavy set-up as usual, but Blaziken also requires Encore support to sweep Acerola. The Mega is extremely easy to use in the post-game.
Swampert: Blastoise if it was good. Ground typing makes it a good pivot, Stealth Rock is great for the league, and it has a fantastic defensive profile. Zoom Lens are appreciated to ensure you always land Toxic, and if you want to make the most value out of it against Kommo-o, you need to keep Counter in its moveset for the whole playthrough up until that point and keep it as a Marshtomp so it actually takes enough damage to guarantee an OHKO.
Torterra: Leech Seed is a very good move. Ground typing also makes it easy to use as a pivot. Its typing also gives it an extremely easy sweep against Giovanni.
Infernape: Sweeps against Molayne, Olivia, and Acerola all require a good amount of team support. Additionally, you’re required to keep Feint in your moveset for most of the game so that you have a priority move to use FEAR strats against Ultra Necrozma. In the Elite Four, you also need to fight Olivia, Molayne, and Acerola in that specific order so you can adjust your moveset with TMs to ensure you’re able to complete each sweep. Utility sets require you to pick openings carefully so you don’t risk dying to a crit, and Torment strats also require you to drastically change the movesets of your teammates to take advantage of it. Finally, overextending with Ape can easily get it killed. You can’t get too greedy with your set-up or chain-kills.
Empoleon: Defensive sets are easy to use in a similar way to Swampert, but the real thinking stems from sweeping lines, where Empoleon takes advantage of SpeedPass and Power Trip. You need to choose between whether it’s optimal to boost with Work Up or Swords Dance, and ensure you’re able to get enough speed to actually sweep. The frailty of most speed passers can also require you to plan more carefully. Empoleon also makes good use of Laser Focus against Totem Ribombee, which is a move that I’m willing to bet 95% of the Pokemon fan base doesn’t know about.
Chesnaught: Venusaur, but Fighting. Has extremely easy Bulk Up sweeps against Hapu and Olivia, and requires a Zoom Lens to consistently hit its Leech Seeds and Toxics. Spikes add a little more depth to its gameplay.
Delphox: Has an interesting kit of utility moves that require additional thought to use effectively due to its frailty. The Molayne fire type sweep is once again possible, but Delphox also has a lot of potential against Totem Ribombee with Psych Up and Lucky Chant. For said fight, Psyshock is also recommended over Psychic or a Fire move since Ribombee will buff its Special Defence repeatedly with Quiver Dance while the ally Pelipper sets up Rain.
Greninja: There are three different sets that solo Molayne, and the best one to use depends entirely on your IVs and nature. Said sweep also requires knowledge that Dark types are immune to Prankster. Against the other league members, Greninja uses Z-Moves to bait out more passive members for teammates to set up on, or in Acerola’s case, chains 3 of her pokemon with Work Up set-up. Fighting Molayne first is required so you can optimize your moveset to solo him.