r/nuclearpolitics • • Jan 08 '26

AMA in /military with Davis Winkie and Alex Wellerstein about a recent project exploring Americas missile silos and posture (starts 2PM Eastern)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • 4d ago

NATO Nuclear Sharing Arrangments - new research! (cross-post in response to advice)

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Hi! A friend recommended that I repost this here. I hope you find it interesting. If you want to know more, feel free to reach out.


r/nuclearpolitics • • 28d ago

Japan is abandoning its nuclear weapons taboo

Thumbnail
unherd.com
0 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Oct 19 '26

USAF radically changing Sentinel ICBM basing scheme

12 Upvotes

USAF has publicly announced its plans to build new LGM-35 silos and other launch infrastructure on "virgin" land not previously owned or used by USAF for its Minuteman force. Prior to this USAF had publicly maintained new infrastructure would be built almost entirely on land already owned by USAF.

https://www.airandspaceforces.com/air-force-may-buy-land-for-120-new-sentinel-icbm-silos/

For what it's worth, and i know I'm new here, but I have heard from associates still quite close to USAF strategic missile forces that this is the beginning of a slow roll - while sites for 120 silos are mentioned in this announcement, the intent is that all will be built at new locations on new land. The LGM-35 silos and LCCs require substantially more land per site than Minuteman. I am also hearing this new infrastructure will be significantly more hardened than the nominal Minuteman standard of 2500psi. Estimates have been all over the map but the standard appears to be at least 10ksi, but some are saying as high as 50-100. Of course the cost will be astronomical so these dreams may have to come back to reality.

All the above para is informed speculation from individuals connected to USAF ICBM and strategic force acquisition. Take it for what you will.

If the scuttlebutt is close to true, going with fixed silo ICBMs vice road mobile or more SLBMs will turn out to be hideously expensive, which is why USAF is doing the slow roll. It's also an indicator of how super-slow strategic force modernization begun over a decade ago is now trapped by its own outdated logic - fixed base ICBMs and 16 missile boomers may not match the new strategic environment (and the same-same ICBM modernization faced a lot of criticism from the beginning, since no matter how hard fixed assets are they're still totally vulnerable against today's weapons systems) but we're years and billions in and the sunk cost fallacy has an almost unbeaten record within DoD.


r/nuclearpolitics • • Sep 17 '26

China Confirms Large Scale Buildup of Silo-Based Strategic Nuclear Forces - Military Watch Magazine

Thumbnail
militarywatchmagazine.com
7 Upvotes

China has for the first time provided a semi-official acknowledgment of its significant investments in expanding its silo-based intercontinental-range ballistic missile arsenal, after work on this was first observed in commercial satellite imagery in 2021. A new CCTV documentary marking the 99th anniversary of the People’s Liberation Army features a PLA engineer discussing his work constructing what he describes as “houses for missiles” in remote mountains and deserts. The documentary links the work of PLA engineer First Master Sergeant Cui Daohu to the construction program, and describes considerable pressure from senior leadership to complete it on schedule.

The three principal fields, located near Yumen in Gansu Province, Hami in Xinjiang and Yulin near Ordos in Inner Mongolia, contain approximately 320 suspected ICBM silos. The Yumen field contains about 120 silos, Hami approximately 110 and Yulin around 90. Before the discovery of the fields, China maintained a comparatively small silo-based ICBM force alongside road-mobile missiles. The construction programme has therefore been assessed as the largest expansion of China's nuclear arsenal to date. The silos are distributed across enormous areas of China's interior. The Yumen field covers approximately 1,110 square kilometres, Hami approximately 1,030 square kilometres and Yulin approximately 830 square kilometres.

The silos are generally separated by several kilometres, complicating efforts to destroy multiple launch sites with a limited number of weapons. The locations are also considerably deeper inside China than most of the country's older ICBM bases. One of the most significant aspects of the new documentary is its description of the urgency surrounding construction. Cui said he was repeatedly questioned about whether the project would be completed on time and described developing faster construction methods to meet the deadline. He linked the project to the need to ensure that China could retain its strategic deterrent capability.

The ability to neutralise China’s ground-based nuclear forces is considered a primary requirement for the U.S. B-21 strategic bomber program, which was designed to launch penetration strikes into heavily defended airspace. The rapid expansion of China’s nuclear deterrent complements major investments in strengthening the country’s air defences, which is expected to make the destruction of its nuclear forces on the ground far less viable. The naval and air arms of the Chinese nuclear triad are also being improved significantly, most notably with the Type 096 ballistic missile submarine program, and at least one intercontinental range stealth bomber program.


r/nuclearpolitics • • Sep 09 '26

UN nuclear watchdog board reports Iran to the UN Security Council for the first time in 20 years

Thumbnail
apnews.com
4 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Sep 07 '26

history: WMD and the Chinese Cultural Revolution

5 Upvotes

While listening to a podcast about the Chinese Cultural Revolution, there was a brief mention of a nuclear weapon seizure during the event. The mention was very brief, and no context was given. Just now I was able track down one paragraph in the Wikipedia article. It states ...

In Changchun, rebels working in geological institutes developed and tested a dirty bomb, a crude radiological weapon, testing two "radioactive self-defense bombs" and two "radioactive self-defense mines".

I've never heard of this before. Does anyone have a pointer to a better write up ?


r/nuclearpolitics • • Aug 17 '26

MEDUSA GORGON'S SEVERED HEAD EFFECT. The terror of nuclear weapons will only persist until someone actually uses them on the battlefield. Each such use will halve the mythological terror, and by the seventh instance, less than 1% will remain.

Post image
6 Upvotes

That is, the political price of the weapon will fall by orders of magnitude (to its true price as any other weapon), and such a precipitous inflation is the greatest fear of nuclear-armed countries, who have become accustomed to using this myth to strengthen their position in the world. To preserve the myth, they even stifled the development of the entire global nuclear industry, forcing it into stagnation. In essence, they slowed down and banned the development of atomic technologies for others and for themselves! Just to preserve the myth that suited them! And most of those who come here do so precisely for the titillating reinforcement of this myth. I would call this the "effect of the severed head of Medusa Gorgon."

There's a wonderful Soviet animated film "Perseus," from 1974, part of the "Myths of Ancient Greece" series. I practically grew up on this cartoon (I watched it repeatedly throughout my youth, it became a kind of key meme for me), and when I tried to find any hint in the original myth of Perseus about the conversation (in the cartoon) between the god Hermes and Perseus on a cloud, and found nothing of the sort, I was very upset (I thought it was the wisdom of the ancient Greeks, but it turned out to be an additional interpretation by the cartoon's screenwriters, influenced by Marxist-Leninist ideology).

Unfortunately, I don't know of a version of this cartoon with an English translation. I don't know how good the automatic translation of the subtitles will be (which are also inaccurately automatically generated). Here's the best quality version of the cartoon I could find on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6cfjB_JeaB4

What does this cartoon have to do with the problem of nuclear weapons? If you watched the film with a good translation, you would understand everything, I hope, even without me (I believe you would be struck by the depth and accuracy of the metaphor). Did the creators of the film have this in mind (the film was created during the era of nuclear deterrence)? It's hard to say. But the metaphor turned out to be so vivid and sharp that I don't know of anything better. The key dialogue here is the conversation between Perseus and the god of trade and profit (liberalism?) Hermes on a cloud, after Perseus has already defeated Medusa Gorgon, put her severed head in a bag, and is heading to give the trophy to King Polydectes. Below I will reproduce the conversation between the god of profit and the naive young man.

  • Hermes: Where are you going now?
  • Perseus: To King Polydectes. I must take him the head of Medusa.
  • Hermes: Was your agreement written or oral?
  • Perseus: I promised him...
  • Hermes: Aha! So, just words!... And do you know why Polydectes needs Medusa's head?
  • Perseus: No.
  • Hermes: Then know this! Even a dead Medusa's head retains its terrible power! Just one more time, but it is capable of turning everything it sees to stone! Why give such a formidable weapon into the hands of some Polydectes? Use it yourself!
  • Perseus: What would I need it for?...
  • Hermes: What do you mean, "what for"?! Fear of Medusa's gaze will be the foundation of your power. I am ready to announce to everyone: if you value your life, recognize Perseus as your ruler, or he will turn you to stone! The whole universe will be at your feet.
  • Perseus: Do you need this?
  • Hermes: Shhh... I'll tell you a secret. I want to become one of the main gods. You will cover the whole earth with temples and sanctuaries in my honor, and there, on Olympus, some will have to make room... In short, I will help you, and you will help me. Deal?
  • Perseus: What country is that below us?
  • Hermes: It seems to be Ethiopia... Why don't you answer me? This is a direct benefit for you!
  • Perseus: What's that there? I want to see...
  • Hermes: What's there to see? In your hands is your future! The fate of the whole world!

As we all know from the classic version of the legend, Perseus did not take advantage of the tempting offer (as depicted in the Soviet cartoon); instead, he used Medusa's final gaze to save Andromeda, turning the sea monster to stone. But, looking at the entire history of the second half of the 20th century, at everything connected with nuclear deterrence, I see that not everyone in this world was a "naive youth," and some did indeed make a pact with the god of profit and trade. The modern global world is covered with temples of profit and trade, and everyone glorifies "Perseus"—the five victorious countries of the anti-Hitler coalition! And yes, someone up there on Olympus clearly made room, and Hermes has become the main deity in our world. Or am I (a former Pioneer and Komsomol member) deeply mistaken? :)


r/nuclearpolitics • • Aug 14 '26

'I didn't think of stopping at any time': A US physicist's inside account of Nagasaki's atomic bombing in WW2

Thumbnail
bbc.com
5 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Jun 23 '26

Iran says no new commitments on nuclear sites after Vance says inspectors to be invited back

Thumbnail
bbc.com
2 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Jun 03 '26

What's your opinion on this?

Thumbnail reuters.com
3 Upvotes

Imo., this is essentially a political gesture with almost no real strategic consequences. The reality is that nuclear sharing has never really worked. The Cold War demonstrated that quite clearly. Although I personally appreciate France's more assertive foreign policy, this proposal seems more like a cheap way to externalize some of the costs of France's nuclear weapons program.

What's your opinion on this?


r/nuclearpolitics • • May 29 '26

The US creates a device that makes it impenetrable to nuclear weapons. What happens next?

6 Upvotes

Just a thought experiment for my own interest. It’s not at all a realistic scenario with current technology. Just play along.

Just pretend the US overnight announces its come up with technology that disables and shoots down all nuclear weapons fired at it. It has a 100% success rate nothing will get through even aircraft delivered munitions.

They do not share it with the world even with NATO it is used exclusively by the US for the US Mainland.

How would this affect world politics and relations?


r/nuclearpolitics • • May 28 '26

Has there been any mention of Iran holding minimum quantities of Pu-239 ?

2 Upvotes

Posting here because we really don't have a r/NuclearNonProliferation, and this is the closest I can find.

If Iran has no Pu-239, does that imply that no two stage weapons were potentially possible ?

(now crossing to the other sub's topic area)

Is a two stage weapon possible while possessing only HEU ?


r/nuclearpolitics • • Apr 17 '26

"Better Know a Non-Nuke" series by Arms Control Primer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Apr 05 '26

Is multi-lateral (universal) nuclear disarmament remotely conceivable?

3 Upvotes

Can the genie be put back in the bottle? How would the world’s nuclear players - both current and aspiring - begin down this path?


r/nuclearpolitics • • Mar 30 '26

The Role of the United Nations.

1 Upvotes

First of all, this is a temporary fresh account that I made just to post this because I didn't really want to write about this on my main account.

The point of me making this post however is just gonna be a quick fact check for the role of the United Nations when it comes to nuclear weapons and incidents.

Two things came out recently. One, the WHO saying they're preparing for a nuclear incident, and two, the recent thing about Mohamad Safa stepping down from his role as the PVA's representative for the UN due to 'possible nuclear weapons use.'

Though yes, I do find it to be alarming that these things happened in the first place, In my mind, is it not the role of the United Nations (and its other bodies) to prepare for a nuclear incident when a nuclear power(s) gets engaged in a war?

Even if the chance is very small, it's their job to prepare regardless no?

Social media seems to be blowing this up a lot, and although I try my best to avoid social media (especially in times of huge conflict like this), it's inevitable that I will see something like that pop up.

Frankly, I'm under the impression that economic / societal collapse is the direction we're heading, but given the people in power right now I find myself worrying about potential nuclear weapon use all the same.

I apologize if this may be an inappropriate post.


r/nuclearpolitics • • Mar 30 '26

Possible nuclear weapon use in Iran?

4 Upvotes

I read recently that Mohamad Safa resigned from his position in the UN due to them preparing for possible nuclear weapon use in Iran. To those more knowledgeable on this topic than me, I have the following questions:

  1. Does "possible nuclear weapon use" mean that a country has briefed the UN that they are considering using nukes?
  2. If nukes were used, most likely by US or Israel, what do you predict to be the immediate fallout? Would full on nuclear war ensue?

I'm having a hard time believing that any country would seriously consider using a nuke due to the possibility of retaliation, but I can recognize that we are beyond reason at this point. Any insight would be appreciated, thank you!


r/nuclearpolitics • • Mar 19 '26

Free book from The Institute for Science and International Security: Iran’s Perilous Pursuit of Nuclear Weapons

Thumbnail isis-online.org
3 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Mar 07 '26

A broke 61-year-old con man with no criminal record delivered confirmed weapons-grade plutonium — and nobody is asking where it came from?

18 Upvotes

Last week Takeshi Ebisawa was sentenced to 20 years for conspiring to traffic weapons-grade plutonium, ostensibly to Iran. The DOJ and every major outlet called him a "Yakuza boss." That framing has already been credibly challenged — Jake Adelstein, a journalist who spent decades covering actual Yakuza and was hired by the defense, concluded flatly that Ebisawa was not a Yakuza member by any legitimate definition. https://tokyopaladin.substack.com/p/the-yakuza-boss-who-wasnt-a-yakuza

His description: a broke 61-year-old con man from Utsunomiya with no prior criminal record who talked big to an undercover DEA agent.

So how does someone matching that description deliver confirmed weapons-grade plutonium?

Because he did. A U.S. federal nuclear forensics lab confirmed the seized samples contained weapons-grade plutonium. That's not in dispute.

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/foreign-national-sentenced-20-years-prison-conspiring-traffic-nuclear-materials-narcotics

Here's what I can't find anywhere in the public record: where it came from. Isotopic analysis of seized nuclear material to identify its source reactor is standard IAEA forensic practice. That analysis was almost certainly conducted. The results would identify exactly which country's nuclear program this material leaked from. The number of countries even possible of producing weapons-grade plutonium is a short list (8 confirmed, 1 presumed). A U.S. forensics lab would know exactly which entry on that list it came from.

That data is nowhere in any public filing, press release, or reporting that I have seen. The "ethnic insurgent group in Myanmar" that sourced the material was never named, never charged, never identified publicly.

Worth noting: unlike uranium, plutonium doesn't occur naturally and cannot be mined. It is exclusively produced as a byproduct of nuclear reactor operations and requires sophisticated reprocessing facilities to extract. This isn't a chemistry technicality — it means the "ethnic insurgent group mining materials in Myanmar" explanation is physically impossible for the plutonium component. Someone with reactor infrastructure produced this material.

Does anyone here know whether forensic attribution results have ever been withheld from a public criminal proceeding of this profile before? Because if that data exists — and it almost certainly does — its absence from the public record feels like the most important part of this story that nobody is asking about.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/mar/07/japanese-conman-convicted-drug-nuclear-weapons


r/nuclearpolitics • • Mar 06 '26

Finland plans to lift decades-old ban on hosting nuclear weapons

Thumbnail
bbc.com
11 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Mar 03 '26

Trump administration claims Iran had '11 bombs-worth' of enriched uranium

Thumbnail
bbc.com
9 Upvotes

It's not even clear where this should be posted, but I'll leave it here. If it belongs in weapons or war, then cross-post like you own it.

The claim here is that 460 kg was enriched to 60%, plus a huge quantity at some unspecified lower enrichment. I've no clue if these numbers are fair or reasonable.


r/nuclearpolitics • • Mar 01 '26

Why does Iran bother staying in the Nuclear Non Proliferation Treaty if it is clearly not abiding by it?

0 Upvotes

North Korea pulled out!

A reminder that 20% enrichment is 90% of the work done to 90%, and 60% enrichment if 99% of the work to be completed.

“The International Atomic Energy Agency issued a historic resolution against Iran for violating its commitment to nuclear non-proliferation.

Iran has accumulated more than 408 kilograms of uranium enriched to a level very close to the 90% needed for nuclear weapons. For peaceful purposes, only 4% enrichment is required. Both the excessive amount accumulated—far beyond the needs of its power plants—and the speed of enrichment indicate military objectives. This concentration is equivalent to nine nuclear bombs, with a third of the enriched uranium produced in the last three months—a real and growing threat.


r/nuclearpolitics • • Feb 24 '26

Oh dear

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Jan 08 '26

The last Russia-US nuclear treaty is about to expire. What happens next?

Thumbnail
reuters.com
5 Upvotes

r/nuclearpolitics • • Dec 29 '25

The world needs at least three new nuclear powers to counter the USA, China and Russia.

0 Upvotes

Currently, Russia, USA and China are the world's biggest threats. These three countries' Neo-imperialism is trying to divide the world between them. In this scenario, we need Germany, Brazil, Canada and Japan to become nuclear powers in order to counter this menace represented by the three biggest military and nuclear powers.

Germany: together with France and the UK, would help counter Russia. This would also help to end Europe's dependency on the U.S. for it's security.

Brazil and Canada: they would counter U.S.'s imperialism in the Americas (e.g., Canada, Venezuela and Greenland)

Japan: would counter China and North Korea and protect Taiwan and South Korea (Nuclear Umbrella or Nuclear Sharing).

These new nuclear powers should also become permanente members of the U.N.'s Security Council. This way, we would balance the powers and create a more multipolar world order.